Culture The childhood transition narrative is crumbling - God, I hope so.

________________________
The narrative about childhood transition that transgender activists have been selling is slowly crumbling. Last week, Reuters published an investigation into the exponential increase in teenage girls wanting to transition, acknowledging that referrals to gender clinics have been overrepresented by this population. For many, their gender dysphoria is influenced by their peers and social media.

For anyone who’s been following this issue for a while, you may be thinking, "Oh, really?" The piece also described a variety of reasons why a young woman may want to live as a man, including mental health issues besides gender dysphoria, hatred of her body, sexism, and not wanting to be sexualized due to being female.

WHY CAN'T WE LET CHILDREN BE CHILDREN?

Regarding the desire to change one’s body, a recent study published in JAMA Pediatrics found a total of 1,130 double mastectomies were performed on minors between 2016 and 2019, representing a 389% increase. The study also documented relatively high rates of anxiety (about 21%) and depression (about 16%), in addition to gender dysphoria, in these patients. Another analysis, discussed by Reuters, found at least 776 double mastectomies performed in the past three years on patients as young as 13.

In the United States, the sex ratio of gender referrals, once dominated by boys, is nearly 2-to-1 today and dominated by girls. As bans on "gender-affirming care" are being debated in dozens of states, Florida has continued to take an evidence-based stance in combating radical gender theory and protecting children. Following a request from Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, the state’s Board of Medicine and Board of Osteopathic Medicine decided to prohibit transition-related procedures, including hormones and surgery, for minors earlier this month.

Adolescence is a time characterized by trying on different identities and being impulsive and suggestible. It’s no wonder that friend groups, social media, and online communities have the potential to shape young people’s minds and behaviors in such powerful ways.

A few years ago, the concept of transition regret and detransitioning remained relatively rare. Now, as the number of detransitioners continues to grow, I hope that more policymakers will take heed and listen to their voices. The fact that mainstream news outlets are gradually pulling the reins on the early transitioning movement is an indication that the cultural tide is turning. But concern and support for detransitioners must remain, even after the battle against childhood transition has been won.
_____________________________

Requested by @JosephStalin. Please God, let this be true, for the sake of children everywhere.
 
From the Reuters article they cite (which is a better read)
Kelly, a 43-year-old parent who asked that her full name not be used to protect her family’s privacy, told Reuters that her child was heavily into highly sexualized anime and transgender online forums when the 12-year-old started experimenting, seemingly overnight, with being a transgender boy. The child’s therapist encouraged medical intervention, Kelly said, but while Kelly supported social transition outside the home, she made it clear that her child would have to wait until she was 18 for hormones and top surgery.


After several years of living as a boy and using “he” and “him” pronouns, Kelly’s child, now 18, is back to using her female name, dressing in feminine clothing and using “she” and “her” pronouns. “We would have lost our daughter if we had followed what the therapist was telling us to do,” the mother said.
Man, I like anime, but more and more it seems to be fucking with people's heads.
 
If they mention it, it'll be with the implication "that was in ye olden backward days, but it'll never happen again because we're modern, sophisticated, enlightened people".
"I mean really, how could anyone ever think castrating their own children was a good idea? Bunch of barbaric morons. Anyway kids, todays the day you're old enough for your Tesla chipping, please stand in an orderly line..."
 
From the Reuters article they cite (which is a better read)

Man, I like anime, but more and more it seems to be fucking with people's heads.
The kid was 12 when she was watching yaoi. That's the real fucked up part detractors don't seem to realize. I watched anime at her age, but I didn't watch that kind of shit, and never once did I think "I should become a boy." This is what happens when Saturday morning cartoons/anime blocks go away, leaving only unmoderated streaming where TV-MA shows aren't locked away behind age-restriction walls/premium, or (much more likely) when you don't monitor what your child does online.
 
And that children can't be trusted to understand what's in their long-term interests and allowing them to (or worse, grooming them to) permanently mutilate their bodies is a bad idea.

There's a reason minors can't enter into most contracts. This all used to be so obvious that no one needed to say it.
It really does seem like a slippery slope to lowering the age of consent.

You're asking middle schoolers to make decisions about their future sex lives and families that most normal, healthy 18-year-olds in our society don't have figured out.
 
Until Metokur's "How a Sausage is made" is mandatory viewing in Public schools, its not over yet. And I know schools are proud of showing students semi graphic videos about poor road safety and childbirth. And today, sodomy.

I remember as a kid being taught history and reading some of the stuff that happened way back when. I can't help but wonder if teachers are going to explain this sort of phenomenon fifty years from now or just pretend it didn't happen like so many other weird occurrences in history.
They never talked about Weimar Germany in any way shape or form in public schooling. Especially with how it parallels the West today with the infestation of faggots and Marxists. Just Kaiser with WWI and Hitler with WWII. So as far as they're concerned, it will remain as "One day, for no reason at all, people voted Hitler into power."
 
The kid was 12 when she was watching yaoi. That's the real fucked up part detractors don't seem to realize. I watched anime at her age, but I didn't watch that kind of shit, and never once did I think "I should become a boy." This is what happens when Saturday morning cartoons/anime blocks go away, leaving only unmoderated streaming where TV-MA shows aren't locked away behind age-restriction walls/premium, or (much more likely) when you don't monitor what your child does online.
A huge portion of the Western Bungo Stray Dogs fanbase are kids barely out of middle school. This is a seinen manga full of suicide jokes, violence, child abuse, very heavy themes in general, and references to literature kids shouldn't be reading until high school. One of the main antagonists is a pedophile who tried grooming one of the main characters when she was a child. I can instantly tell if someone is a kid the second they try saying that guy isn't actually into prepubescent children.

