Culture Watching 'A Wrinkle in Time' is a political act - Supporting Disney movies is a sign of resistance, says CNN

Purchasing a movie ticket has become the latest act of political resistance.

The Black Lives Matter and #MeToo movements, started and inspired by courageous black women, have ushered in cultural sea changes -- including challenging harmful and inaccurate media portrayals of African-Americans. The movie "Black Panther" has provided a rare opportunity to celebrate and savor the success of a story in which black characters' individual choices shape their collective destiny.

"A Wrinkle in Time," directed by Ava DuVernay, opens this weekend. The film is an adaptation of the 1962 book of the same name written by Madeleine L'Engle. A blend of science fiction, fantasy, and young adult coming-of-age narrative, it is the story of Meg Murry, an awkward and brilliant teenage girl, who adventures across space and time to rescue her scientist father, mysteriously gone missing. DuVernay's role as director brings a subtle strain of intersectionality woefully missing from much popular young adult fiction like "The Hunger Games" and the "Twilight" trilogy, in which white girls save the world.

The diverse casting in "A Wrinkle in Time" also takes an important step in normalizing girls and women of color as heroines of our own stories, interested in math and science, and struggling to define ourselves in a world that doesn't always accept us for who we are. The movie presents a vision of female empowerment in which whiteness is no longer the standard.

Unlike "Black Panther," race is not central to the characterization or plot of "A Wrinkle in Time." L'Engle, who authored multiple young adult novels, was white. While her books touch on issues of equality in some ways, race is rarely an explicit theme.

Race is present in this film adaptation because of DuVernay's decision to cast biracial actor Storm Reid as the movie's protagonist. Oprah Winfrey and Mindy Kaling are also cast as two of the fantasy creatures who help Meg and her brother seek their father's freedom.

Representation matters, as Rashad Robinson, executive director of Color of Change (a civil rights advocacy organization formed in 2005 in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina) told me -- especially for children. By going to see films like "Black Panther" and "A Wrinkle in Time," "kids of color get to see themselves as heroes, centered in the story, and as the person to root for," Robinson said.
It remains to be seen whether "A Wrinkle in Time" will experience anything like the same box-office success and emotional resonance with African-American audiences that "Black Panther" has had. Some prognosticators think it's unlikely, but it's possible. As teenagers, we often consume media to affirm we are not alone in our freakishness. We long to embark on heroic quests in which the very qualities society deems "wrong" about us -- a love of math and science for example -- become tools for positive transformation and change.

This is what the book "A Wrinkle in Time" did for generations of white girls, and some black girls, who loved the book and now want to share the same sense of awe and recognition they felt when reading the book with their children and grandchildren.

Black girls of a certain age who liked speculative fiction had limited choices when searching for inspiration. Some enjoyed L'Engle, and looked to other authors like Octavia Butler or Tananarive Due for inspiration because their novels featured characters who looked and sounded like them. For some black women, the "Wrinkle in Time" movie's appeal may be less about nostalgia and more about its director. DuVernay's bold directorial vision inspires us all.

"I absolutely love Ava DuVernay," said my friend Kimberly Simon as we discussed the importance of the success of giving black children positive role models on- and off-screen. Simon and her husband raised more than $300 to take 32 local foster children to see "Black Panther," and will do the same for "A Wrinkle in Time."

"She is the first African-American woman given the budget (of more than $100 million) to do this," Simon said. "Little girls can see her and say, 'I want to be a director.'"

Regardless of the reasons why we choose to see "A Wrinkle in Time," it is important that we eradicate negative stereotypes of blacks in media. The media images we consume bleed into the public consciousness and seep into our education, housing, health care, and criminal justice systems. We may not be able to march every day. But we can vote at the polling place and with our dollars at the movie theater. The revolution will not only be televised, but it will come with a pair of 3-D glasses.

http://archive.is/oYYrV
 
I'm sorry but I hated the book. I hated how much of a bitch everyone was to Meg. Meg was kind of the Shinji of the book, except she wasn't whining so much as acting as the relatively normal person who is wondering what the fuck is going on. "Gotta go here, gotta go there" "Okay I guess if it'll help me save my father". Don't get me started on Charles Wallace the Perfect Wunderkind and how everyone in the family seems to just throw Meg under the bus until they need her to do something, in which case they give her the little attention and praise she needs to dance for them.

Well..I'm salty. From what I've heard, the girl who played Meg was phenomenal but everything else was just a mess and disjointed. Hopefully the actress will get more roles that can help showboat her talents if that's the case.
 
