- Joined
- Sep 16, 2013
When I think about belief in God to belief in Santa, I come up with two major differences.
1. When you are little, your parents tell you that Santa leaves you presents. But it is not Santa (sorry kids), it is your parents. You might go the mall and sit on his lap, but that is a man pretending to be Santa. Any interaction kids have with "Santa" is completely fabricated. Very few people have an interaction with God, or believe that they have an interaction with God, that is fabricated by another person.
2. You are taught about Santa by your parents, teachers etc. None of them believe in Santa. You are taught about God by your parents, priests, etc. Often, they believe in God, particularly if the teaching is designed to encourage you to believe. You are taught about God honestly, and about Santa dishonestly.
Basically, Santa is pretty easily demonstrably false. God is not demonstrably false, at least not easily.
No intelligent adult, or even adolescent, believes in Santa Claus. Many intelligent adults believe in God. If you are a hardcore atheist, that is an entirely defensible position. If you believe that believing in God is a little silly, that is a defensible position. If you think believing in God is a sure sign of a lack of intelligence, then the large number of highly intelligent and accomplished people who believe in God makes your position entirely indefensible.
1. When you are little, your parents tell you that Santa leaves you presents. But it is not Santa (sorry kids), it is your parents. You might go the mall and sit on his lap, but that is a man pretending to be Santa. Any interaction kids have with "Santa" is completely fabricated. Very few people have an interaction with God, or believe that they have an interaction with God, that is fabricated by another person.
2. You are taught about Santa by your parents, teachers etc. None of them believe in Santa. You are taught about God by your parents, priests, etc. Often, they believe in God, particularly if the teaching is designed to encourage you to believe. You are taught about God honestly, and about Santa dishonestly.
Basically, Santa is pretty easily demonstrably false. God is not demonstrably false, at least not easily.
No intelligent adult, or even adolescent, believes in Santa Claus. Many intelligent adults believe in God. If you are a hardcore atheist, that is an entirely defensible position. If you believe that believing in God is a little silly, that is a defensible position. If you think believing in God is a sure sign of a lack of intelligence, then the large number of highly intelligent and accomplished people who believe in God makes your position entirely indefensible.