Dr. Who

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
-9 is calling bullshit and saying that these new Daleks are human, and it made them crazy? I'm not trying to nitpick here, but this shit is hard to follow.

That was also a thing in "Daleks in New York." WTF was up with RTD and humanizing daleks?

-"And for my next Trick." I like the line, but they reused it in the 50th anniversary and hearing it now just made me realize I'm still pissed at Eccleston for not coming back for that. It actively made the show as a whole so much worse because he didn't.

So much this. If a time traveler could fix the 50th anniversary, we might reconsider killing all humans.

-Bad Wolf still has nothing to do with anything, quit trying to pretend that it does, fuck you.
-The conclusion to the "Bad Wolf" 'arc' is still fucking stupid, and it will never *not* be fucking stupid. Rose got infinite powers from the heart of the Tardis, and she chose to use those powers to scatter the words "Bad Wolf" all across space and time, for reasons that have had absolutely no real effect on the plot, except that we now know that it's something that "Infinite powers Rose" had on her mind. It means even less now than it did originally.

Ok good. I knew about the 9th's season but everything I looked up, I could never figure out what was up with "Bad Wolf." So it's just a dumb predestination paradox? It could have been "rabid badger" and still would have worked?

That was as much Moffat's fault as his. Paul McGann was RIGHT THERE, he even did a goddamn special for you, and instead they have to slot a whole new Doctor in instead of rolling the backup in the form of the fan favorite who never got a fair shot. Rest in piss, Moffat era.

If someone could get Paul McGann into the 50th, we will DEFINITELY cancel our kill all humans plan.

I can't really fault them for bringing in John Hurt as the "War Doctor" because come on it's John Hurt! But still I'd say they screwed up the obvious chance to have McCann come in and be a big presence.

I guess the guy can't be too mad since he's made a solid career just off Doctor Who audio dramas alone. And it feels like his tenure is going to outlive the reboot itself now since FemDoctor is a resounding failure.

I mean I get John Hurt - but like... why not make him the Gallifray general or another character? Heck I would have loved John Hurt as Rassilon (the old version, less this new "lolz evilz" version). Hell have him join the Doctor on the vision question instead of freakin' Rose. But the doc? If not #9, it should have been #8.
 
I mean I get John Hurt - but like... why not make him the Gallifray general or another character? Heck I would have loved John Hurt as Rassilon (the old version, less this new "lolz evilz" version). Hell have him join the Doctor on the vision question instead of freakin' Rose. But the doc? If not #9, it should have been #8.
I whole-heartedly agree. "The War Doctor" should have been 8, "The Moment" should have been Lucie bleedin' Miller, and 9 should have been in the 50th.
 
Series 1 is officially over but before I begin Series 2:

-9 is better than I gave him credit for being, and I do now genuinely wish we got more of him on screen. Thank heaven for Big Finish.
-Rose Tyler is a massive cunt and I think even less of her than I did before I started this re-watch. I had convinced myself that she didn't get *that* bad until Series 2, but that clearly wasn't the case.
-I originally had a lot more sympathy for Mickey Smith, but the dude's a willing cuck at this point. Also, if "Trisha Delaney" is even real, then Mickey is almost as shitty as Rose is for leading her on while still wanting Rose.
-I originally had a lot *less* sympathy for Jackie. True, she's literally just a 20 year older Rose, but nobody should treat their mother the way Rose treats Jackie, not even a braindead chavlet.
-"Bad Wolf" is not now, nor has it ever been anything even closely resembling a "plot arc". Future Spoiler: Neither is "Torchwood".
-van Staten did nothing wrong.

Alright, it's time for Christmas in July err.. August.

-So right away this is what I'm talking about with Jackie. She hasn't seen or heard anything from Rose in (presumably) months, and last she knew Rose was going off to do something extremely dangerous. When Rose comes out of the TARDIS, we don't see her even pretend to act happy to see her mum again. Very next scene she's sneering at her and telling her to shut up. Fuck you Rose Tyler.

-This is also the first (but by no means the last) example of 10 being a dick. He intentionally chose to come to Christmas Eve, rather than say... the same day Rose left, I'm sure that sounded like a cool idea in your head, but seriously poor Jackie.

-Poor dumb Ricky still comes running when he hears the TARDIS. You're on the job mate, they're going to fire your ass for running off like that. She isn't worth it.

-Jackie: What do you mean that's the Doctor? Doctor Who?

-Jackie: He's got 2 hearts? Anything else he's got 2 of?
Jackie's thirsty...

-Seems like 10 ate some garlic for dinner last night, and his stank breath is attracting... Somebody.

-All things considered, I like this scene where we see Rose and Jackie speculating about how 10's changed. I could have done without Rose asking her obviously horny mother about her sex life though. (Thankfully she gets quickly distracted by...)

-...MP Busybody who has now evolved into PM Busybody. And Jackie's bragging about getting paid "18 quid" more a week for some reason. I don't care enough to see what the exchange rate was in 2005, but that's only like $25 more a week in real money today. That's some British Golden Age.

-So this scene was really bad. Terrible CG just made it look like the unmanned space probe that PM Busybody was so proud of just got sucked into Mars's ass.
I was confused so I looked it up a plot synopsis, apparently it got sucked into the villain of the week's space ship. (I watched the scene back multiple times, the way they showed it still looks like the probe got sucked into Mars, or at very least a shitty asteroid.)
Whatever. Anyway, I find myself thinking... Why weren't the villains of this episode the Ice Warriors? I know they aren't the most popular Who villains (especially back then), and I admittedly wouldn't have recognized them at the time, but from what I remember (I haven't gotten there yet) the actual villains they use in this episode were kind of shit. If they were going to Mars anyway, might as well use some of the show's history.

-I'm sick of beating this dead horse, but Mickey just gave Rose 20 quid. She offered to pay him back and he declined- "Consider it Christmas present" (I'm sure she'll get you something real nice in return dude), but how the fuck was she planning to pay him back? She doesn't have a job. Or was she planning to steal Jackie's extra 18 quid?
I forget, did she know that the Doctor can basically just pull 'fuck you' money out of his ass like he did to give Adam a head vagina computer a few episodes back?

