The Holocaust Thread - The Great Debate Between Affirmers, Revisionists and Deniers

I'm just going to copypasta the whole thing about Treblinka from a fellow friend and denier named Scott:

____________________​

The Question: Does anyone have a good answer for the charge that when the Nazis left Treblinka , they didn't just blow up the buildings; they bulldozed everything and ordered a farmhouse and trees built on top?

The Answer: It's basically B.S. that these camps were razed, as David Cole and Holohoaxers argue.

Remember that these camps were not built to last. Typically, if infrastructure wasn't torched when abandoned by the military, locals scavenged building materials, land, etc.

Treblinka had two small camps, one on each side of a gravel quarry, the pit of which still exists today.

At the older small camp, usually called Treblinka I, you can still find the building foundations where the penal workers lived, who worked the gravel quarry.

bigpit.jpg
plan_obozu_en.jpg
Treblinka II was another small camp on the other side of the quarry, closer to the rail spur. There wasn't much there at all. Just a few buildings, an armory, and a kennel, which was called the Zoo, because there were also some local wild animals, like a fox, kept there.

There was a water well at TII, which is supposed to be near where the alleged gas-chambers were and the burning pyres and mass grave. This doesn't make a lot of sense since the well water would be contaminated and useless. The water table is fairly high there because the Bug River is not that far away.

Near TII and the quarry, there are some photos from Commandant Kurt Franz's wartime photo album, which shows Menck & Hambrock power shovels, i.e., dragline excavators, working on loading piles of gravel. They are not digging mass-graves, and according to construction experts in various RODOH discussions, this is not the right type of equipment for that kind of purpose anyway.

Bagger_von_Menck_&_Hambrock_1937_gebaut,.jpg

All remote camps like this have a burn pile and trash pit someplace, but the TII site has no vaunted mass grave. The very limited archaeology of the site that is allowed by Jews curiously has not found any such thing, which tells you what you need to know.

If there really was a mass-grave at Treblinka or the Reinhardt Camps, they would have studied it to death, and they would never shut up about it.

Contrast this with the Katyn Forest Massacre site which was reported to the Germans in 1943 after they occupied the area during the war and found the bodies of thousands of captured Polish officers shot execution-style in the neck by the NKVD in 1940. The Germans invited forensic experts from enemy and neutral countries to inspect the site and to vouch for the authenticity of the investigation, and otherwise internationally document the massacre.

Although the Soviets blamed the Katyn massacre on the Nazis at the Nuremberg trials, nobody bought it, and the U.S. Senate even did their own Cold War investigation during the McCarthyite era.

Unlike with the Katyn affair, no kind of Nazi massacre site has ever been found, let alone has there ever been a serious forensic investigation of alleged Nazi crime-sites.

My guess is that if forensic archaeology was ever done comprehensively at Treblinka, they would not find many graves, but they might find something like a trash pit. When Jews were conscripted for forced-labor during the war, it is possible that their confiscated baggage and other junk was sent to be sorted for recycling -- and much of it simply burned as useless trash.

There was likely some delousing/disinfection/fumigation done at Treblinka or nearby environs because the earliest Treblinka atrocity stories claim that internees were (not gassed) but being STEAMED to death like lobsters.

Well, steam pressure disinfection is one of the methods used for treating goods, clothing, baggage -- along with the delousing of people -- at border-control points. All modern armies did this in the field, and railway Cordons Sanitaire were created by the Germans and others during World War I, and afterwards by the victorious Allied powers in Poland and the Balkans. Millions of Russians died from a typhus epidemic during this time.

The typhus fever pathogen is spread from infected Jews to others via the feces of the Body (i.e., clothing) Louse. But for the most part, Western Europe was spared thanks to such decontamination efforts. Zyklon-B and later DDT greatly simplified this disinfection process.

At a border-control point at El Paso, Texas circa 1917, Mexican migrant workers were deloused and their baggage gassed by either steam or Zyklon-B. And these people themselves were forced to be deloused and bathed.


1798509_orig.jpg


A good source on Typhus is the 1935 book by the American bacteriologist Dr. Hans Zinsser called Rats, Lice, and History: the biography of a bacillus. He noted that even New York Jews from Eastern Europe who were not lousy still had a latent (and potentially deadly) form of the typhus pathogen in their bloodstreams called Brill-Zinsser disease.

Add some cramped living conditions including some of these Jews and introduce Clothing Lice as a vector for the typhus pathogen, and you had a deadly epidemic in no time and everyone is at risk. The best (and expensive) vaccines of the day were only marginally effective against this disease.

