Culture Watching 'A Wrinkle in Time' is a political act - Supporting Disney movies is a sign of resistance, says CNN

Purchasing a movie ticket has become the latest act of political resistance.

The Black Lives Matter and #MeToo movements, started and inspired by courageous black women, have ushered in cultural sea changes -- including challenging harmful and inaccurate media portrayals of African-Americans. The movie "Black Panther" has provided a rare opportunity to celebrate and savor the success of a story in which black characters' individual choices shape their collective destiny.

"A Wrinkle in Time," directed by Ava DuVernay, opens this weekend. The film is an adaptation of the 1962 book of the same name written by Madeleine L'Engle. A blend of science fiction, fantasy, and young adult coming-of-age narrative, it is the story of Meg Murry, an awkward and brilliant teenage girl, who adventures across space and time to rescue her scientist father, mysteriously gone missing. DuVernay's role as director brings a subtle strain of intersectionality woefully missing from much popular young adult fiction like "The Hunger Games" and the "Twilight" trilogy, in which white girls save the world.

The diverse casting in "A Wrinkle in Time" also takes an important step in normalizing girls and women of color as heroines of our own stories, interested in math and science, and struggling to define ourselves in a world that doesn't always accept us for who we are. The movie presents a vision of female empowerment in which whiteness is no longer the standard.

Unlike "Black Panther," race is not central to the characterization or plot of "A Wrinkle in Time." L'Engle, who authored multiple young adult novels, was white. While her books touch on issues of equality in some ways, race is rarely an explicit theme.

Race is present in this film adaptation because of DuVernay's decision to cast biracial actor Storm Reid as the movie's protagonist. Oprah Winfrey and Mindy Kaling are also cast as two of the fantasy creatures who help Meg and her brother seek their father's freedom.

Representation matters, as Rashad Robinson, executive director of Color of Change (a civil rights advocacy organization formed in 2005 in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina) told me -- especially for children. By going to see films like "Black Panther" and "A Wrinkle in Time," "kids of color get to see themselves as heroes, centered in the story, and as the person to root for," Robinson said.
It remains to be seen whether "A Wrinkle in Time" will experience anything like the same box-office success and emotional resonance with African-American audiences that "Black Panther" has had. Some prognosticators think it's unlikely, but it's possible. As teenagers, we often consume media to affirm we are not alone in our freakishness. We long to embark on heroic quests in which the very qualities society deems "wrong" about us -- a love of math and science for example -- become tools for positive transformation and change.

This is what the book "A Wrinkle in Time" did for generations of white girls, and some black girls, who loved the book and now want to share the same sense of awe and recognition they felt when reading the book with their children and grandchildren.

Black girls of a certain age who liked speculative fiction had limited choices when searching for inspiration. Some enjoyed L'Engle, and looked to other authors like Octavia Butler or Tananarive Due for inspiration because their novels featured characters who looked and sounded like them. For some black women, the "Wrinkle in Time" movie's appeal may be less about nostalgia and more about its director. DuVernay's bold directorial vision inspires us all.

"I absolutely love Ava DuVernay," said my friend Kimberly Simon as we discussed the importance of the success of giving black children positive role models on- and off-screen. Simon and her husband raised more than $300 to take 32 local foster children to see "Black Panther," and will do the same for "A Wrinkle in Time."

"She is the first African-American woman given the budget (of more than $100 million) to do this," Simon said. "Little girls can see her and say, 'I want to be a director.'"

Regardless of the reasons why we choose to see "A Wrinkle in Time," it is important that we eradicate negative stereotypes of blacks in media. The media images we consume bleed into the public consciousness and seep into our education, housing, health care, and criminal justice systems. We may not be able to march every day. But we can vote at the polling place and with our dollars at the movie theater. The revolution will not only be televised, but it will come with a pair of 3-D glasses.

http://archive.is/oYYrV
 
I get your point about big corporations co-opting "resistance" in their marketing but you'd have to replace "Big Mac" with "Whopper" or a... what's the larger burger at Wendy's called?... "Dave's Double/Triple" since Donald Trump is a known Big Mac fan.

This is something that runner-up brands have been doing in their marketing for a long time.

When the Coke marketing dept operated along the notion that "Coke is what you drink on your front porch, Pepsi is what you drink in your back yard", Pepsi took that and ran with it, marketing themselves as the "street" brand, the rebel challenger etc.

Now, it's apparently being adopted by the top brands also.

Is there a term for this sort of marketing tactic? It's like when oil companies talk about how green and environmentally friendly they are, except here we have movie studies talking about how woke they are. "Go see our movie to stick it to Trump and the cishet white patriarchy!"