-This is a scene between two shitty people. Rose is basically telling Mickey how little anything outside of the TARDIS matters, and Ricky is being a passive aggressive bitch back to her. What else do you expect her to be talking about dude? And why did you still come running when you heard that landing sound?

-Rose: It must drive you mad. I'm surprised you don't give up on me.
I thought for sure that you'd both given up on eachother? I really do not understand how the relationship between these two characters works. It doesn't seem like it's healthy for either of them. (Which is probably why it doesn't last)

-So when I said I remember the villains of the week being shitty, I'll admit these weapon/trumpet playing Santas were a large part of that. One of them literally just got taken out by a Christmas tree that he shot down on himself.

-That stank breath is still nasty 10. Brush your damn teeth when you wake up.

-Lol, evil Christmas tree. That's another shitty villain I vaguely remembered from this episode.

-That scene where Rose hands catatonic 10 his sonic, whines "help me," and he sits up and blasts the tree was pretty neat. It's weird, it's only 11 minutes into the episode. I thought I remembered 10 being out of it for a lot longer than that, oh never mind he just fucked off again. Also shut the fuck up Jackie.

-Mickey is a cuck. Moving along.

-Oh no... the Human Race has just been shown absolute proof of alien life... Just like we were shown in the farting alien episode last year when a genuine UFO crashed into Big Ben, an "alien" was found in the wreckage (you never found out it was a fake), and 10 downing street was blown up like a day later. At least Moffat retconned this shit as not happening (I think O-o) when he took over.

-I get that it's a gag (and she did it before), but PM Busybody pulling out a card and saying "Harriet Jones, Prime Minister" to the fucking underling we saw her with earlier this episode is fucking retarded. Aaaand like most politicians, she's a liar to boot. Yes it's fair to say, I do not like Harriet Jones... But stay tuned, my ultimate opinion of her may surprise you.

-Random black general dude just says that "Martians look completely different", and fair enough because they do. But why weren't these guys just Ice Warriors?

-I like the continuity of Mickey still being able to hack into the government, but it's kind of sad that they never fixed that vulnerability that literally led to 10 downing street being hit by a missile launched by some unknown person through "hacking". It's been quite some time since then...

-I still don't believe that Harriet Jones would be a competent leader in real life, and I'll get to that, but... I like the bits where we see the top brass of the government, including her, acting to fight an alien threat without the Doctor readily able to help.

-*The translated Sycorax message to Earth*
Sycorax Strong
Sycorax Mighty
Sycorax Rock!
Me: Right on. I still think you guys are shit villains.

-Apparently 1/3 of the world's population are standing on the edge of buildings seemingly getting ready to jump.
Me: Do a flip!

-No. this is just dumb shit. Why would the UK just randomly send a sample of one of several (and I just googled it, A+ isn't even the most common blood type, that's apparently O+) blood types in their shitty random probe to Mars? Even if you didn't know that your probe was going to be intercepted by some other race with "blood magic" that's just retarded. This bald toady guy is an idiot.

-PM Busybody just said that the (entire?) royal family was on the roof (as in getting ready to jump as well), but I'm calling bullshit on that. I just googled your queen bongs, and her bloodtype is actually documented, and it isn't A+. It actually seems to be O+. and your royals are all so inbred that I doubt that many of them stray from her there either, although I obviously don't care enough to prove that.
Seriously though, imagine having a "royal family" in the current year. LOL.

-British PM Harriet Jones is openly begging "The Doctor" for help on live television. No, nothing ever comes from the Doctor being named by the Prime Minister on live television, not even after this episode.

-Lol... the busybody leader of Britbongistan thinks that she's "the leader of the world." The Sycorax are only even more pathetic for actually believing her in that regard.

-A Sycorax just removed his bone helmet and has an almost as stupid bone face under it.

-LMFAO stupid bald toady guy just got killed. LOL I didn't even finish typing that and random black general dude also just got killed.

-The joke where PM Busybody pulls out her ID card, and even the Sycorax knew who she was got a legit chuckle from me.

-Rose is *still* being a cunt to Jackie, and I don't like it. Aaaand... Jackie gets left behind again. LMFAO Rose wasn't looking and she got grabbed by a Sycorax.

-10 is still passed out, with stank breath.

-Rose is a retard, and she's just spouting out random shit she's heard over the last year in equally random order. She really is just a "wailing child" like bonehead calls her.

-I *love* it when 10 tells bonehead that he's busy.

-Why does the Doctor want to lose his soul by being a ginger?

-10 just quoted the Lion King 10. I actually really like the Lion King, but that joke wasn't funny.

-This scene where 10 challenges bonehead "for the planet" is pretty neat. Right on.

-10 just lost his hand, but I doubt that will ever come up again. It's cool though, he just burped up a new one.

This is where I rip off my own hand, so to speak, and tell this episode to go fuck itself, but give me a second.

-10 beat bonehead... But bonehead is a sore loser and tried to backstab him after the fact. So 10 killed bonehead outright, using a UK Christmas Orange that he found in the pocket of the pajamas he happened to be wearing at the time. (They foreshadowed that orange amazingly well, so no complaints here.)

-"No second chances." I honestly don't mind that creed myself, but it doesn't really sound all that Doctorly to me either. Let's see how long it takes for him to contradict this...

-10 just told the Sycorax that Earth is defended, and sure they *seem* to be accepting that they are defeated as they run away right now... But Jeez, didn't bonehead also just *seem* to accept that he was defeated until 10 turned his back on him? It's almost like these fuckers don't have any sense of honor at all, and could very well come back when 10 is gone.

-Also, 10 just literally told Harriet Jones that Earth is not necessarily safe from more attacks, like at all- after he was MIA for a large chunk of this episode.