A milder variant of typhus called Scrub Typhus was extant in Mexico at this time, but the climate of the Southwest of North America was less conducive to exanthematic or epidemic typhus (rampant in Poland, the Balkans, and Russia).

Leftist Reconquistas whine to this day about how rayciss and Genocidal it was for the Gringos to force those dirty Mehicans to delouse and to have their baggage and rail cars fumigated to keep disease out. This is what is meant by a Cordon Sanitaire. In Europe, the practice of disinfection with steam and fumigation with Zyklon-B saved millions of lives. And DDT, introduced on a massive scale in the later part of World War II by the Americans, probably saved millions of lives

I somewhat disagree with many Revisionists that TII was a Durchgangslager or Transit Camp for processing Jewish deportees. We don't know exactly how many actually set foot in these camps that the Hoaxsters claim never left alive. It is possible that the nearby train station at the small town of Treblinka did something like population transfers -- including delousings -- but it just as easily could have been done at some other place like the busy rail junctions at Malkinia-Ostrow, which is barely a road march away from Treblinka. Disinfection stations were typically located strategically to screen two-way soldier and civilian traffic at border-control points.

The three Reinhardt Camps, as they are sometimes called, were built near the old Soviet border in Eastern Poland. They were named after Fritz Reinhardt, a Nazi financial official involved in Customs assets and wartime salvage and recycling.

However, people like the late Israeli spook and Holocaust historian Yitzhak Arad claimed that these camps were "Pure Extermination Camps" (as opposed to concentration camps, Konzentrationslagern with wartime security detainees, or labor camps where people actually worked).

The fact that people incontrovertibly worked at camps like Auschwitz undermines the extermination narrative somewhat. Why kill your labor force? Arad implausibly claims that the Reinhard (sic) Camps (Belzec, Sobibor, and Treblinka) were named from the Christian name of Obergruppenführer Reinhard Heydrich of the security police (assassinated by British and Czech agents in 1942).

Well, we know that Treblinka did have a work camp and a gravel quarry. Treblinka I is where most of the buildings actually were. There may have been some waste disposal and disinfection work done regionally near Treblinka -- or even done at Treblinka II, which was closer to the rail spur at the lower camp than Treblinka I.

Sobibor did work recycling Soviet ammunition for German use, and Belzec was involved in cutting timber. These camps have recently been modified with all kinds of concrete barrier Holocaust kitsch that curiously makes future forensic investigation difficult if not impossible.

At a RODOH discussion thread, a photo was posted from Sobibor of German NCOs relaxing at a cafe -- and low and behold, some of those SS men taking breaks from gassing Jews are actually wearing Customs enforcement service uniforms.

Those tricky Nazis.

🙂
 
Looks like CODOH got hacked and taken down. I wonder if it's anything related to kiwifarms in some way. They didn't have any contact info, but NULL might be up to doing some of their hosting duties.

 
Looks like CODOH got hacked and taken down. I wonder if it's anything related to kiwifarms in some way. They didn't have any contact info, but NULL might be up to doing some of their hosting duties.

Maybe you have received the same email I got from them stating that one of the five trustees is causing major problems with paying bills and demanding an amount of cash to allow this operation to continue. I cannot say for certain but gut instinct tells me that Rudolf is following a similar path as Hunt did. If I am wrong I'll gladly admit it.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Lord Xenu
Maybe you have received the same email I got from them stating that one of the five trustees is causing major problems with paying bills and demanding an amount of cash to allow this operation to continue. I cannot say for certain but gut instinct tells me that Rudolf is following a similar path as Hunt did. If I am wrong I'll gladly admit it.
I just checked it to see if anything new was going on to discover it was down. I don't really follow it regularly.
 
I just checked it to see if anything new was going on to discover it was down. I don't really follow it regularly.
This is the text of an email dated January 20, 2024.
Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust
Dear fellow revisionists, friends, patrons and supporters!

We, the trustees of the Bradley Smith Charitable Trust, aka Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust (CODOH), owe you all an explanation as to what happened, what is going on right now, and what we expect from the near future regarding CODOH and its various operations.