From what I've heard, the girl who played Meg was phenomenal but everything else was just a mess and disjointed. Hopefully the actress will get more roles that can help showboat her talents if that's the case.
She's in the Disney stable for life, or at least early adulthood.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Uncanny Valley
I re-read the book a few months ago- eh, it was alright I guess but I can see why I didn’t end up remembering it too well.

This movie adaptation looks awful though. Isn’t Mrs Whatsit supposed to be a centaur like creature, not a cabbage dragon?
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Uncanny Valley
If Meg and her mom are black, then how will she go on to have a redhead daughter. You know, the one who had a whole book wherein she had to forgive an elderly lesbian for trying to rape her? I kinda doubt they're going to make that one into a movie...
 
If Meg and her mom are black, then how will she go on to have a redhead daughter. You know, the one who had a whole book wherein she had to forgive an elderly lesbian for trying to rape her? I kinda doubt they're going to make that one into a movie...
Because it's fashionable to racebend redheads into african americans (See: Jimmy Olsen, Wally West, Mary Jane Watson, Little Orphan Annie, Hawkgirl, etc)

https://thenerdsofcolor.org/2015/04/01/orange-is-the-new-black-racebending-redheads/ (article is an April Fool's joke, but it really makes you think...)

Also:
http://variety.com/2018/film/news/ava-duvernay-superhero-movie-new-gods-dc-1202725043/

HA HA HA HA HA! I can see it now. "First woman of color to direct back to back $100m+ movies"
 
Last edited:
Black Panther and Wrinkle in Time are mass produced soulless products by the most powerful entertainment company; since Coco was mentioned (contrary to what you think it did super well in Mexico) never forget Disney tried to copyright the words Dia De Los Muertos and important symbols of the festivity like sugar skulls. "POC friendly" my ass.
Corporate Disney is an ass. There is no denying that. They’ve rewritten copywrite countless times for the soul purpose of keeping Mickey Mouse out of Public Domain.
What makes a movie good production wise is the effort put in on the part of the writers, producers, and director. That’s where a lot of the value from a film comes from. The people who work on the film do it because they have the passion to do it. The company is the one who’s in it for the money. It’s a matter of separating the corporation from the people who worked on the movie.
This is also why I despise the meme about “Who Killed Captain Alex” being a better movie solely because the fuck who made it did it for passion. That’s exactly what drives the people who work on movies, while the corporation funding the movie wants the budget they gave the film earned back.
 
I don't remember which Redlettermedia video it is but there's one where they discuss movie budgets and say something like comparing one 100 million dollar movie when you could make 100 individual million dollar movies and make a lot more money back in return on investment.

But for Disney it's about milking all the peripheral income sources. Tie ins, merchandise, t shirts for every dumb member of your family. Disney is great at both feeding off nostalgia and manipulating dumb people. But yeah, Disney is exploiting the "woke" thing to try to get butts in the seats. Watching BP or Wrinkle in Time doesn't make you a Civil Rights activist anymore than watching Captain America makes you a patriot.

As Mark Twain put It- it's easier to fool people than to convince them they've been fooled.
 

Damn.
http://www.wbur.org/artery/2018/03/15/childhood-fantasies-wrinkle-in-time
Ava DuVernay's 'A Wrinkle In Time' Destroyed My Childhood Fantasies, But I'm Still Glad I Saw It

Only difference between the two I'm noting is that this one is real. Also, no colored hair and no obesity, but the author looks otherwise exactly like you'd expect.

The high sheriffs of KF yelled at me the other day for failing to archive something, so here that is: link.
 
I like how this review and its comments show just how "woke" people are about this film.


Screen shot 2018-03-20 at 2.28.01 PM.png
Screen shot 2018-03-20 at 2.28.50 PM.png
Screen shot 2018-03-20 at 2.30.11 PM.png
Screen shot 2018-03-20 at 2.30.34 PM.png


Also they keep bringing up the director was originally going to be involved with Black Panther, but she dropped it to go to A Wrinkle in Time instead. Fucking hell :story:.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Uncanny Valley
YourMovieSucks put out a review of the movie. Gave it a 1/10, said it's the worst movie he's seen all year.


Can anyone tell me if he's ever given any other movie a 1/10? Because I can't for the life of me remember.

He gave the Death Note Netflix movie a 1 on his podcast review with a different YouTuber if I'm remembering correctly.

He really fucking hated that movie. Like, enough to articulately disintegrate that movie on the aforementioned video and on the Pan Pizza podcast while dismantling the crew's lame attempts at defending the movie, essentially reviewing it twice with new things to say each time.

So Yeah, this one must be a real stinker.
 
Back