MK1 failed because it wasnt conceptually a good idea.
You know when people complain that nothing ever changes and the status quo remains the same? I think MK1 is an example of the other extreme, when you change things too much but not even in engaging ways. The old Sub-Zero is now Scorpion? That isnt as clever as they think it is.
Dont get me started how the plot became very MCU ish with another extremely tiresome dip into multiverse because of fucking course. I dont think I gotta point out the flaws with the narrative, many already did.
I legit think that, for all the fuck ups of MK X, it really was the last worthwhile entry narratively wise, without mentioning that the gameplay was great and didnt feel like they were trying to reinvent the wheel like MK11 and especially MK1 did.
And, of course, there are the guest characters. You know how sad is it to an old school MK fan to see people more excited about what guest characters we will get rather than the actual game? And, god damn it, at least MK X and 11 had sort of a theme with them, if 1 has a theme its "Whats popular right now/characters that should have been in the main game/leftovers we couldnt fit in previous entries". There is a reason why people are making fun of Ghostface being here because, well, WHY is he here? What connecting thread he has with MK or the other guest characters? Doesnt help that most cant ignore that Ghostface wouldnt be able to take on literally anyone from the MK universe and the lore doesnt really even try to explain that he got a buff or something.
There was Chaos Reigns but I heard so much mixed shit about it that its not even worth talking about it, Im just saying that if this DLC ends on a cliffhanger (that would be continued on the second expansion which, opps, aint happening anymore) then anyone thats a fan of this narrative is shit out of luck.
More and more I look back and think that Armaggeddon really should have been the end or at least MK9 should have continued it instead of resetting everything and then do nothing that unique with it.
Street Fighter is winning on the simple basis that its not shitting the bed as badly, especially narratively.
Thanks to Suicide Squad Kill The Justice League WB has no plans for an Injustice 3. KTJL has tainted the DC brand so deeply the Wonder Woman game is on ice and the only thing NRS is allowed to make is a new MK in an effort to drive up profit margins for 2026 or 27.
They still will make it DEI as fuck though, both in development and final product.
I remember how they complained that they were only doing MK and Injustice but now they can only stick with on IP and nothing else.
Also it will be difficult to make an Injustice 3 and just have Batman with a new voice with no explanation