I still can't believe that 109 crazy exes of Sam have falsely accused him of being a creep and schemed and colluded against him for his entire career.
*sighs* Women
Kiwifarms functions kind of the opposite that the mainstream does. Over there being a catty woman or tranny in distress will make you instantly credible, whereas on kiwifarms those people need to work twice as hard to be believed. This is especially the case when they accuse a guy most people here think is okay. I think the problem for the leakers is that they can't seem to get this, and expect instant validation like they would get in the mainstream. It isn't like that here.
With that said, Sam Hyde does seem to have some vices, which can be established with only minimal reliance on the leaks.
1. He is a philanderer and seem to have no concept of fidelity to the women he is with. This is pretty obvious if you just watch his videos, where he repeatedly admits to cheating. His attitude about it isn't fully clear, but from his tone, he seems to think it would be ridiculous to expect him to stay loyal. Based on this, I'm guessing he has some weird compulsive hypersexuality thing going on, stemming from the e-fame getting to his head or maybe some hang-up from his earlier years. His philandering also makes sense in light of the leaks - if you mess around with the hearts of girls as a habit, it's unsurprising you have a platoon of vindictive bitches spreading dirt about you.
2. He seems to be a coomer and fetishist. This is a bit harder to establish. There's plenty of allegations about his weird interests in the leaks - I think I somewhat believe those, because fetishistic sexuality would tie in nicely with the first point. There's a few supporting pieces from his videos - for instance, he seems to be pretty knowledgable about obscure BDSM fetish devices in one of the videos.
3. His taste in women seems to be garbage and motivated primarily by whatever he gets off on. As an example of this, he described one of his exes as being an almost psychotic borderline woman, who eventually got him an FBI visit. While getting caught up with one of these girls isn't necessarily a point against him, Sam Hyde was already a sexually experienced guy when he ended up with this harpy. This makes me think he ignored multiple red flags before ending up with her.
Beyond that, his bad taste in women is supported by the leaks. I tend to believe Sam Hyde at least had some of the altercations with women the leaks suggest he had. If one believes that, you have to ask yourself why someone who knows his way around on the internet would go for a girl like Marky, some barely legal 18 year old attention addict from r9k of all places. That's the type of decision making that will get you drama every time. Especially given that Marky also had a troop of protective and mildly unstable thirstlords orbiting her, who ended up flaring up the drama as an act of jealous revenge against Sam Hyde.
And of course that all makes sense in context of his philandering - a compulsive sex addict would expose himself more to crazy women than the average guy, and it is logical that his decision-making would be hindered by his compulsions.
Overall, what does this make Sam Hyde? Well, right now at worst he looks a bit like Lowtax - a guy with poor impulse control who keeps fucking up with regard to women and might eventually end up getting buried for it. To Sam's credit, he is at least funny and puts out good content sometimes. So long as that keeps happening, I think his coomer antics might be forgiven.
Alternatively, the fame might go to his head, his content might take a nosedive and his coomer habits might go haywire. If he can't restrain himself and ends up caught with an underage girl or in some kind of serious abuse case (and we see actual concrete evidence for that), we could have a downfall saga for him. I think it definitely could go that way for him, possibly even quite soon. I like his content, so I hope he keeps his head screwed on straight. But given that he has a bit of an ego as well, some kind of bad ending is definitely possible for Sam Hyde.