Why does he outright say he is, then? "Oh, it's just one of his crazy schemes." That's neat, go back to My Hero Academia. You seem lost.
They never talked about Weimar Germany in any way shape or form in public schooling. Especially with how it parallels the West today with the infestation of faggots and Marxists. Just Kaiser with WWI and Hitler with WWII. So as far as they're concerned, it will remain as "One day, for no reason at all, people voted Hitler into power."
It was talked about when I was in school. The problem is most people don't care about history until they can use it to win arguments. Many of these people may have been whisperers during class. You know the ones with whispers that sounded how getting stabbed feels. I'm trying to pay attention here, knife mouth.
 
not wanting to be sexualized due to being female.

This right here is a big one.. and is not just every bit as insidious and destructive as attacks on boys via fallacies like "toxic masculinity" but the literal other side of the coin! An unforeseen side effect or intentional outcome, it's not clear.. But the the pushing of "sexualisation" and "objectification" dogma is the direct cause. Victimhood is a passive state, and maturity, sexuality and sexual attributes are more than a liability, but a form of disability instead.

The "males looking at females sexually, dehumanizes females" argument is every bit as counter-factual/reality as the rejection of "sticks and stones" and "it's what's on the inside that counts" type logic by the prog left. It attacks males and criminalizes their sexuality while turning females into powerless perpetual victims. It's not hard to see this perverse idea in action... Simply look at social media and major sexual discourse.
 
The left has also adopted this weird "profound wisdom of the innocent children" thing where kids like Jazz Jennings and Gretta Thunberg are taken seriously, despite obviously being the puppets of their handlers.

Interestingly, it's not the first time that's happened in history (typically it's been a religious thing) and it always ends in disaster because kids are retarded.
Ya, remember hearing of the "Children's Crusade" during the time of the Crusades. Indeed, it also turned out horribly.

Thanks for reposting. 👍 Don't know why, but when I posted it and wanted to eliminate extraneous material the entire post went away. Too good not to post, though.
 
Some days I feel like transgenderism is weeding out the mentally ill and convinces them to sterilize themselves without it outright being labeled as eugenics because it's the individual's decision.
I also thought about this and I would be fine with it, if they kept it to themselves and stopped brainwashing children into doing it.
 
I remember as a kid being taught history and reading some of the stuff that happened way back when. I can't help but wonder if teachers are going to explain this sort of phenomenon fifty years from now or just pretend it didn't happen like so many other weird occurrences in history.
If it's US history it will be in the last week of the fourth quarter after the month of Holocaust self flagellation.
 
A huge portion of the Western Bungo Stray Dogs fanbase are kids barely out of middle school. This is a seinen manga full of suicide jokes, violence, child abuse, very heavy themes in general, and references to literature kids shouldn't be reading until high school. One of the main antagonists is a pedophile who tried grooming one of the main characters when she was a child. I can instantly tell if someone is a kid the second they try saying that guy isn't actually into prepubescent children.

Why does he outright say he is, then? "Oh, it's just one of his crazy schemes." That's neat, go back to My Hero Academia. You seem lost.

It was talked about when I was in school. The problem is most people don't care about history until they can use it to win arguments. Many of these people may have been whisperers during class. You know the ones with whispers that sounded how getting stabbed feels. I'm trying to pay attention here, knife mouth.
What happened that made kids so easily influenced? Now, I can't say I have the absolute ideal mental health, but its easy to say that none of my issues stem from watching some cartoon I wasn't supposed to when I was twelve.
 
Jazz Jennings is a large reason for this in my eyes.

I see what you did there

because jazz is fat

They never talked about Weimar Germany

We glossed over it in school. The way that era seems to be taught is two things
1. Hyper inflation
2. An explosion of the arts and music before that fuddy duddy Hitler put a stop to it.
 
From the Reuters article they cite (which is a better read)

Man, I like anime, but more and more it seems to be fucking with people's heads.
It wasn't always like this. I wouldn't say anime is the cause, but it's a convenient carrier for the fetish.
Thing is, “highly sexualized” anime is just a common fall guy excuse to not explain the real symptoms as to how the child thinks he/she is trans at just 12 years old.

Unfortunately, due to the onslaught of drugs, destroying the nuclear family and indoctrination of public schooling with hidden agendas, we live in a world where these types of people can’t differentiate between fantasy and reality.
 
Thing is, “highly sexualized” anime is just a common fall guy excuse to not explain the real symptoms as to how the child thinks he/she is trans at just 12 years old.

Unfortunately, due to the onslaught of drugs, destroying the nuclear family and indoctrination of public schooling with hidden agendas, we live in a world where these types of people can’t differentiate between fantasy and reality.

Naw, it isn't. But the cult is using anime as a way to shape how they perceive themselves as women. You know they don't really like anime, right? Even though a few of them are former male waifu obsessed weaboos, anime is not well regarded amongst them. It just happen that an anime waifu avatar is easier than the 'shop.
 
What happened that made kids so easily influenced? Now, I can't say I have the absolute ideal mental health, but its easy to say that none of my issues stem from watching some cartoon I wasn't supposed to when I was twelve.
I don't buy that cartoons are making kids troon out. That's up there with Doom causing school shootings, Judas Priest causing suicide, and Spongebob making kids gay. Pure nonsense parents spout to take themselves out of the equation.

The more likely reason for all of this is a mixture of wanting authority and self image issues common in teenagers. Rather than treating these self image issues like a normal part of puberty, they are currently being treated like a sign of a severe mental illness. If your teenager starts getting suicidal or cutting themselves because they hate their body, that means they need therapy and maybe medication. Not hormones and puberty blockers.
 
Back