Culture The childhood transition narrative is crumbling - God, I hope so.

________________________
The narrative about childhood transition that transgender activists have been selling is slowly crumbling. Last week, Reuters published an investigation into the exponential increase in teenage girls wanting to transition, acknowledging that referrals to gender clinics have been overrepresented by this population. For many, their gender dysphoria is influenced by their peers and social media.

For anyone who’s been following this issue for a while, you may be thinking, "Oh, really?" The piece also described a variety of reasons why a young woman may want to live as a man, including mental health issues besides gender dysphoria, hatred of her body, sexism, and not wanting to be sexualized due to being female.

WHY CAN'T WE LET CHILDREN BE CHILDREN?

Regarding the desire to change one’s body, a recent study published in JAMA Pediatrics found a total of 1,130 double mastectomies were performed on minors between 2016 and 2019, representing a 389% increase. The study also documented relatively high rates of anxiety (about 21%) and depression (about 16%), in addition to gender dysphoria, in these patients. Another analysis, discussed by Reuters, found at least 776 double mastectomies performed in the past three years on patients as young as 13.

In the United States, the sex ratio of gender referrals, once dominated by boys, is nearly 2-to-1 today and dominated by girls. As bans on "gender-affirming care" are being debated in dozens of states, Florida has continued to take an evidence-based stance in combating radical gender theory and protecting children. Following a request from Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, the state’s Board of Medicine and Board of Osteopathic Medicine decided to prohibit transition-related procedures, including hormones and surgery, for minors earlier this month.

Adolescence is a time characterized by trying on different identities and being impulsive and suggestible. It’s no wonder that friend groups, social media, and online communities have the potential to shape young people’s minds and behaviors in such powerful ways.

A few years ago, the concept of transition regret and detransitioning remained relatively rare. Now, as the number of detransitioners continues to grow, I hope that more policymakers will take heed and listen to their voices. The fact that mainstream news outlets are gradually pulling the reins on the early transitioning movement is an indication that the cultural tide is turning. But concern and support for detransitioners must remain, even after the battle against childhood transition has been won.
_____________________________

Requested by @JosephStalin. Please God, let this be true, for the sake of children everywhere.
 
It's crumbling too slowly. Girls are mutilating themselves with testosterone and double mastectomies as we speak.
Yes, the crumbling needs to accelerate post-haste if we want our children to have the ghost of a decent future. Still, the fact that it's crumbling in the first place is very encouraging.
 
It's almost as if learning some modicum of self acceptance is important in your formative years.
Or something. Whatever. I don't know.
And that children can't be trusted to understand what's in their long-term interests and allowing them to (or worse, grooming them to) permanently mutilate their bodies is a bad idea.

There's a reason minors can't enter into most contracts. This all used to be so obvious that no one needed to say it.
 
Jazz Jennings is a large reason for this in my eyes. You have this guy who had his body ruined by his whacko mother since he was 3 and when he finally got the chop the Incision popped due to there not being enough “material” to work with. Now he’s a fat mess of a human being who’s grades are a mess and his whole family is also a mess and his show had to be taken off the air due to it completely ruining the narrative that “if we make kids transition early they will be fine”.
 
And that children can't be trusted to understand what's in their long-term interests and allowing them to (or worse, grooming them to) permanently mutilate their bodies is a bad idea.

There's a reason minors can't enter into most contracts. This all used to be so obvious that no one needed to say it.
Similarly, you can't get a tattoo until you're 18 so why the fuck would you be allowed to sterilize yourself for reasons outside of a dire medical emergency? I'm not necessarily saying that legal age restrictions always make sense, only that some sense of consistency would be fantastic. As it is now, a significant percentage of the people who bemoan that you're allowed to sign up for the military before you can drink in the US somehow think it's fine to make the call to stop your body from developing when you're 10.
 
It helps that whoever is in charge of The Narrative has started letting detransitioners speak.
Oh, they're very much still actively trying to shut them down. They're just starting to hit a critical mass in which its too difficult to silence them all, and the shrouds gotten away from them.

This all used to be so obvious that no one needed to say it.
This was obvious in a period when the vast majority of young people had kids, and realized early just how stupid they are. Now birthrates are cratering, child stupidity is medicated away into a cooperative haze, and any problem child can be quieted for a couple days with an xbox and a $20 fortnite card. No small surprise that this gives many people a completely warped perspective of youth competence.
 
This was obvious in a period when the vast majority of young people had kids, and realized early just how stupid they are. Now birthrates are cratering, child stupidity is medicated away into a cooperative haze, and any problem child can be quieted for a couple days with an xbox and a $20 fortnite card. No small surprise that this gives many people a completely warped perspective of youth competence.
The left has also adopted this weird "profound wisdom of the innocent children" thing where kids like Jazz Jennings and Gretta Thunberg are taken seriously, despite obviously being the puppets of their handlers.

Interestingly, it's not the first time that's happened in history (typically it's been a religious thing) and it always ends in disaster because kids are retarded.
 
Anyone with half a brain could see this was inevitable. What’s most sickening is that so much of this shit could have been avoided if sensible, qualified people without any self interest had stepped up about fifteen years ago and put the brakes on troons more ridiculous rhetoric before everybody got high on po-mo gender theory, especially when it came to skeevy AGP men and self regarding humanities academics who’ve been the biggest pushers. Instead they got all behind it because LGB orgs draped it in the rainbow flag as a way to continue justifying their existence and income stream once gay legal equality was achieved. Special spicy straights should have been told to fuck off from the get-go, not embraced to artificially boost the numbers. Now here we are, with increasing numbers of normies coming to the conclusion that troons are gross (many oldskool troons are really pissed off by this because again it’s all down to the AGPs and their shitty behaviour), lesbians have been pretty much erased as a group, and gays are getting caught in the backlash. Both are getting increasingly terfy as a result.

Slowest train crash ever.
 
The left has also adopted this weird "profound wisdom of the innocent children" thing where kids like Jazz Jennings and Gretta Thunberg are taken seriously, despite obviously being the puppets of their handlers.

Interestingly, it's not the first time that's happened in history (typically it's been a religious thing) and it always ends in disaster because kids are retarded.
It still is a religious thing - They worship purity of thought, and in their eyes, what can be purer than an untainted child? Well, a child thats been 'correctly' guided in the world.
 
It still is a religious thing - They worship purity of thought, and in their eyes, what can be purer than an untainted child? Well, a child thats been 'correctly' guided in the world.
Another example is ‘young people now are so switched on politically’, when they’re not, there still twats, just like they’ve always been. The current crop of youth aren’t special and I hate how they and their fashionable opinions are fetishised by lefty Gen Xers who feel old but want to be seen as still with the zeitgeist. Sad fuckers.
 
I remember as a kid being taught history and reading some of the stuff that happened way back when. I can't help but wonder if teachers are going to explain this sort of phenomenon fifty years from now or just pretend it didn't happen like so many other weird occurrences in history.
If they mention it, it'll be with the implication "that was in ye olden backward days, but it'll never happen again because we're modern, sophisticated, enlightened people".
 
Back