It's actually the tip of the iceberg I tried to keep most of the cricisms relavent to US politics for example what does the author mean by goverment?What part of the goverment? For example does the inam council of Iran count as goverment? do local political groups such as school boards?
the author isnt wrong in the strictest sense,bellowing racial slurs in public might get you fired. but his problem is he's overeaching because it's expediant to the current climate, he thinks he pressure people who he hates into silence by obaying the laws of freedom of speech even if he ignores the spirit but he hasnt considered the long game where it's really easy for non-liberal groups to use the same tactics so he's really fucking himself in the long run.
The biggest problem with it is that Randall shows absolutely no awareness of, much less respect for, the
principle of free speech or free inquiry. Sure, you
can shut down any speech you disagree with if you control a private forum, and in some cases it's even appropriate -- who wants to get into a brutal, ugly discussion of religion on a chess forum, for instance? But when you close yourself off to dissenting ideas, you learn nothing and only have your views and beliefs reinforced, to the point where any opposing thoughts seem not only incorrect but objectively wrong or even downright evil. A private university
could decide to have no right wing speakers, but what kind of university refuses to challenge its students' and faculties' beliefs? (Which is one major reason why modern academia is turning into a horrible joke.) The comic is an exercise in Puritanical finger-wagging: "Oh, sure, you can say whatever you want
over there, and the government can't, like,
arrest you for it, but don't you dare speak your mind in a place
I care about!"
Randall's cowardice in not addressing what, specifically, he's referring to in the comic doesn't help matters, either, but it's why it's become a go-to argument for the sort of person who unironically uses the phrase "freeze peach," and it's a pretty good cameo of the sort of free expression arguments an ogre like Bob is wont to make.