I have a few ideas, whether or not they're good is debateable.
First off, like you said we've got a problem with combativeness. There's way too many people in here whose only goal is to start shit and piss people off. Sure, we like a little trolling, but we don't need 20 people @ing HHH everytime someone says or does dumb shit. For that I propose the following: Make @ing people to start shit a bannable (or otherwise punishable) offense. If you've got shit to talk, take it to dms you fucking spergs.
To add to that point, we dont need 5 million derangement/enslavement threads where people can shit around screaming at eachother about how stupid the other side is. Remove all those threads, disallow further ones, and instead have a megathread for making fun of all political spergs who tard out online. If they tard hard enough just make a fucking thread. We need to stop taking this shit so seriously and start laughing at retards who do. The Biden megathread can stay because it's for posting news regarding Joe Biden, our sitting president.
If people want to start shit and/or glow post, they don't belong here. Same for doom posting. Crying about how terrible everything is and threatening to murder politicians in minecraft doesn't further discussion and it makes threads fucking unreadable. The only way to read half the threads is through highlights. You wonder why autistic thunderdome threads grow so fast? It's all the retards screaming about fucking nothing.
Nothing will ever change the "my side good your side bad" mentality. I should know, I fucking hate democrats and I can't pretend to be unbiased. That doesn't mean that we can't fucking talk to each other like civilized adults. It's a total fucking fog of war shit flinging frenzy out here whenever anything happens and some of you spergs think we're the pinnacle of unbiased discussion. We're fucking not, so at least play nice or get your toys taken away.
If it's gonna be a multi-mod job, simply put we need different mods for the different boards.
Articles and News needs someone to make sure that what's getting posted is actually articles and news. I'm not saying catparty and their weird threads have to go, just that we clean up satirical or outright inflammatory articles (which I almost never see but some tards will find any excuse to fling shit). They're rare but a funny haha article kind of takes away from the intended experience. Maybe just a megathread for satirical news. Keep politisperging to a minimum unless it actually contributes somewhat to understanding or discussing the posted article.
Deep thoughts is more chill. It should probably be kept as is but with a mod in there making sure there's actual discussion going on, not rampant opinion-flinging, screeching monkey orgies.
Happenings needs a TON of cleaning up. It's where we discuss ongoing major events and its 90% just noise. Reading through the highlights of any given thread doesn't help either because every other post is people complaining about all the niggercattle pissing 10 feet straight up into the goddamn air like autistic rainmakers. We would need multiple mods for this board, especially when happenings get featured because when that happens we combine the normal userbase with a ravenous sea of autistic sharks with no teeth. It's a fucking mess. We want happenings to be readable? We gotta clean out all the fucking white noise. Will people complain? Yeah. But who fucking cares? If you're mad you can't write scat fanfic about how the people with different opinions have messy forceful sex with their geriatric man of choice then go cry about it on fucking onionfarms or whatever.
Finally, and I doubt you could do this, but we should have a fourth autistic thunderdome board, also named the Autistic Thunderdome. There are no mods. No rules. Only negrates, no positive rates. Clicking the report button is an automatic ban for the clicker. Posting in the board gives an automatic badge of the star of david to signify them as posters in the board.
Again, unfeasible, but it would be funny.
Anyways that's just like, my opinion man.