We need to clarify that the current crisis is the result of an INTERNAL dispute. It has apparently nothing to do with outside forces. The reason that all our websites are offline is the simple fact that the servers have been turned off by the hosting company due to unpaid bills in the order of two hundred dollars ($200). Access to the hosting account where payments are managed is currently controlled by one CODOH trustee. Without consulting with CODOH's Board of Trustees, he turned this hosting account from a company account to his personal account by changing the account information to reflect only his personal contact information. He currently refuses access to anyone else. He moreover refuses to update any payment information or pay the outstanding bills himself. He has done the same thing with CODOH's domain name account. He has turned off some domain names, resulting in websites not hosted by CODOH no longer being reachable with those domain names. This trustee demands a payment of three hundred thirty thousand US dollars ($330,000) from the CODOH Trust before giving access to that account, so that the outstanding bills can be paid, and web services restored.

CODOH currently has some four thousand dollars in its bank account, and no other financial assets. Hence, paying $330,000 is impossible. No one can expect that the other trustees step up and pay $330,000. Furthermore, no donation from the personal assets of our generous supporters should be used.

The trustee in question furthermore demands that, for the next 24 years, 3% of all proceeds of the CODOH Trust are paid to him. However, CODOH is a charitable trust whose Declaration of Trust of December 2014 states clearly that "[n]o part of the net earnings of this trust shall inure or be payable to or for the benefit of any private shareholder or individual."

The trustee in question made numerous public or private statements about this ongoing conflict over the past several weeks. None of the other CODOH trustees have signed up to volunteer for this organization in order to engage in infighting and public mud-slinging. We will therefore not respond to any of this trustee's missives. We only remark that anyone willing to engage him should insist on him presenting evidence for his claims. That is what revisionism is ultimately all about: we do not accept claims at face value but demand verifiable evidence. Our private appeals to him to provide such evidence have remained unheeded.

We hope that the trustee in question becomes reasonable, thus allowing a peaceful resolution of this unnecessary conflict and preventing any litigation.

Meanwhile, we regroup and try to reestablish all web services as best and as fast as possible. If you want to be of assistance in this regard, or if you wish to learn more about this conflict, please get in touch using our NEW contact information provided below.

DO NOT USE ANY OTHER ADDRESS!

Sincerely

The other Four of the Five Trustees of the Bradley Smith Charitable Trust
(We do not reveal the names of any of the trustees here for their own protection.)
 
  • Autistic
Reactions: potatoman
Just watched Europa the last battle.

It’s the most autistic shit I’ve ever seen.
 
I've been saying for a while that Jews stopped being gods chosen people when they rejected the teachings of Jesus Christ their saviour.

I think I should go through his teachings and compare them to the major criticisms against Jews. Stuff like “Do to others as you would have them do to you.” in retrospect must be absolutely mind blowing concepts for a people who believe themselves to be perpetually persecuted.
 
I've been saying for a while that Jews stopped being gods chosen people when they rejected the teachings of Jesus Christ their saviour.

I think I should go through his teachings and compare them to the major criticisms against Jews. Stuff like “Do to others as you would have them do to you.” in retrospect must be absolutely mind blowing concepts for a people who believe themselves to be perpetually persecuted.
I think the Jewish behavior is already visible in their oldest writings.


25b.jpg
>Oy gevalt, that wicked Pharaoh was giving us a hard time! We had to work for our living with our own hands – it was literal slavery.
>And as for the price gouging with the food, well, if we hadn't done it, someone else surely would have!
>Moses had to pull a little 'skinwalk' maneuver, blending in as an Egyptian and subverting them. Hey, it was self-defense; they were plotting to holocaust us, so Moses had to do what he had to do.
>Speaking of self-defense, we had to kill their children with blood magic to protect ourselves. It was either that or get wiped out – tough times call for tough measures!
>They hate us just because we're chosen by Yahweh. Why do these dumb goy always have to be so jealous?

>Haman thought he could build this massive gallows and kill us all, but little did he know we were already plotting his downfall.
>Esther played the leading role, pulling off a high-stakes crypto Jew operation by becoming the queen.
>Haman – he really had it out for us just because we're Jewish. Oy vey, we had to subvert Persia and kill him, he was planning to kill us.

>It's all in self defense they goyim are born with seething hate for us, so we have to kill them before they kill us.
 
Are there any good books about why the holocaust is suspect? On all the claims brought up at the Nuremberg trials?
 
Did my own research. Seems like the Holocaust 101-301 books seem good. Found them on archive.org.

>Holocaust 101
Dr. Thomas Dalton - Holocaust: An Introduction

>Holocaust 201
Dr. Thomas Dalton - Debating the Holocaust: A New Look at Both Sides
Dr. Nicholas Kollerstrom - Breaking the Spell: The Holocaust, Myth & Reality

>Holocaust 301
Lectures on the Holocaust
 
Back