-Right after this, PM Busybody's aide tells her that this mysterious "Torchwood" is ready, PM Busybody is *clearly* bothered by this, but still tells them to fire anyway, blowing up the Sycorax ship.

-Harriet Jones is still a shitty leader, but firing on the Sycorax ship was absolutely 100% the right call. 10 wholeheartedly agrees with this as well, after all, "No second chances." oh wait...

-...10 has the absolute gall to call shooting down the ship of a *clearly* still evil alien race that is *only* backing down because their honorless leader barely got beat in fair combat, (and still tried to backstab him after losing) "Murder". No, fuck you 10. What was the Earth supposed to do if you weren't here? It's a shame that this mysterious "Torchwood" never got its own show, and in the third series of that show didn't experience a retardedly similar alien menace to this episode, only with the Doctor nowhere to be found. Oh wait, Children of Earth was in fact a thing...

-10 unilaterally, and prematurely, ended "Britain's Golden Age" out of sheer fucking spite. And Harriet Jones didn't even do anything wrong. She was 100% correct here. Fuck you 10, this episode was a terrible first impression for me. I'm not surprised that I still like you a lot less than most people do.

Next episode has catlady nuns (and not even the sexy kind). Joy.

Edit: Fixed some spelling errors and reworded a few points.
 
Last edited:
Series 1 is officially over but before I begin Series 2:

-9 is better than I gave him credit for being, and I do now genuinely wish we got more of him on screen. Thank heaven for Big Finish.
-Rose Tyler is a massive cunt and I think even less of her than I did before I started this re-watch. I had convinced myself that she didn't get *that* bad until Series 2, but that clearly wasn't the case.
-I originally had a lot more sympathy for Mickey Smith, but the dude's a willing cuck at this point. Also, if "Trisha Delaney" is even real, then he's almost as bad as Rose is.
-I originally had a lot *less* sympathy for Jackie. True, she's literally just a 20 year older Rose, but nobody should treat their mother the way Rose treats Jackie, not even a braindead chavlet.
-"Bad Wolf" is not now, nor has it ever been anything even closely resembling a "plot arc". Future Spoiler: Neither is "Torchwood".
-van Staten did nothing wrong.

Alright, it's time for Christmas in July err.. August.

-So right away this is what I'm talking about with Jackie. She hasn't seen or heard anything from Rose in (presumably) months, and last she knew Rose was going off to do something extremely dangerous. And when Rose comes out of the TARDIS, we don't see her even pretend to act happy to see her again. Very next scene she's sneering at her and telling her to shut up. Fuck you Rose Tyler.

-This is also the first (but by no means the last) example of 10 being a dick. He intentionally chose to come to Christmas Eve, rather than say... the same day Rose left, I'm sure that sounded like a cool idea in your head, but seriously poor Jackie.

-Poor dumb Ricky still comes running when he hears the TARDIS. You're on the job mate, they're going to fire your ass for running off like that. She isn't worth it.

-Jackie: What do you mean that's the Doctor? Doctor Who?

-Jackie: He's got 2 hearts? Anything else he's got 2 of?
Jackie's thirsty...

-Seems like 10 ate some garlic for dinner last night, and his stank breath is attracting... Somebody.

-All things considered, I like this scene where we see Rose and Jackie speculating about how 10's changed. I could have done without Rose asking her obviously horny mother about her sex life though. (Thankfully she gets quickly distracted by...)

-...MP Busybody who is now PM Busybody. And Jackie's bragging about getting paid "18 quid" more a week for some reason. I don't care enough to see what the exchange rate was in 2005, but that's only like $25 more a week in real money today. That's some British Golden Age.

-Right, so this scene was really bad. Terrible CG just made it look like the unmanned space probe that PM Busybody was so proud of just got sucked into Mars.
I was confused so I looked it up, and apparently it got sucked into the villain of the week's space ship. (I watched the scene back multiple times, it still looks like the probe got sucked into Mars, or at very least a shitty asteroid.)
Whatever. Anyway, I find myself thinking... Why weren't the villains of this episode the Ice Warriors? I know they aren't the most popular Who villains (especially back then), and I admittedly wouldn't have recognized them at the time, but from what I remember (I haven't gotten there yet) the actual villains they use in this episode were kind of shit. If they were going to Mars anyway, might as well use some of the show's history.

-I'm sick of beating this dead horse, but Mickey just gave Rose 20 quid. She offered to pay him back and he declined- "Consider it Christmas present" (I'm sure she'll get you something real nice in return dude), but how the fuck was she planning to pay him back? She doesn't have a job. Or was she planning to steal Jackie's extra 18 quid?
I forget, did she know that the Doctor can basically just pull 'fuck you' money out of his ass like he did to give Adam a head vagina computer a few episodes back?

-This is a scene between two shitty people. Rose is basically telling Mickey how little anything outside of the TARDIS matters, and Ricky is being a passive aggressive bitch. What else do you expect her to be talking about dude? And why did you still come running when you heard that landing sound?

-Rose: It must drive you mad. I'm surprised you don't give up on me.
I thought for sure that you'd both given up on eachother? I really do not understand how the relationship between these two characters works. It doesn't seem like it's healthy for either of them. (Which is probably why it doesn't last)

-So when I said I remember the villains of the week being shitty, I'll admit these weapon/trumpet playing Santas were a large part of that. One of them literally just got taken out by a Christmas tree that he shot down on himself.

-That stank breath is still nasty 10. Brush your damn teeth when you wake up.

-Lol, evil Christmas tree. That's another shitty villain I vaguely remembered from this episode.

-That scene where Rose hands catatonic 10 his sonic, whines "help me," and he sits up and blasts the tree was pretty neat. It's weird, it's only 11 minutes into the episode. I thought I remembered 10 being out of it for a lot longer than that, oh never mind he just fucked off again. Also shut the fuck up Jackie.

-Mickey is a cuck. Moving along.