Over at TV Tropes it is called "The Man is sticking it to The Man".

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheManIsStickingItToTheMan
 
It makes me sad that these bastards are taking a book I really liked as a child (I ended up reading pretty much everything by L'Engle after I finished with Wrinkle, I liked it that much) and are ruining it with a shitty movie pushing a shitty agenda. I don't care about them casting PoC, I really don't, the whiteness of Meg or any other character didn't have any bearing on the story. But I'd rather they cast PoC because they're good actors and not just as stunt casting for woke points.
 
I guess you missed this.

Beyonce has been a halmark of the resistance for years.

Beyonce is one of the most successful black artists out there. She got there by first being put on pageant stages by her parents since she was five. She was in a successful teen group, and launched an incredibly successful solo career that continues to this day.

She is probably one of the most privileged women in music right now, being worshipped for almost everything that she does. I doubt it would be within her best interest to be truly "resisting" anything that deprives her and her marketing machine of sweet, sweet money.

This is what turned me off of Black Panther, the difference being that Black Panther actually looks fun while this one looks boring as all hell.

Black Panther is just a superhero movie. But people are acting like it's the next Twelve Years a Slave. I am absolutely allergic to this nigh evangelical press and social media machine that makes buying a $15 movie ticket and sitting your ass down to watch a movie into the equivalent of attending a march on Washington. And if you say that it's just a superhero movie then you're called a racist.

The same thing happened with The Last Jedi and it annoys me so much that I actively avoid anything that isn't an art house movie nowadays. At least the woke art house movies have integrity.
 
I sincerely doubt this movie's going to do well. It's probably not going to totally bomb, but it's going to underperform. I more so blame the marketing posters than the smugness of the cast.

Oprah looks like a drag queen who would get laughed out of a party at the Capitol from the Hunger Games.
122099.jpg

I was in New York recently and seeing her and her buddies' nightmarishly made up faces on giant billboards made me cringe.

Speaking of posters, I couldn't help but notice most of the non-English posters put a lot more focus on the white characters -

French (I also saw a French one with the little girl, also a substantially better marketing choice than the drag show Oprah)
a-wrinkle-in-time-french-movie-poster.jpg


Romanian (same image):
a-wrinkle-in-time-romanian-movie-poster.jpg


Spanish, from Argentina:

a-wrinkle-in-time-argentinian-movie-poster.jpg
 
I sincerely doubt this movie's going to do well. It's probably not going to totally bomb, but it's going to underperform. I more so blame the marketing posters than the smugness of the cast.

Oprah looks like a drag queen who would get laughed out of a party at the Capitol from the Hunger Games.
122099.jpg

I was in New York recently and seeing her and her buddies' nightmarishly made up faces on giant billboards made me cringe.

Speaking of posters, I couldn't help but notice most of the non-English posters put a lot more focus on the white characters -

French (I also saw a French one with the little girl, also a substantially better marketing choice than the drag show Oprah)
a-wrinkle-in-time-french-movie-poster.jpg


Romanian (same image):
a-wrinkle-in-time-romanian-movie-poster.jpg


Spanish, from Argentina:

a-wrinkle-in-time-argentinian-movie-poster.jpg

What happened with the non English Black Panther posters? I wonder how they marketed that movie when black people aren't always viewed well in regions such as Asia.
 
If this doesn't scream just how blatantly corporate all of this "political activism" is, then nothing will.

Another lifetime ago, I used to go church on the regular. The one I went to was one of those 90s-infused churches where people sung pop songs parading as hymns, they held up their hands, and all looked like extras from the set of Friends. The reason I eventually left this, and pretty much all organized churches for that matter, is because it was nothing but pandering to the masses, giving them an easy way out instead of being personally responsible. Oh, it's okay if you're a piece of shit the rest of the week, come here, throw us a twenty and confess your sins to yourself while you hum along to the Eagle's "Peaceful, Easy Feeling." Thoughts and prayers everyone!

The reason I bring that bit of digression to this point is because whenever I see articles like this, whenever the corporate talking heads come out to rattle out some hollowed out message, I recognize this as the same empty-headed, placating miasma they expelled at church. It's okay folks, don't worry about the fact that places like Detroit and Baltimore are fucking craters now. Don't worry about trying to concern yourself with real problems. Watch Wrinkle in Time and Black Panther, oh look at how woke you are! Aren't you such a good person! Now say bad things about Trump and sit there on your social news feeds. Remember - don't do anything and continue being fat, boring, and complacent - big corporations like Disney and CNN and Google will make it all better!

