I've maintained 8 pounds overweight for like 5 years and it bums me out. I have to maintain about 1200 calories a day to lose weight and it seems like every time i start eating normally again I bump back up to exactly 8 pounds over and stay there. I'm a huge believer in calories in and calories out so this makes no sense to me because logically if my normal eating habits cause me to gain weight, I should be slowly ballooning.
Sounds to me like your "eating normally" is probably around 1200 versus what you end up eating when you eat more than that. So you have two choices: get used to eat less, or exercise more while eating what you're eating now
And I totally agree regarding exercise; if I stop doing physical activity for even a few days my mental state just crashes.
Oh yeah every five or six weeks I take a week off and it just kills me
What's "eating normally"? Seems there's an accounting for calories that isn't being done here. Eating normally should be right on your BMR, where you won't gain or lose anything.
No no no. That's just wrong. BMR is the calories you would require
if you laid in bed all day doing absolutely nothing. If you eat at BMR you will lose weight. What she needs to do is eat according to her TDEE, total daily energy expenditure.
TDEE vs BMR
Example: A 20 year old girl, who's 5'0" and weighs 100 pounds
Her BMR is 1,145 cal/day. If she's doing fuck all all day (goes to work in her car, sits all day, comes back home and watches tv then goes to sleep) all day every day, she needs 1,374 calories to maintain. If she had a job in sales or whatever that kept her up on her feet, maintenance would be 1,575 cal/day. If she exercised 3-5 times a week moderately for at least half an hour, maintenance would be around 1,775 cal/day. If it was moderate to intense exercise 5-6 days a week, It'd be around 2,000 cal/day.
Anyone who eats at BMR will lose weight, unless they are in a coma. Might be slow depending on how much weight you need to lose and how active you are, but you will be losing weight if thats what you are eating.
@MakeItRain you probably overestimate how many calories you can eat, and while it's true calories in/calories out is a great system, there are still small variations due to metabolism. If your metabolism is slower, it could be that you need to cut back 100-200 or so calories in order to maintain at the weight you want to reach once you reach it versus what you are eating right now
Even better, though, would be eating what you are eating now but doing more physical activity instead. You will eat "normally" and lose the weight.