-Oh no... the Human Race has just been shown absolute proof of alien life... Just like we were shown in the farting alien episode last year when a genuine UFO crashed into Big Ben, an "alien" was found in the wreckage (you never found out it was a fake), and 10 downing street was blown up like a day later. At least Moffat retconned this shit as not happening (I think O-o) when he took over.

-I get that it's a gag (and she did it before), but PM Busybody pulling out a card and saying "Harriet Jones, Prime Minister" to the fucking underling we saw her with earlier this episode even is fucking retarded. Aaaand like most politicians, she's a liar to boot. Yes it's fair to say, I do not like Harriet Jones... But stay tuned, my ultimate opinion of her may surprise you.

-Random black general dude just says that "Martians" look completely different, and fair enough because they do. But why weren't these just Ice Warriors?

-I like the continuity of Mickey still being able to hack into the government, but it's kind of sad that they never fixed that vulnerability that literally led to 10 downing street being hit by a missile launched by some unknown person through "hacking". It's been quite some time since then...

-I still don't believe that Harriet Jones would be a competent leader in real life, and I'll get to that, but... I like the bits where we see the top brass of the government, including her, acting to fight an alien threat without the Doctor readily able to help.

-*The translated Sycorax message to Earth*
Sycorax Strong
Sycorax Mighty
Sycorax Rock!
Me: Right on. I still think you guys are shit villains.

-Apparently 1/3 of the world's population are standing on the edge of buildings seemingly getting ready to jump.
Me: Do a flip!

-No. this is just dumb shit. Why would the UK just randomly send a sample of one of several (and I just googled it, A+ isn't even the most common blood type, that's apparently O+) blood types in their shitty random probe to Mars? Even if you didn't know that your probe was going to be intercepted by some other race with "blood magic" that's just retarded. This bald toady guy is an idiot.

-PM Busybody just said that the (entire?) royal family was on the roof (as in getting ready to jump as well), but I'm calling bullshit on that. I just googled your queen bongs, and her bloodtype is actually documented, and it isn't A+. It actually seems to be O+. and your royals are all so inbred that I doubt that many of them stray from her there either, although I obviously don't care enough to prove that.
Seriously though, imagine having a "royal family" in the current year. LOL.

-British PM Harriet Jones is openly begging "The Doctor" for help on live television. No, nothing ever comes from this, not even after this episode.

-Lol... the busybody leader of Britbongistan thinks that she's "the leader of the world." The Sycorax are only even more pathetic for actually believing her in that regard.

-A Sycorax just removed his bone helmet and has an almost as stupid bone face.

-LMFAO stupid bald toady guy just got killed. LOL I didn't even finish typing that and random black general dude also just got killed.

-The joke where PM Busybody pulls out her ID card, and even the Sycorax knew who she was got a legit chuckle from me.

-Rose is *still* being a cunt to Jackie, and I don't like it. Aaaand... Jackie gets left behind again. LMFAO Rose wasn't looking and she got grabbed by a Sycorax.

-10 is still passed out, with stank breath.

-Rose is a retard, and she's just spouting out random shit she's heard over the last year in equally random order. She really is just a "wailing child" like bonehead calls her.

-I *love* it when 10 tells bonehead that he's busy.

-Why does the Doctor want to lose his soul by being a ginger?

-You just quoted the Lion King 10. I actually like the Lion King, but that joke wasn't funny.

-This scene where 10 challenges bonehead "for the planet" is pretty neat. Right on.

-!0 just lost his hand, but I doubt that will ever come up again. It's cool though, he just burped up a new one.

This is where I rip off my own hand, so to speak, and tell this episode to go fuck itself, but give me a second.

-10 beat bonehead... But bonehead is a sore loser and tried to backstab him after the fact. So 10 killed bonehead outright, using a UK Christmas Orange that he found in the pocket of the pajamas he happened to be wearing at the time. (They foreshadowed that amazingly well, so no complaints here.)

-"No second chances." I honestly don't mind that creed myself, but it doesn't really sound all that Doctorly to me either. Let's see how long it takes for him to contradict this...

-10 just told the Sycorax that Earth is defended, and sure they *seem* to be accepting that they are defeated as they run away right now... But Jeez, didn't bonehead also just *seem* to accept that he was defeated until 10 turned his back on him? It's almost like these fuckers don't actually have any sense of honor at all, and could very well come back when 10 is gone.

-Also, 10 just literally told Harriet Jones that Earth is *not*necessarily safe from more attacks, like at all- after he was MIA for a large chunk of this episode.

-Right after this, PM Busybody's aide tells her that this mysterious "Torchwood is ready", and PM Busybody is *clearly* bothered by this, but still tells them to "fire" anyway, blowing up the Sycorax ship.

-Harriet Jones is still a shitty leader, but firing on the Sycorax ship was absolutely 100% the right call.

-10 has the absolute gall to call shooting down the ship of a *clearly* still evil alien race that is *only* backing down because their honorless leader barely got beat in fair combat, (and still tried to backstab him after losing) "Murder". No, fuck you 10. What was the Earth supposed to do if you weren't here? It's a shame that this mysterious "Torchwood" never got its own show, and in the third series of that show didn't experience a retardedly similar alien menace to this episode, only with the Doctor nowhere to be found. Oh wait, Children of Earth was in fact a thing...

-10 unilaterally, and prematurely, ended "Britain's Golden Age" out of sheer fucking spite. And Harriet Jones didn't even do anything wrong. She was 100% correct here. Fuck you 10, this episode was a terrible first impression for me. I'm not surprised that I still like you a lot less than most people do.

Next episode has catlady nuns. Joy.
Don't worry, 10 being a cunt has a pay-off IIRC.
 
Heck I would have loved John Hurt as Rassilon (the old version, less this new "lolz evilz" version). Hell have him join the Doctor on the vision question instead of freakin' Rose. But the doc? If not #9, it should have been #8.

Whatever else was wrong with The End of Time, Timothy Dalton as Rassilon was magificent. You could really believe that the Time Lords, driven to desperation by the Daleks would reach back through time to a man like that to save them.
 
