- Joined
- May 14, 2019
South was 12% (I would have expected much more) according to what I pulled upI blame it on Americans loving an underdog tale. The plucky, courageous South against the industrialized masses of the North, but it never is that simple. In reality the South was almost entirely conscript once people realized after the first year that oh, the North isn't just going to roll over and let the South win. The first Confederate conscription act was passed in April of 1862, less than a year after the war started. On the northern side the Enrollment Act wasn't even proposed by Congress until 1863, almost a full year after the South had begun conscription, but both it and the earlier Militia Act of 1862 largely mimicked the way the Continental Army had been formed via a quota system of troops from each state with draftees being a last resort in case the quotas weren't met.
This is confusing firstly because many people (having looked into this) only volunteered to avoid the draft (they could choose their own unit and get bonuses if they volunteered, so the draft was like a threat).
I'm also not sure if these figures count militia as part of the army and if conscription into the militia is counted as militia. That SHOULD be how it's done, but when you deal with the American Revolution it leads to endless confusion with a lack of clarification about state militia and (at sea) privateers.