Which Series Will Get Finished First? - A Song of Ice and Fire Vs. Berserk

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Miura probably did have an idea or a script for an ending mapped out.
I guess I was wrong...
https://twitter.com/berserk_project/status/1534023434174627840
1654649765087.png

Still, it looks like one of his assistants was told how he wanted to end the series at least. Question is whether they can pull it off or not and not fuck up the atmosphere of the last chapter.
Jesus H. Christ, Miura died, had a whole year of mourning, announced that his whole goddamn team will continue the story without him and Martin STILL hasn't made a dent.
No matter what happens, I'll always find joy in the fact that Martin and his tale will go down as overrated and unfinished schlock that had a garbage tv ending, while Miura's work (finished or not) goes down as a work of art that ended only because of his death, and on a high note to boot.
 
I'm going to leave Berserk be. I suspect it'll go like Dune did after Herbert died. Well, perhaps less rampant faggotry, but Miura is gone, and Berserk just goes unfinished too.

Martin doesn't seem to care about ASOIAF that much. I don't know what it's like to be a writer in his shoes, so hard to say why he's just not that driven to finish it.
 
I'm going to leave Berserk be. I suspect it'll go like Dune did after Herbert died. Well, perhaps less rampant faggotry, but Miura is gone, and Berserk just goes unfinished too.

Martin doesn't seem to care about ASOIAF that much. I don't know what it's like to be a writer in his shoes, so hard to say why he's just not that driven to finish it.
He’s just not that driven of a writer. His history mostly consisted of writing for the shitty 80’s Twilight Zone and Outer Limits. I’m convinced A Game of Thrones used 100% of his ability to write a story. You can tell he had no ending beyond the first book planned, which resulted in so many characters and plot lines being introduced only to do fuck all in actually developing that he struggles to make anything entertaining, much less coherent.
 
No matter what happens, I'll always find joy in the fact that Martin and his tale will go down as overrated and unfinished schlock that had a garbage tv ending, while Miura's work (finished or not) goes down as a work of art that ended only because of his death, and on a high note to boot.
This is the ultimate win really. Berserk gets to be the legandary unfinished work of a genius AND actually get finished. I mean, the last issue he made is serviceable enough as an ending if they really fuck up the continuation. But Martin? There's no way out. He will die, his work will remain unfinished, everyone will slowly realize that he was full of shit and that his work is overrated and went nowhere, and that'll be that for him. A wet fart in literary history.
 
Martin doesn't seem to care about ASOIAF that much. I don't know what it's like to be a writer in his shoes, so hard to say why he's just not that driven to finish it.
After decades, a story that you once had drive and passion for can grow to become an obligation that you have no fucking clue how you can possibly resolve. The “fun parts” of writing get lost in the boring, technical work of tying all of your loose threads back into a mostly-coherent central narrative. It’s clear that GRRM had an overarching plan for the series, but it’s also clear that whatever that plan was got lost sometime after the third book, so the story he’s trying to finish (…not trying that hard though) isn’t even really what he sought to write in the first place.

Honestly, long-form, serialized storytelling is incredibly difficult. Even in the best of times, the author can simply get bored/tired of writing their story, but nonetheless feel obligated to finish it at the expense of new stories that they may want to write. But really, what incentive does GRRM even have to finish Winds at this point? His franchise is practically dead and he’s pissed away so much goodwill that what few book fans remain have no faith that he’ll put out Winds, much less actually finish the series.

ASOIAF honestly suffers from the same problem fucking Homestuck did. It grew way beyond the original planned scope with too many random and ultimately inconsequential side plots, but what really killed it is the attitude/perception of the creator as this godly figure who was slowly revealing this grand master plan for the story… only for it to be revealed that actually he’s just as lost as the fanbase as to how to satisfyingly tie the numerous and disparate plot threads back into a cohesive ending. So instead of sitting down and just doing it, they put it off and occupy their time with pointless (and ultimately failed) side projects. Except unlike Andrew Hussie, GRRM is old and fat and will likely die before he decides to just shit out whatever ending he can manage.
 
After decades, a story that you once had drive and passion for can grow to become an obligation that you have no fucking clue how you can possibly resolve. The “fun parts” of writing get lost in the boring, technical work of tying all of your loose threads back into a mostly-coherent central narrative. It’s clear that GRRM had an overarching plan for the series, but it’s also clear that whatever that plan was got lost sometime after the third book, so the story he’s trying to finish (…not trying that hard though) isn’t even really what he sought to write in the first place.

Honestly, long-form, serialized storytelling is incredibly difficult. Even in the best of times, the author can simply get bored/tired of writing their story, but nonetheless feel obligated to finish it at the expense of new stories that they may want to write. But really, what incentive does GRRM even have to finish Winds at this point? His franchise is practically dead and he’s pissed away so much goodwill that what few book fans remain have no faith that he’ll put out Winds, much less actually finish the series.

ASOIAF honestly suffers from the same problem fucking Homestuck did. It grew way beyond the original planned scope with too many random and ultimately inconsequential side plots, but what really killed it is the attitude/perception of the creator as this godly figure who was slowly revealing this grand master plan for the story… only for it to be revealed that actually he’s just as lost as the fanbase as to how to satisfyingly tie the numerous and disparate plot threads back into a cohesive ending. So instead of sitting down and just doing it, they put it off and occupy their time with pointless (and ultimately failed) side projects. Except unlike Andrew Hussie, GRRM is old and fat and will likely die before he decides to just shit out whatever ending he can manage.
Maybe he's talked about this, but I don't care enough to look: I'm curious if Martin was not only hungry as a writer for recognition and validation as a fantasy author when he stayed ASOIAF, but also steady income. Now that he has all 3 in spades, he's just apathetic to the series now.

Or maybe the people who want him on this TV stuff are not only writing him fat checks, but kissing his ass too. Compared to the salty OG fans (that actually put his dumb ass on the map and only want their story finished), that's probably a lot more alluring to him presently.
 
Even if what we have may not be what Miura intended, either way, GRRM should eat his heart out!

He will never have a Brandon Sanderson, a Kouji Mori, and a Christopher fucken Tolkien preside over his work!
Remember when clickbait articles and gaggles of fanboys on social media were claiming GRRM was going to be the next Tolkien and surpass him? Pepperidge Farm wishes it could forget.
 
Berserk at least appears to be continuing partly out of a sense of love and goodwill from the people who knew Miura personally. If fatass George dropped dead tomorrow, I have no doubt the only hacks who'd finish the rest of the shitshow would finish it purely out of the need for Western gimmebucks and member-berries.
 
I kinda get it old man wants to enjoy his remaining days. But you would think that fact how bad ending of Show was he would have atleast some motivation to give his lifes work proper ending.
I have to admit it was entertaining to watch it live go from one of most hyped up shows to being forgotten week after last episode.
 
Back
Top Bottom