You know, I know this might not be the thread for it (tho I dont think that there is much to talk about to justify starting a thread solely dedicated for it) but I have read Crossed recently
To specify, I read Crossed, Crossed Family Matters and Crossed Psychopath
And oh boy, I just get this "The walking dead but disgustingly edgy" vibe. Did you think Garth Ennis was edgy when writing The Boys comic? Bitch, you havent seen Garth when you tell him to write the most disgustingly edgy shit. And I do mean that I think this is Garth at his worst.
The basic premise is that, for whatever reason, a lot of the population suddenly become these "Crossed" individuals, and they are basically murderous sadistic rapists with no regard about humanity and morality. They can infect you with their body fluids, which implies a scientific origin but there isnt any explanation found (rather lazily I might add). This came in 2008 (I think) so 5 years after the TWD comics were out (2 years before the TV show tho) so you can imagine the comics were getting quite a bit of traction already among the industry and this whole thing feels like Garth's "answer" to TWD...as if to say "TWD is tame compared to our stuff"...and it is but its not better. The TWD comics are flawed but they still kept you engaged for the most part, Crossed basically keeps you relatively hooked to see what is going on at first but it eventually becomes all about the shock value.
And I think this is what ultimately becomes the selling point of this brand, the exploitive shock value...now I wont show you any of it because I think its best experienced as you read (cough,itsonReadComicsOnlinetho, cough). It catches you offguard at first but it once I got into Family Matters, I realized that this follows a patern.
1- Introduce group, most of them are bland at best and outright unlikable at worst
2- Have them be picked off one by one from reasons that range from bullshit to absurd
3- Make absolutely sure to show every gruesome detail, including the rape (The Crossed are big fans of that)
4- Eventually "conclude" (or rather stop) following whatever is left of the group by the time the volume ends.
The ironic thing is that I just feel this TWD DNA all over Crossed, tho I have no idea what Garth is trying to say with this series...humans are all monsters just one "whatever event" from snapping into our true grotestic nature? I dont necessarily disagree with that world view but it feels borderline cartoonish to the extends that Garth goes to REALLY send that across. The premise seems rather similar to The Crazies from George Romero (if its a coincidence that both Crossed and TWD are based off of Romero movies, Im not sure) except the Crossed are waaay more vicious and even smarter. And the main character of volume 1 looks suspeciously like Rick Grimes
Dont believe me? Check it out.
Getting a "can I copy your homework? Sure, just dont make it too obvious" vibe...
I guess my issue is that I feel like Crossed had potential as a setting but instead it allows itself to indulge on pointless shock value that leads to desensibilization real quick, by the time I read Psychopath, I felt just kind of done because the shock value just felt predictable and boring at that point. At least Crossed V1 tried to keep some level of self control but I guess they decided to make the shock value the whole point of reading these comics so there is that. I almost want to try to imagine Crossed getting a TV show like TWD and realising the sheer futility of it because even on HBO it would be far too much...but if they tamed the shock value, then we wouldnt have that much of what to invest because Crossed lacks hard on the character departament...they all feel like caractures or weaker versions of characters you would find in TWD or any other survival show...also the always shrinking parties kind remove any sense of investment because you know almost none of these characters are sticking around (killing your characters doesnt equal realism and good writing automatically)
I guess I just felt like sharing my disgust with this brand and I guess its kind of my fault for going into this brand, with the reputation it has, and expect any different but I kind of expected a more explicit and violent TWD and I kind of got that in the most extreme way possible to the point of utter lack of investment. Curious to what others think (and again, sorry if this goes out of topic too much but I doubt there is much to say about Crossed so making a dedicated Thread is kind of pointless)