having just put 20 hours into it I think some of the side quests are quite good and the handmade explorable area around the city is also quite good, overall I think the negativity is a harsh knee jerk reaction from people expecting something different
its absolutely better than mothership zeta, for me I’d put it around dragonborn in a ranking of Bethesda DLCs
my review is as follows:
Decent side quests
good unique explorable area
the two unique guns it does add feel like they add something to the basegame weapons
main story is not very good and quite short, I think they could have made it better by forcing you to do 3 side quests at one point because they were a better experience
also the new dungeons are better than most of the basegame ones
no new ship parts or land vehicles is annoying
only 1 actually new space suit and only 2 actually new weapons
My overall rating is 6.5/10