- Joined
- Jan 1, 2023
If you have a 9mm, just load hardcast rounds in it. It's certainly true that too much handgun is better than not enough, but it's also true that the handgun you already have is a far less expensive option than the handgun you don't.I'll ask here since the innawoods thread is slower than molasses whats a good handgun for backpacking keep in mind I'm more concerned for 4 legged critters than 2 after doing a bit of research I'm heavily considering the Ruger SP101 for the following major reasons:
Phil Shoemaker killed a Kodiak bear with 9mm hardcast rounds in a defensive gun use. I'm certain it's more than enough for a black bear, which is the sole bear in 95% of areas with bears.
Anyone who tells you that 10mm or .357 Magnum is necessary to stop a bear is a fudd. It's recognized as fuddlore and has been refuted with studies.
That makes sense if you run .357 Magnum. As I discussed earlier, it's really not necessary for stopping bears in most any case.Weight: Ironically enough the weight is something I was originally wary of until I realized bear defense rounds for .357 kick like a mule
It doesn't matter what anyone tells you: capacity is important to some degree. There's no guarantee you're going to get an immediately incapacitating hit in that five rounds. It took Phil Shoemaker eight or nine to take that Kodiak down.Robust Build: Ruger makes this particular model like a fucking tank hence the enhance weight and 5 round capacity vs the traditional 6
You know what has more aftermarket support than an SP101? A Glock or an M&P 2.0.Aftermarket Support: The Sp101 was released in the 90s and has stuck around for a while so you can find aftermarket shit EVERWHERE
People can get wigged out all they want, it doesn't matter. "Oh no, a scary gun! What ever shall I do?" There's nothing they can do about it. Open carry, conceal carry, do whatever you want, but stop caring what cityslicker, nogunz faggots think.Concealability: I need a CCW and on backpacking trails alotta people get wigged out when you open carry (people go missing on trails/parks alot)
1. As someone else said, revolvers almost always have many more parts than semi-autos.Why a Revolver vs Semi? (Inb4 Fudd Faggot): >tfw you will never be Arthur Morgan
a few but a major reason(s) is dirt and mags, dirt is like sand for trails it gets everywhere and since 10mm is the minimum for bear defense in a semi this impacts reliability in all semis. or as scotty kilmer would put it "more moving parts more stuff can go wrong" Mags take up more space, weigh more (loaded), and usually require belt mounting (for ease of access) , vs 2 speed strips of .357.
2. As established earlier in my post, you don't need 10mm to kill a bear. They're not magically immune to 9mm, .40 S&W, .45 ACP, .357 SIG, etc.
3. You really think a speed strip is going to be better because you can throw it in your pocket, despite the fact they're less intuitive than a magazine and take longer to reload your revolver with than a speedloader? It's almost always faster to reload a semi-automatic than a revolver. I carry two spare magazines on a daily basis and they're comfortable as-is, let alone don't print.


pilled.