I just find this entire situation ironic, isn't "forgiveness" like a core tenet of Christianity? they're fans of a show that very obviously tries to be anti-christian despite the fact that the morals it pushes are rooted in Christian ideology. It's like the perfect microcosm of everything wrong with this show and it's fans.
It is, but that’s one side of the coin, and not the side they take issue with. Forgiveness goes hand in hand with the other core tenet, repentance, and that’s where the breakdown starts happening with these sorts of things. God will forgive us and we should forgive, however, God also requests that we truly try and repent of the sins we commit to be forgiven, and we need others to repent of their sins as well, which comes in the form of trying to be better.
These people love what I call Hippy Jesus, where he tells you to be nice to everyone no matter the sin, and be cool to one another, and that so long as you’re generally nice, you’re good. This ignores actual Jesus, who says “Your sins are forgiven”, which everyone loves, but then adds a line, that they don’t like.
What they absolutely despise is: “Go and sin no more.” Which indicates you need to stop the behavior that was sinful. In their view, those standards are evil and oppressive, because you should be able to do whatever you want, whenever you want, without thought to either the future or other people. So long as you don’t do something really bad, like murder someone (and if Luigi M. taught me anything, even murder isn’t that evil, depending on who you kill, which should worry everyone and anyone who has ever interacted with those sociopaths because they have a very loose and liquid definition of who’s deserving to be killed) then Heaven isn’t something that is given, Heaven is owed to you. You are perfect the way you are, and if someone tries to hold you to a moral standard, they’re the issue, not your behavior, God included.
As an afterthought, People here also joke about the Sad Backstory thing excusing all actions, I have met people that actually think that if someone does something like steal or rob someone, it’s not their fault for making the choice, no they’re has to be a reason they’re doing it that’s understandable and thus, just need some kindness.
Source for this: Atheists and Leftists in the family/People that utterly despise Christianity, but constantly try to co-opt the church for their own shitty beliefs.