I truly dislike the sequel for what it did, and that includes I legitimately liked the concept of the twins if nothing else: both the obvious would-be villain actually being a genuinely good man wanting heroes back after all and his push for them legitimate, and the actual villainess having a decent motivation to protect her brother/said seeming bad guy clearly not excusing her evil. Actually a really good nuance for a superhero film, ya know?
But man, they should have been saved for a much better future sequel plot as we continue to properly build off the first one.
Incredibles 2 has moments but God it was a let down.
I remember being frustrated by the new heroes designs because they look like mutant cereal mascots, instead of the actual humans that supers were originally. Only two or so look remotely normal. Like are you telling me that no one can tell the brick monster and the pigeon man are superheroes?
Screenslaver is a cool villain until Evilyn explains her motivation. Which is pretty fuckin pointless when you remember that supers were already banned for like 15 years. "The world can't rely on heroes!" It already doesn't, and you're making it worse thanks.
The plan at the end was retarded, Evilyn invites a bunch of foreign superheroes and then doesn't brain wash them, just trusts that her gang can take care of them. What if they can't???? Those are superheroes! The set piece also felt so small scale compared to the Omni droid destroying a city, which subtly acts as a family outing for the Parrs, complete with a road trip and a game of catch between Dash and Bob. (brilliant).
Just crashing a yacht into a harbor is way lamer.
There's also the problem of Helen not getting as much of an arc as Bob got in the first movie. Granted she was a pretty complete character in the first movie so they might have just miscalculated making her the star, Dash or Violet would have been more interesting. All she really does is look for the screenslaver, fail, and then try again at the end, it never felt like her character was informing any of her plot beats, she also doesn't have a prior relationship with Evilyne like Bob did with Buddy. It doesn't feel as personal as it did.
I hope for 3 we get a time skip, there is no where for the family to go as they are, something has to change. I wanna see a new story with these characters, cause on its surface Incredibles is about getting older, it's disappointing for a sequel not to advance that theme.