Post Ratings Discussion

[Far Queue]

Whilst people are making suggestions, does anyone have suggestions for different colours for the thumbs up/down icons (it's weird them being the same colour).

I'd go with yellow or orange. It sets the two apart in the same way that the green/red agree and disagree colors do. Orange isn't used for anything else that's circle shaped, so it's both distinct and immediately identifiable even at smaller sizes.

Some of the other suggestions are good (lighter pink for Feels, shorter 'i' with bigger dot for Informative, etc.) but the only icon that really bothers me is the islamic content rating. The shade of green should be deeper and the proportions of the star and crescent feel off. I'd honestly just suggest ripping off the design from the Algerian flag, and using that shade of green.

 

[Misaki Nakahara]

1) The new ratings are gay I hate change REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

2) I propose a "Detective" rating, like for when someone does some digging on a cow and uncovers something new you give them the "Detective" rating

 

[cowisnow]

I want the powerlevel design to stay. It's not hard to search what the icon is.

Once KiwiJeff posted that little video I did a google search and learned more about it. Makes perfect sense now.

 

[BlueSpark]

I made a lot of the changes that people asked for (though there were obviously conflicting opinions so not everything was possible).

Tell me how these look:

Spoiler

 

[Chichan]

WTF, we drink appletinis now?

I thought it was absinthe.

 

[Ma Wang]

I made a lot of the changes that people asked for (though there were obviously conflicting opinions so not everything was possible).

Tell me how these look:

Spoiler

View attachment 888960

No "thunk provoking"? What's the doggo for?

 

[BlueSpark]

No "thunk provoking"? What's the doggo for?

I actually did make a Thunk-Provoking one, I was just finishing it up.
I'm guessing the reason that Null doesn't have a vector for Thoughtful is that Joypixels (the company that makes that thinking emoji vector) probably makes people pay for the vector version.
Well, I made a new one that looks very similar yet legally distinct:

Spoiler

The doge emoji is used on one of the subforums.

 

[BoJack Horseman]

Much better, though I still don't understand why DRINK! is green, and Semper Fidelis has poor contrast. needs to be shinier. Also that Winner star looks... very spiky.

 

[Adamska]

I made a lot of the changes that people asked for (though there were obviously conflicting opinions so not everything was possible).

Tell me how these look:

Spoiler

View attachment 888960

That's noticeably better. The only one that still needs work is Islamic content since the star is too big for it. Just shrink it by about... 50% and you're pretty much good.

 

[BlueSpark]

That's noticeably better. The only one that still needs work is Islamic content since the star is too big for it. Just shrink it by about... 50% and you're pretty much good.

Much better, though I still don't understand why DRINK! is green, and Semper Fidelis has poor contrast. needs to be shinier. Also that Winner star looks... very spiky.

When I was making it I thought the blue liquid looked weird and I made it green because kiwi juice or whatever. Changed part of the globe colour on Semper Fidelis, see below. I made the Winner icon look more like the original pixel art version (screenshot below) because people didn't seem to like the new design.

 

[maalikthefakemuzzie]

I demand an edgy rating!

 

[Kiwi Jeff]

I demand an edgy rating!

Why?

 

[maalikthefakemuzzie]

Why?

There are a few edgy dudes (like me) on this forum.

 

[Birthday Dickpunch]

I actually did make a Thunk-Provoking one, I was just finishing it up.
I'm guessing the reason that Null doesn't have a vector for Thoughtful is that Joypixels (the company that makes that thinking emoji vector) probably makes people pay for the vector version.
Well, I made a new one that looks very similar yet legally distinct:

Spoiler

View attachment 889118

Does this look oddly green-tinged to anyone else or is it just me?

 

[PsychoNerd054]

2) I propose a "Detective" rating, like for when someone does some digging on a cow and uncovers something new you give them the "Detective" rating

That's more or less what Semper Fieldis and Achievement are for.

 

[ILovePudding]

There are a few edgy dudes (like me) on this forum.

If you have to tell people you're edgy, you're clearly not.

 

[BoJack Horseman]

There are a few edgy dudes (like me) on this forum.

View attachment 889333


When I was making it I thought the blue liquid looked weird and I made it green because kiwi juice or whatever. Changed part of the globe colour on Semper Fidelis, see below. I made the Winner icon look more like the original pixel art version (screenshot below) because people didn't seem to like the new design.

View attachment 889349

View attachment 889348

Give the winner star a slight gradient to give it some material depth (like the original) and round off the outline edge just the tiniest bit. Right now it just seems totally flat and cartoonish looking.

 

[BlueSpark]

Does this look oddly green-tinged to anyone else or is it just me?

Fixed:

Give the winner star a slight gradient to give it some material depth (like the original) and round off the outline edge just the tiniest bit. Right now it just seems totally flat and cartoonish looking.

 

[BlueSpark]

So here's the icon set so far:

Spoiler

 

[Corbin Dallas Multipass]

It's different than before thus it is objectively inferior and I'm fucking mad as hell!

Change is bad and strange and I hate it.