Whatever else was wrong with The End of Time, Timothy Dalton as Rassilon was magificent. You could really believe that the Time Lords, driven to desperation by the Daleks would reach back through time to a man like that to save them.
Nothing against Timothy Dalton, even his regeneration being the way it is can work. It just bugs me that that is now ALL the versions we see of Rassilon.

He is good though and it is satisfying to watch him bitch slap the Master.
 
Glad to see @UnKillFill's review are back. Someone wanted a review of Resurrection of the Daleks and I volunteered because against all conventional wisdom I actually like that story, so here it is:

Is this Resurrection of the Daleks or Invasion of the Space Hobos?

Oh man, police brutality’s off the scale here #SpaceHoboLivesMatter

Aw, they killed actual hobo too? Is no-one safe?

Hey neat, it’s Rodney Bewes, star of The Likely Lads, Whatever Happened to the Likely Lads? and the question: “Whatever Happened to Rodney Bewes?”.

That is a craptastic spaceship, even for classic Who. Looks like something I’d make out of an egg box. Dalek fly around in saucers not whatever the hell this is:

1.png

This story takes place after Frontios where the Tardis gets blowed up real good. Can’t remember if this shit with the time corridor is a lead in from that.

Janet Fielding looks great in that outfit even if she looks like she should be asking if you’re looking for a good time on street corners.

Rodney Bewes keeps calling for his friend even after he hears the machine gun fire. Dumbass

Lytton said nothing anachronistic is to be brought to Earth, but they just transmatted a Dalek trooper in there for a clean up.

In the DVD commentary the actors commented about how the outfits the station staff wore in this story looked like something workers would wear at McDonald’s and now I can’t unsee it.

Oh yeah, Rula Lenska’s in this one too. I love how JNT would take comedy actors and have them play hardasses.

More crap model shots. This one’s literally just a still image with some bad laser effects overlayed.

Rula Lenska’s basically Beryl Reid from Earthshock all over again.

Hehe, this shot looks kind of dirty:

2.png

“The cruiser’s docked?”
“The cruiser’s docked!”
Sorry, could you say that again? I didn’t get it the first time.

Rodney Bewes: “Have you got anything to eat?”
Me: “Yes, this Doctor literally has a vegetable on his collar for no discernible reason. It’s a bit manky, but it’ll do if you’re starving.”

The Dalek Trooper helmets walk the line between kino and cheesy. For me they lean slightly more towards kino, but the giant dildo on the forehead looks very silly.

Oh, this is one of those episodes where they could only afford so many laser effects so most of the guns are just LEDs of doom.

Lytton: “Your battle tactics won’t work, their position is too strong”
They literally had to pull the bulkhead down with their bare hands and then make a barrier out of junk they had lying around. I know the whole point is the Daleks are much weaker in this time period, but goddamn that’s pathetic.

This is one of the few Dalek episodes that doesn’t feature Roy Skelton as a Dalek voice artist. The voices in this episode are provided by Royce Mills and Brian Miller (aka Mr Elisabeth Sladen). Royce Mills delivers a subdued, creepy performance, but Brian Miller is too ranty for my liking, even for a Dalek. Still leagues better than the bozos they had in Day of the Daleks.

So Lytton’s grand strategy for taking over the station was just to gas them. I’ll bet that one really got the noggin joggin. Also, why do only some of the station staff have gas masks? Do the proles not get them?

Convenient the Davros kill switch doesn’t work.

This story is literally just Earthshock all over again. The Doctor bumbles into a military operation on earth, while other shenanigans are going on in space. Only difference is you don’t get the shock of seeing his old enemies show up again because it’s in the title and they appear with virtually no fanfare. We’ve got the megabitch station commander, the no nonsense military captain, the hapless scientist and the antagonists trying to carry out a covert operation which only ends up drawing more attention to what they’re up to.

The Daleks are downright nasty in this one. It’s been a while since we’ve seen them gun down this many people in cold blood.

How the fuck did that Dalek not see Turlough? He’s not even trying to hide.

“What’s that smell?”
“Well it can’t be the prisoner.”
Was that a fart joke?

Ahaha some of the death scenes in this episode are fucking hilarious. Shame that dishy Indian girl had to die.

Why are the machine guns firing tissue paper?

Bahahaha best Dalek destruction ever. Who’d have thought defenestration would be so effective?

3qRpoTv.gif


Dalek: “The Dalek that was sent to the warehouse has been destroyed”
Supreme Dalek: “How is that possible?”
Apparently a three storey fall is all it takes.

More blind Daleks. Even with their eyestalks they’re fucking useless. How did you not notice a mangy ginger sneaking around your ship?

Davros: “You speak as though my Daleks are no longer capable of war.”
Well they were forced to retreat by the graveyard shift staff of space McDonald’s, so yeah, they aren’t.

Turlough discovers the Daleks have a bubble wrap fetish.

I forgot the Doctor gets trigger happy again in this episode. Get fucked with that “I never would” shit Ten.

Doctor: “I must find Turlough”
Must you though?

It’s painfully obvious the guy getting throttled by the Dalek mutant is doing all the puppeteering.

Is the military captain really using a payphone to try and communicate with his superiors? What kind of Mickey Mouse military operation is this? Actually what am I saying? This is Britfagistan.

Ooh, Leslie Grantham’s in this one too. They’re really rolling out the starpower. Assuming that by “starpower” you mean C and D-List TV stars of yore and convicted murderers.

Davros: “Two totally logical war machines unable to outthink each other? Fascinating!”
Yeah, you were presented with this exact same problem in Destiny of the Daleks. Y’know, the Dalek story immediately before this one.

Davros: “This time they will not abuse me!”
Show me on the doll where the Dalek touched you.

The Doctor’s nicked the PissedOffVideoGamer’s stick:

3.png

That poor soldier has the worst luck. That’s the second time he’s had a lovebite from the same Dalek mutant. Apparently it won’t take no for an answer.

