- Joined
- Jan 24, 2020
People have been asking for high graphics PC games from Nintendo since at least 2007. Honestly, that’s both a) missing the point of Nintendo games as PC gamers have always been the opposite to their target demographic, and maybe stir some bad blood via emulation, rom hacks, and fan games, whether or not that’s justified; and b) indicative of the problem that these older Pokémon fans don’t actually know what they want. Adult Pokémon fans have been chasing the dragon that is the magic they felt for the franchise when they were six, which is obviously never going to happen.I'd love to see Gamefreak being ballsy, releasing a Mainline-Title with High-End graphics and a huge map to discorver for PC tho.
Since the shift to HD, games aiming for a more realistic look have become a dime-a-dozen. The modern games market has proven that a strong, stylized art direction through development will always result in a better game than trying to allocate limited resources (even for a Pokémon game) from gameplay development towards achieving photo realism. The issue with Pokémon is its art direction stumbled at X and Y, and has been on a downward trend since. Pokémon design still undergoes the same philosophy it had thirty years ago, where what the Pokémon looks like and what it can do are largely arbitrary with a handful of more crafted exceptions. Combined with designs being submitted by multiple people with wildly varying art styles and a shift towards a more mainstream anime look, which designs just being animals with magic powers (Klefki and other in animated designs add a lot of variety) and Pokemon just ends up resembling a generic phone game, bootleg to itself.
The last time Game Freak really cared about art direction was Black and White. Part of that was, as you suggested, a return to their roots of some 200 Pokémon available, at least during the main part of the game. People derided it at the time, to where Black and White 2 completely scrapped that idea. Game Freak gets a lot of blame for being lazy/incompetent and just letting the franchise print money, but conveniently forget that when they did try and toe the line once they realized they had infinite money, fans shot themselves in the foot over it.
Fuck, I really didn’t intend this to turn into an essay.