In isolation, there were things I really did like. Homelander and Butcher's fates were very fitting for their characters, but I wish that both of them did some heinous shit before they fell. Homelander's humiliation would've had weight if he did some heinous shit to innocent people in the season rather than killing the sycophantic president and Not!Elon. However, his death really is fitting for this spoiled manchild with superpowers that never worked a hard day in his life.
Butcher too would've benefitted from doing some atrocity before Hughie kills him. The scene between the two is really solid in isolation, but it really would've benefitted from some more stuff.
I think outside of Hughie and Starlight, the rest of The Boys didn't really have fitting endings. MM's felt way too happy and Kimiko's ending is fine, but it feels a bit funny that the finale of The Boys hinged on exposing a japanese woman to nuclear radiation to strengthen her.
But The Deep's ending is flawless since he went out in the best manner possible and he really had the most consistent arc throughout the series like A-Train. Ashley also kind of benefits a lot as her ending fits the type of person she is.
However, Sage felt like she got off way too scot free especially since she helped give the idea of putting Starlight supporters in Death Camps, her getting lobotimized into a retard isn't really good, and she is a character that really never earned any sympathy for all the terrible shit she did.
Oh Father's thing made sense given the blatant blasphemy he spouted.
But a lot of this season really falls due to how there are spin-offs that really hamper the show. The fact that Gen V characters make pointless cameos suck and the fact there was blatant setup for a Gen V season 3 in this finale before it canned really says a lot. But the worst offender is the whole bullshit with Soldier Boy since all his stuff was just a backdoor pilot for a show yet to be seen, and his morals flip on a dime. I swear the season probably would have been improved a lot if they didn't have any of these spin-offs influence the main show.
Not helped with the fucking shit jokes like the 5 minute speech about how Frenchie views people's ass holes or that dumb shit with the animal themed superheros.