iRON-mAn
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2019
Also, didn't Snape use Sectumsempra to slash James open in one of the memories in the memory sieve? He nearly killed the him, too, and I'm fairly certain he didn't apologize for it.
Neither incident of almost-killing is okay in the slightest, but it's not like Snape was a totally innocent victim. He did nasty shit to James, too.
I believe you're thinking of Harry using it on Malfoy. To my knowledge, Snape never actually used the spell, though he did invent it. He also invented the levicorpus spell, which was subsequently used by James on Snape. I'm happy to be proven wrong though.
I think the difference is that Snape is framed as 100% a polarizing anti-hero character whereas James was shaped from the beginning to be this well-loved hero that everyone spoke highly about until you find out what an asshole he was. Snape was by no means a misunderstood victim as he did his own fair share of awful shit. But the book portrays him as a nasty, flawed person that acted with courage and conviction and maybe even some redemption but was ultimately, still, a nasty flawed person worthy of just as much pity as contempt. It wasn't so for James because it just feels like he gets a free pass since everyone's judgments about him are colored with awe or friendship.
Snape and James were both equally horrible people. The only difference is that one is very clearly supposed to be seen that way and the other basically got rewarded with the girl and a legacy even though he didn't do that much to make up for it in the grand scheme of things.
Is he though? The Order of the Phoenix is all about Harry finding out more stuff about his dad and learning that he was an obnoxious shit. The point was that James changed for the better and settled down, Snape dwelt on his anger and insecurity, which led him down a darker path. The fact that we don't know whether James completed a 12 step program or just became self-aware of how much an asshole he was, doesn't change the fact that he did change. Everyone says he was a better person later in life. Are we just supposed to dismiss that because it isn't shown?
If any one is an unrepentant bastard, it's Sirius. He's the one who tips off Snape that Remus is going to the Shrieking Shack every month and he continues to be an absolute dick to the man years later, even after he's joined the Order.
Last edited: