Memory lost to Nick's brain holes and/or something lost in translation during the game of telephone going through Moody could maybe explain two versions contradicting one another, but now with at least three proven contradictions and the possibility of a fourth, giving him the benefit of the doubt is getting silly.
Not to defend Nick, but he has always been bad with details. He hAs played fast a loose with them and timelines when it suits him or he cannot be arsed to check. His chat and fans used to keep him straight on so many things, but left to his own devices, his non-effort is more noticeable.
The only needed consistency in Nick's stories is that of what is convenient to him.
The claim that Nick's story about running into April's new boyfriend has had "
three proven contradictions and the possibility of a fourth" doesn't stand up to scrutiny. The number of "proven contradictions" appears to be at most one, but that may be on the part of a misunderstanding by Melton's Gator in mixing up the dates.
In the most detailed claim directly by Nick yesterday, he says that the traffic light interaction with April's new boyfriend happened in March.
The last time I saw April was at an intersection in town. I'm trying to think when that was, it was in March sometime. And yeah, she was with her boyfriend, and he flipped me off, which, okay, like I guess. I didn't do anything to him, I'll come snuggling.
Talking to Camelot on April 21, Nick described it as happening "the other day", and that prior to that he had not spoken to April since January.
I saw her the other day at a stop light, but I haven't spoken with her or seen her since January, other than just seeing her randomly at a stop light, so I don't know.
The only way you can get to "contradiction" here is by parsing "the other day" in an extremely literal manner inconsistent with Nick's previous uses of the word:
this is just another of those "technically true" Nickisms where normal people understand "the other day" to mean in the last 2-3 days or up to a week ago at most
The problem with this interpretation is that just a week and a half ago Nick used "the other day" to describe the date of his last conversation with CGoody, which could not have happened any later than January 28 unless Nick held a seance. This means Nick's conception of "the other day" goes up to 3+ months at minimum.
This isn't a contradiction.
@elb stated that she heard about the "April boyfriend" story in early April which doesn't contradict this timeline, as this appears to be a matter of days or weeks after Nick is claiming it happened.
It was April, earlier in the month. I’m not comfortable narrowing down more than that, I’m sorry!
That leaves the Discord message from Melton's Gator, Moody, as the only clear contradiction. But if we look at what Moody actually said, it's very muddled:
Based on what Nick told me - he hasn't spoken to her in months. The last time he came close to that was in January where he saw her car at a traffic light and her boyfriend flipped him off.
Moody says that based on his conversations with Nick, that Nick "hasn't spoken to [April] in months" and "the last time he came close" to speaking with April Imholte was in January when the boyfriend traffic light incident happened. But in talking to Camelot on stream, Nick said explicitly and repeatedly that January was the last time he talked to her, which is much more than "coming close" to speaking with her by seeing her in her car.
Without more to go on, it seems much more likely to me that Moody mixed up Nick's manic descriptions of what happened and wrongly applied "January" to the date of the boyfriend incident instead of the date of the last time they spoke.
I agree with this. (I was 100% being a coward and waiting until someone else brought it up.)
I believe that April has a new BF. I believe the middle finger story. Nick just fucked up his dates with whippet-brain.
I agree. This is the kind of claim by Nick that has the air of truth because it's something that doesn't fit his self-image, not something he tends to make up like his "these lesbians tried to pick me up!" story and others.
I can see him lying that he didn't talk to or see April. Lying about April having a new boyfriend seems borderline; I'd have assumed he'd say nothing rather than making up that she moved on and entered into a serious relationship with someone else within a couple months of her leaving the spare house. Lying about April having a new boyfriend who driving around with April and flipped him off when he saw Nick definitely seems odd to make up, because it totally contradicts Nick's narrative about their split being on good terms. It obviously implies April was talking shit about Rekieta to the new boyfriend.
That's what makes all this Spicer-farmer-visit-possible-bodycam-release so interesting. I don't believe April expected all those details to come out at Hackamania. Also, she has the least to lose and most to gain by having the bodycam released and pocketing the cash.
If April actually is in a new and serious relationship, I doubt she much appreciates Nick leaking her extremely detailed, cringe DMs about Nick and Aaron's mutual cuckold fetishes to the public.
bum bum BUM
