I had some hopes for Solution 9 because it was interesting with the memory wipe stuff and how it could have played out. You could make a scary story about memory wiping akin to dementia
That whole element is so bizarre. In the story, it serves almost no point whatsoever and it gets brushed over as abruptly as it's introduced. It's one of those "hiroi thought it sounded cool, shoved it in, then forgot about it and moved on to the next one" things.
The entire point of it isn't to contemplate on "post death society," but rather to contrast with the Yok Huoy memorials. There's this "theme" in the story of "we'll remember you," which means absolutely fucking nothing and always comes off retarded - my only guess is that Hiroi thought it sounded "profound" because at the end of Shadowbringers, where you consign an entire civilization's memory to oblivion at the fucking bottom of the ocean, Selch asks you to remember they existed. It's this moment of existential angst and weakness that comes across as this poignant mixture of heartfelt and desperate... and so of course Wuk says some retarded shit like "don't worry sphene, we'll remember you, we'll carry that burden" and I already forgot the entire plot of the expansion
I was hoping that it would turn out that the real Sphene had long since been turned into a primal
Nono, you can't just involve ideas from the rest of the setting and story. This is Wuk's story, and we have to make sure everyone understands that the
FUTURE of FF14 will not be bound by its past, and as such it won't feel any obligation to provide actually-interesting twists or dynamics.
Are people really upset over the viper changes?
I think it's more that "the class had effectively one thing to manage" and now it has zero.
Ultimately, it is more of a QoL change, but it exposes the really obvious flaw that class design has reached such a simple, barebones state that there's nothing to fuck up on
half 90% of the classes in the game. You can play like the average DF DPS and still excel.