Replied portions are bolded
Agreed. Unless I'm mistaken, Emet never actually tells you what exactly Zodiark did to save the "star" ¹ yet he can certainly tell you the (potentially one of many) things Hydaelyn did to (in his words) basically fuck everyone over right along with Zodiark.
It is implied that Zodiark with his godly powers stopped the catastrophe we saw in the last 4.0 dungeon. I don't think we need to really explain the exact details similar to how Louisaix stopped the calamity between 1.X and 2.0. Sure the finer details of that are relevant, but we don't need the exact details. Considering Hydaelyn in her weakended state can stop the purge of light on The 1st, Zodiark being able at his arguable peak stop the end of the world and using Amourat tech repair everything overtime before the world gets broken in 14 isn't that far fetched.
Funny how getting some answers (even if possibly just half-truths) raises questions you never even had before above so many other longstanding issues in terms of urgency, isn't it? Or at least that's where I'm at with it.
and
Do you suppose anyone actually does truly know? I'd suspect that crystal cat and word salad elf may have at least some answers they're choosing not to share, but..I guess I find myself doubting that anyone alive (that we know of so far..perhaps on another Shard?) knows jack shit about Hydaelyn.
The main question I have is why the fuck Hydaelyn refuses to comment on anything? She could have communicated any of this back in HW and she didn't, she just tries to misdirect it towards vague shit like "Zodiark bad, we must stop bad" while ignoring everything else. Like she can't be this oblivious to what is going on, why she refuses to explain any sort of truth or tell us anything is bordering on infuriating. I try to immerse myself in this story and try to sort of put myself in the WoL's shoes and deattach myself from reality into this game, because role playing is fun when it is actual role playing. I'm about ready to quit being the Warrior of Anything until this crystaline bitch explains literally anything.
For the longest time I thought that 3.4's revelations with the Warriors of Darkness meant that light and darkness are in this eternal clash and tipping one too far off causes a catastrophic imbalance, because presumably if the 1st can become this pure light hellzone, why can't The Source? Turns out that isn't really likely to happen because the reason these things happen go beyond just "Light and Dark must be in balance" it goes on meddling on a dramatic scale across multi deminsions by a legion of dark wizard 4D chess masters. So what the fuck? It feels so manipulative to me how vaguely she explains anything. I know she's weak and stuff, but come on.
My friend and I have wracked our brains on that one. If Hydaelyn is the planet we live on..the Source..is that name merely ceremonious? No one has ever referred to Hydaelyn as a planet that we could find at all, yet Emet references the "star" his people lived on constantly. Is the Source and Shards what's left of Emet's star? Or is it merely just some FF word fuckery, you think? Or..?
You can blame Midgardsormr for this fuckery. Midgardsormr claims he came to this "star", as in the implied planet with Eorzea, Othard, and Ilsabard as the current known and relevant major land masses with various nations that are too numerous to name cleanly. He brought with him 7(?) children, I believe they were eggs, that we know as notable characters like Bahamut, Hraesvelger, Tiamat, and Nidhogg. Meaning Midgardsomr was not born on Hydaelyn, he is from somewhere else. Same with Omega presumably considering Midgardsormr claims to have battled Omega in space or something. Don't take my exact word on Omega as I haven't touched Omega's story in forever, but I remember Midgardsormr explaining this somewhere around 2.5 or in early sections of Heavensward. What exactly "Space" is, is beyond me that is an answer I don't think we actually have anywhere been explained what is going on unless it is somewhere in the Omega raid story line.
How any of that ties to the whole shard shit, is completely beyond me.