- I think Oliver's a bit more useful than Eve (at least preteen years) because (despite very little training, being less than six months old, and only just getting his powers) he still wzs able to land a punch. Plus, he was actually helping out in the Invincible War against multiple Mark variants. Sure, he needed the help of other heroes, but he was able to takedown a weaker variant. Eve was oneshotted by OmniMark, came into the Conquest fight with no plan-all bullshit, and had to literally die to help in anyway. I feel the issue comes back to powerscaling. We never see the main characters train, get stronger, and square off against greater foes. This makes it seem like they stagnate in ability/strength despite months passing by & diminishes the value of future confrontations. Oliver isn't useless, he's underutilized. Honestly, most of thr hero cast is.
- I agree with the "he should be more alien" sentiment. I don't like the infinite text writing style of Kirkman, but I think it would make sense to show Oliver's more Thraxanlike mindset. Like, sure he'll nod along to Mark & Debbie's "killing bad" ideas, but having more scenes with him struggling because it's foreign to him would be good. Him outgrowing his friends (mentally & physically) & dealing with that. I do like him more in the show, but I wouldn't think this would detract from his character type. A theme of nature v nurture where Oliver struggles with his natural inclinations v his loving upbringing (since show-Debbie is more "Mom #2" than "Mother"). I feel this way about Mark, to a lesser degree, too. That would do great in a better written, more character driven show. Shame.
If Kirkman used more than 4% of his brain to "better revamp" Invincible, the show could actually go from mediocre to one of the best of a modern era.