The space McDonald’s workers have used the Stormtrooper strategy from A New Hope.

Davros: “90 years I was frozen in that! 90 years of mind numbing boredom!”
Davros just perfectly described the experience of watching Series 11 and 12 of NuWho.

Soldier: “Anyone want some tea?”
So fucking British.

Haha, Lytton actually uses the giant dildo on the Dalek helmet to remove it. Neat.

Oh no! Rodney Bewes is evil! Whoda thunk it?


Lytton: “They kill anybody, even if they need them.”
Rodney Bewes: “How long before it’s your turn?”
Damn that’s a good line.

Turlough is told they’re standing outside a self-destruct chamber and then asks what they’re going to do when they go inside. Rula Lenska is right to call him a dumbass.

“Would anyone like some tea?”
That’s the second time it’s been offered in a crisis. Again, so fucking British.

Why are the Daleks just letting the Doctor wander round the duplication chamber willy nilly? Restrain the fucker! He could’ve disabled half the equipment by now you morons (actually, why didn't he?).

“The Daleks are very capable of devising painful and undignified ways of dying.”
What, like being blinded and pushed out of a window?

Love the “You fucking moron” look the Dalek gives Rodney Bewes when he lets slip Davros is there:

4.png

Why have the Daleks suddenly forgotten about the fuckface gas from the initial attack? Surely they could just pipe that into the self-destruct chamber and be home free.

Lytton makes his troops take out the CCTV camera after they’ve been spotted. Fat load of good that’ll do now.

The Daleks have a nearly complete set of TARDIS team action figures and just need the Doctor to complete their collection.

Maybe I missed it, but why does Davros have to stay on the station? Is that really the only laboratory they could find for him? I’m pressing x to doubt.

Oh whoops, Rodney Bewes has become Michael Palin’s character from A Fish Called Wanda.

*Self-destruct opens*
Rula Lenska: “Why am I so excited? This is the last thing I’ll ever do.”
Whoa. 2deep4me.

I’m impressed Tegan’s outrunning the policemen in high heels.

This episode doesn’t take any prisoners. First the hobo gets gunned down in cold blood, now some poor old coot metal detecting.

Nooooo! Rula Lenska’s dead. Will the other celebrity guests survive this episode?

That scientist lady screamed too much for my liking. Thank fuck she’s gone.

I like Terry Molloy as Davros, but he doesn’t half rant in this story.

Do the corridors on the Dalek ship have a perception filter or something? How did Turlough miss the fucking TARDIS right next to him?

Good thing Rodney Bewes shut off the duplication machine. The Doctor could’ve remembered the Morbius Doctors again (I am not calling them the Timeless Child Doctors, fuck that shit).

Supreme Dalek: “The Doctor is free! Your troopers have failed!”
Lytton: “More to the point, where were your Daleks?”
Oh snap.

The Dalek troopers look utterly bored while they’re being tied to the tables. They don’t even try to fight back. Maybe they’re into that.

So the Daleks put the Movellan virus on Earth because it was safer there? Again, I’m pressing x to doubt. They have the whole universe to choose from.

The Daleks went to all this trouble to get hold of Davros to try and cure the Movellan virus only to get rid of him? I know he’s a slippery fuck, but all the Daleks need to do is kill everyone loyal to him and he’s fucked again.

Davros: “You will pay tenfold for the agony I suffered!”
No Davros! Don’t show him a preview of Series 13! That’s too cruel even for you!

Oh man, the black dude just got gunned down. That was a wasted character arc if ever there was one.

Davros is handing out love eggs now. I don’t like where this is going:

5.png

These soldiers/Dalek duplicates are fucking morons. How do you let yourself get flanked by a slow moving pepperpot?

More cheesy death scenes. Fun fact: this episode has a higher body count than The Terminator.

Leslie Grantham’s dead too? Nah, he’ll be back, he always comes back. You can’t kill Dirty Den.

I can’t explain to non-Britfags how amusing it is to see Rodney Bewes trying to be an action hero. You just kind of have to know the context.

I can’t believe the Daleks left two guys guarding the self-destruct chamber and didn’t try to disable the mechanism or lock it down some other way.

“I told you she could start an epidemic if she released the virus!”
So Tegan was behind the Covid-19 outbreak. Huh, that actually makes a lot of sense.

Ew, the love eggs are doing their job a little too well. Spunk everywhere:

6.png

I’m sorry...

Jesus Lytton. No need to gun down one of your own men just because. Quite enough people have died this episode.

Lol Davros gets owned by racial purity once again.

Supreme Dalek: “I have my duplicates. Some have already been placed in strategic positions around the planet! The collapse of Earth society will soon occur!”
There’s four minutes left and now this plot point’s coming out of left field. I guess I should be grateful though. If this were done today, there’d be a Trump/Boris joke right about now.

Blimey, Rodney Bewes is indestructible. He survived an LED of death and a direct hit from a Dalek. I bet even after the self-destruct goes off he’s still floating in space lamenting that his co-star won’t allow reruns of his old show.

Lytton lives to Die Another Day.

Tegan’s departure would’ve been really moving if it had been given a little more build up and time to breathe. It feels a bit sudden as is.

“Doctor I will miss you.”

Don’t worry love, you’ll meet again. Big Finish will make sure of it.

Like I say, I do like this story, but I'm not blind to its myriad flaws. The story/plot are terrible if you think about them for more than a few seconds, there's too many plot threads which go nowhere, the supporting cast are practically all ciphers and as I set out above, the whole thing is an inferior rerun of Earthshock without any of that story's saving graces.

That said, it's got some of the best Dalek action in the entire Classic Series, the Daleks themselves look great after their tatty appearance in Destiny (I love the Supreme Dalek's black and white livery), Terry Molloy is always welcome in a story (even if this isn't his best showing), Maurice Colbourne does a great job as Lytton (one of Classic Who's best guest characters) and despite all my jokes at his expense, Rodney Bewes turns in a surprisingly good performance, especially when he has to play against type.