I fucking hate this tripe. At least it appears that people weren't interested by Wrinkle's woke-ness and was completely eclipsed by Black Panther, so that's a small bit of consolation.
 
Another lifetime ago, I used to go church on the regular. The one I went to was one of those 90s-infused churches where people sung pop songs parading as hymns, they held up their hands, and all looked like extras from the set of Friends. The reason I eventually left this, and pretty much all organized churches for that matter, is because it was nothing but pandering to the masses, giving them an easy way out instead of being personally responsible. Oh, it's okay if you're a piece of shit the rest of the week, come here, throw us a twenty and confess your sins to yourself while you hum along to the Eagle's "Peaceful, Easy Feeling." Thoughts and prayers everyone!

There's a good word for that:

"Hot Tub Religion"

That is, "religious" activities whose purpose is only to be relaxing and stimulate your senses, instead of reaching your soul. Materialism disguised as worship.

I mean, being responsible for yourself and other people, is often distressing, not something that just makes you feel good.
 
I know I read the book at some point, but have next to no memory of it. Didn't it have some kind of Christian theme buried in it somewhere?
Probably. All I remember from the book is that a bunch of great people from across time, including Jesus, have fought against the book's villain through being great? (I dunno).
 
Because they know they dare not criticize a film with queen resist/change/hope/woke herself, Oprah Winfrey, in it.

When I was in grade school we had to read "Wrinkle" and I was so bored with it. It felt slow moving, predictable, and none of the characters were very interesting or sympathetic; I always thought Meg and her brother were the kind of nerds who deserved to get beat up in school because they were so smug and insufferable. Also, they keep calling their space warp they use to travel a 'tesseract', and when they shortened that to 'tesser' I wanted to scream. I don't know, it just bugged me.

Disney seems insufferable too, these days. "Wrinkle" is a STATEMENT movie, not a limp, bland kids adventure. "Zootopia" was a STATEMENT movie, not a lame talking animals fantasy. "Mars Needs Moms" was a crappy movie, not a.. oh. Wait.
Haven't read it, but it sounds to me like a dumber sci-fi chronicles of narnia.
 
Disney seems insufferable too, these days. "Wrinkle" is a STATEMENT movie, not a limp, bland kids adventure. "Zootopia" was a STATEMENT movie, not a lame talking animals fantasy. "Mars Needs Moms" was a crappy movie, not a.. oh. Wait.

At least people want to fuck the animals from Zootopia, almost no one wants to fuck Oprah or Mindy Kaling.

Probably. All I remember from the book is that a bunch of great people from across time, including Jesus, have fought against the book's villain through being great? (I dunno).

Jesus couldn't defeat the darkness? Little black girl better than JESUS!
 
Screen shot 2018-03-11 at 12.11.34 PM.png

Screen shot 2018-03-11 at 12.11.50 PM.png

Screen shot 2018-03-11 at 12.10.36 PM.png

lol

The film was never going to do well simply because A Wrinkle in Time doesn't work with film and it never will (not just because it has Christian themes, but because the symbolic imagery's too surreal to properly portray visually and its slow pacing), but I also knew it was going to flop because of the bullshit "progressive" narrative they were pushing the entire time. You never start off your marketing campaign with "the movie is directed by the first African-American woman director" while revealing all the black-washing in the cast.

Also Oprah is a death knell to every movie she's cast in.
 
I sincerely doubt this movie's going to do well. It's probably not going to totally bomb, but it's going to underperform.

Yeah, pretty much. The early domestic weekend prediction from BoxOfficeMojo has A Wrinkle in Time at #2 with $33 million, below even Disney's own prediction, which was $35 million if I remember correctly, though the official studio predictions are always lowballing it so that, should the movie even just barely meet their undisclosed actual opening weekend expectations, they can claim that it exceeded expectations.

Unless the weekend predictions are way off, the fourth weekend of Black Panther should handily beat the opening weekend of A Wrinkle in Time by roughly $8 million.

EDIT: I started writing that before Kari Kamiya's post was up.
 
How pathetic are black people, that they cannot be expected to act as grown adults like the rest of us unless they are more involved in mass manufactured, Hollywood bulshit?

It's not black people who act like this 99% of the time it's woke white people.
 
The movie failed primarily cause fantasy is completely out of fashion, and people still feel the fantasy facade after all those shitty 'gritty fairytales'/fantasy book movies. The Big Friendly Giant did insanely poorly and it's a Spielberg's, for God's sake. Only ones who did somewhat decently are Hobbit and Wizard of Oz cause of prequel branding. People are all over cyberpunk trash nowadays
 
Back