I was going to do Destiny of the Daleks for my next review, but on reflection I think I'll do Attack of Cybermen, a story that shares many similarities with this one (and is in some ways a quasi-sequel), but with the important difference I don't like it. Hopefully I can explain why it fails for me where Resurrection succeeds.
 
What's you guys' most hated line from modern Who?

Call me autistic but I cannot stand Ten's 'I'm burning up a sun just to say goodbye :'('
 
What's you guys' most hated line from modern Who?

Call me autistic but I cannot stand Ten's 'I'm burning up a sun just to say goodbye :'('
I'd have to stick the entire script for "The Timeless Children" in here to answer that question.

Oh wait, thanks to "Attach files", I can actually do that.

Giving a non-facetious answer, tough call, but I'd say Ten's "I don't want to go". Didn't think it was possible for something to top "Carrot juice" as the worst pre-regeneration line.

That or 12's "Didn't you used to be a man?"
"I got an upgrade" exchange.
 

Attachments

What's you guys' most hated line from modern Who?

Call me autistic but I cannot stand Ten's 'I'm burning up a sun just to say goodbye :'('
Any bad ass line that's repeated.

Like I like #11, but even I got a bit annoyed with every other episode him shilling himself. "Basically, run" in the first episode is pretty good. "RUN!" In the doctor's wife is annoying.
 
Everything Immortal Arya says.

That character is on my Mt. Rushmore of "Characters who actively made their setting worse."
Fun fact: I had no idea who the actress was when the episode aired, and I also had no idea why the special effects were so Buffy-tier. Turns out that the two facts were connected apparently.

Though Ashildr/Me redeemed herself a bit in my eyes by calling out the Doctor (and by extension Moffat) on his BS refusal to let Clara go. As terrible as the character was, that was cathartic- basically all the catharsis we got from the retarded "muh hybrid" non-story.
 
What's you guys' most hated line from modern Who?

Call me autistic but I cannot stand Ten's 'I'm burning up a sun just to say goodbye :'('
10’s “I don’t want to go” line. Also “Don’t you think she looks tired?” I hated his treatment of Harriet Jones in The Christmas Invasion. For all her faults blowing the ship up was the right call.

Honestly a lot of dialogue from his era would count. Maybe I am just being harsh since I got into the series during 11’s run and Moffat derangement syndrome was out full force while Davies was praised as some progressive hero. I honestly don’t care about Moffat or what he thinks and does but people getting angry every time he breathed was tiresome. It stopped being fun hanging out with friends because of that.
 
Last edited:
I was going to do Destiny of the Daleks for my next review, but on reflection I think I'll do Attack of Cybermen, a story that shares many similarities with this one (and is in some ways a quasi-sequel), but with the important difference I don't like it.
Massive sped Who fan Ian Levine claims he came up with the story for Attack. He has short thread here.
 
Uh so yeah... New Earth.

This episode begins with Rose trying to convince two people who somehow seem to still her (and who if history is anything to go by, won't be seeing her again for at minimum several months later their time, if only a few days for her) that she also cares about them. I'm pressing X to doubt that one, show don't tell RTD.

-All this while 10 whimsically presses random buttons, turns random knobs on the Tardis console, and smiles. This is a man who, I will say again, just pre-maturely aborted "Britain's Golden Age" out of sheer fucking spite the very last time we saw him. Talk about tonal whiplash.

-I don't know what this sad look Ricky gives Rose as she leaves him behind yet again is supposed to be, but it's really fucking pathetic.
ricky.png


-Rose: Where are we going?
10: Further than we've ever gone before!
Me: Well yeah, I guess that's technically true, but it's only like 10 minutes later into the future than your first trip where the Earth blew up.

-Rose: What's that smell?

-Rose just referred to that episode where Earth blew up as "Our first date." I'm getting sick of bitching about this, because it's beyond a dead horse at this point. (And we all know where it's going anyway.) But bitch... Literally 5 minutes ago you were kissing Ricky and telling him that you loved him. I'm not saying you have to keep dating the the dude, quite the opposite in fact, but for the love of Pete (you know, your dad) just let the poor wanker go. Maybe he can still catch Trisha Delaney on the rebound. I guess he still inexplicably ends up with Marfa, a major upgrade from Rose for him, even if it's a major downgrade for Marfa.

-I was half joking when I said that this episode takes place 10 minutes later than "The End of the World," If I'm understanding things correctly, that one took place in exactly the year 5,000,000,000 and this one takes place in 5,000,000,023. Relatively speaking, I was still right though. The Doctor just said that they created this entire world in those 23 years, which is just ridiculous.

-This city is called "New New York" (Or more specifically the 15th New York, but I'm not typing it out that many times.) I know that the original York is in BritBongistan, but let's be honest nobody gives a shit about 'Old' York these days. I find it interesting that this isn't "The 15th New London" or whatever. (N)USA Number One!

-I always get this episode mixed up with the one where 10 and Marfa come back here and get stuck in generational traffic because of shitty versions of the Macra or something, but nah today we get (amazingly un-sexy) cat girl nuns, the return of the tran-poline, body swapping, and zombies. (And that's just the stuff I remember off the top of my head!)

-10: "The human race lives on, but so do viruses."
Me: Topical!

-Holy shit, is that blue humongously fat fuck the same character who gets his head cut off later in Moffat's run?
Duke_of_Manhattan.jpg
Dorium_close_up_(AGMGTW).jpg

I paused to look it up, but I shouldn't have bothered. Different characters and actors. This one isn't even blue he's just turning to stone. They're both still alarmingly fat fucks though.

-"The face of Boe is dying."
See, now this is why I say this thing can't be Jack. The other stuff- somehow being a massive freaky head in a jar, being millions of years old, singing to people telepathically, even getting pregnant at some point in time, are all things I wouldn't put past Jack... but he literally can't die.

-I want to call bullshit on tran-poline surviving her last appearance, but that "talking out your ass" joke made me laugh, so I'll allow it.

-Cassandra(in Rose's body): Oh my god, I'm a chav!
Me: That's probably the most honest thing Rose Tyler('s body) has said since the show started.

-Aw dammit, this isn't a body swap story at all. It would have been karmic justice for Rose Tyler to have been stuck as a rapidly de-hydrating flap of (ass)flesh if only for a little while, but no RTD had to crap out and make it a boring possession story instead.

-It is hilarious how long it takes 10 to realize that Rose is acting like a selfish and uncaring evil cunt. It's almost like there isn't much of a change at all.
:thinking:

-10: These people are dying, and Rose would care.
Me: Eh maybe she would a little bit. TBH though, Cassandra has been acting more or less how I'd expect Rose to act in this situation. If she didn't kiss you, and talk like a hilarious caricature, I would accuse you of only noticing the difference because you read the script in advance.

-Uh oh 10 just got outsmarted by somebody significantly dumber than him. (Especially if you count Cassandra as being limited by Rose's physical brain.) So much for 10 being any better at this than 9 was.

-Ok no, fuck you cat girl nuns. You're retarded. Every SINGLE door on this floor of the facility opened when one person (with no credentials to even be in here) pulled one single lever, letting out dozens of zombies at once. Even if you knew for a fact that these bodies were essentially corpses (and you didn't, we saw that earlier) you're still exposing every single virus ever to open air and contamination. Forget not letting them touch you, everyone in that room has every airborne virus ever now, and it's probably going to spread planetwide.

-Ditto for designing this facility so that smashing one single electrical panel automatically opens every door on every other floor. There's also some bullshit reason why all of these corpses are speaking perfect English and walking about when they've lived their entire lives inside tubes, but the noise of my head banging repeatedly against the wall drowned it out, so I'm sorry I couldn't tell you.

-Well at least they have some fucking way to quarantine this building... but let's be honest, there's probably one single red button somewhere in some easily accessible location that opens all the doors and lets the zombies out into the world, and they all probably know exactly where it is because they "were in the machine." Fuck this episode.

-Billie Piper does a better job of acting possessed by Cassandra than Tennant does. A much better job.

-If 10's plan is even remotely close to what I think it is, I'm going to be so pissed. If I'm wrong you probably won't even be reading this, lol.

-Ok yeah I'm pissed. This was even dumber than I guessed/remembered. I was expecting 10 to use those bags of magic cure fluid to make the building's sprinkler system somehow spray every zombie at once... (Which for the record *still* would have been really fucking dumb.) But I somehow managed to over-estimate this episode spectacularly. 10 just used the elevator's auto disinfectant system (which to be fair was set up pretty well in a funny scene earlier that I forgot to mention) to spray himself, and like 5 other zombies, who were all *instantly* cured. So then 10 shriekes "PASS IT ON, PASS IT ON!" And all 5 of those cured zombies decided to stop trying to touch 10, and go back and touch all the other zombies instead... This is some how enough to cure every single zombie that those 5ish zombies touch, and presumably every zombie touched by them, and so on.

-If it was *this* easy to cure these people, than those fucking incompetent cat nuns had *NO* excuse for not keeping the "not people" in a state of at least relative health to begin with. Even if they didn't think that they're actual people, and would just stand there without any consciousness - (even though we saw that wasn't true) that would still have minimized the chance of an outbreak if... say, some random retard breaks in and pulls a single lever and then smashes a single panel, releasing every virus out to the world.

"Everybody lives 2.0" this is not. Even though it was clearly trying to be that.

-10 has a (half psychic) chat with the Face of Boe, and this *really* doesn't sound anything at all like Captain Jack. I guess you could say that he changed his voice as well, why not since he changed everything else about himself if that's actually him. But why bother at this point? Also he still can't die.

-The face of Boe: I have to go now, My planet needs me. -teleports away-
Note: The Face of Boe *didn't* die on the way back to his own planet. (But he did just now say that he'll die next time we see him.)

-I feel like Cassandra probably should have just jumped into the Duke of Manhattan's posh attendant lady in relative safety. (She jumped into Rose to help the Doctor heal the zombies instead... for some reason.)

-Cassandra/Rose: "I don't want to die".
Me: I'll bet 10 will *never* deliver a line similar to that. Not even *long* after we all want him to 'go'.

-This ending made me kind of sad... 10 brought Cassandra (while possessing the dying body of her "favorite pattern," 'Chip') back to see herself in the past while she was still human, specifically to the last time anyone ever told her that she was beautiful... so that Cassandra could be the very person to tell herself that she was beautiful, and then die... I'm assuming paradoxicly making 'Chip' her favorite pattern in the first place.

The ending aside, this episode was shit. Easily the worst I've seen so far in this rewatch so far. (Although I have a feeling I'm going to be saying that several more times over the course of this series.)


So yeah, "New Earth" definitely pissed me off more than any episode of Nu Who has so far... But I just watched the preview of the next episode. It's the "Werewolves of Victorian London" episode, and let me tell you- I am not amused.
 
Can I get in on these reviews? I've a real hankering to do one having enjoyed Unkillphil's write-ups. I can do something from Classic Who to avoid overlaps, any suggestions? I have some of the old ones like Caves of Androzani, City of Death, The Romans, Web of Fear on old DVD. And can probably track down some of the others.

Am currently thinking maybe The Sea Devils or The Croutons. What do people think and would they enjoy a review?
 
Can I get in on these reviews? I've a real hankering to do one having enjoyed Unkillphil's write-ups. I can do something from Classic Who to avoid overlaps, any suggestions? I have some of the old ones like Caves of Androzani, City of Death, The Romans, Web of Fear on old DVD. And can probably track down some of the others.

Am currently thinking maybe The Sea Devils or The Croutons. What do people think and would they enjoy a review?

Sea Devils, please. Three's my favourite Doctor.
 
Back
Top Bottom