Opinion ‘Borderlands’ review: Cate Blanchett video game disaster is the worst movie of the year - Have we reached terminal GoySlop?

Article
Archive

‘Borderlands’ review: Cate Blanchett video game disaster is the worst movie of the year​

By
Johnny Oleksinski
Published Aug. 8, 2024, 3:47 p.m. ET

Sometimes when a job doesn’t work out, the former employee will omit that short-lived work experience from her resume.

For Cate Blanchett, that erasable gig is the unspeakably terrible new movie “Borderlands.”

If I was the two-time Oscar winner, I’d hire a crack team to work around the clock to scrub all mention of it from the Internet. The film is that embarrassing.

Unfortunately, for the time being, the star of “Tár” and “Blue Jasmine” is stuck as the lead of the worst movie of the year — a grueling, 102-minute endurance test that’s as lifeless as the video game it’s based on.

And Blanchett is not entirely free from blame either. She reads the lines, such as they are, like a TSA agent at the crack of dawn.

The actress has no palpable connection to her ragtag, barely-alive ensemble, including Jamie Lee Curtis (another Oscar winner), Kevin Hart (an almost Oscar host) and funnyman Jack Black.

Not Blanchett’s fault, but she also dons an ugly bright red wig that might have been inspired by Dairy Queen soft-serve.
image-released-lionsgate-shows-left-87132007.jpg

Everything about “Borderlands” is appalling: the acting, writing, direction, design. As the characters trudge through the sand on their hunt for the mysterious Vault, the desperate audience scours the screen for anything to enjoy — or, at the very least, understand. Our search proves fruitless.

A check-cashing Blanchett plays Lilith, a no-nonsense bounty hunter who’s tasked with recovering the lost daughter of Atlas (Edgar Ramírez) on the planet Pandora.

“I’m not a babysitter,” barks Lilith, as off-putting as her movie.

Whereas the Pandora of James Cameron’s “Avatar” took hundreds of millions of dollars to bring to dazzling life, my casual estimate of director Eli Roth’s “Borderlands” budget is about a buck fifty.
image-released-lionsgate-shows-cate-87131475.jpg

Lilith finds the bunny-eared girl named Tiny Tina (Ariana Greenblatt, who I bet misses her “Barbie” press tour right about now), who says, “Miss Lilith, can you grab my badonkadonk?”

A stupid joke, she’s referring to a toy rabbit.

Tiny Tina, crying-baby-on-an-airplane annoying, could be the key to opening the Vault, which contains a vague weapon … I think.

To unearth the lost sort-of treasure, the pair join with Roland (Hart), Dr. Tannis (Curtis), a scientist, a “psycho” named Krieg (Florian Munteanu) and Claptrap the irksome robot (Black), who’s in a competition with Tiny Tina to cause the most movie ticket refunds.

They drive through the desert shooting people like a middling “Mad Max,” only their basic, color-saturated vehicles are more “Thomas the Tank Engine.”
image-released-lionsgate-shows-clockwise-87131487.jpg

Most of the cast is dressed in the cartoon-punk style of Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn, but occasionally you’ll spot a nonchalant extra wearing a plain T-shirt.

What happens in the middle of the movie? Who’s to say?

There are some routine fight sequences and it is revealed that one of the heroes is a clone. Truth be told, I never could figure out what was going on beyond the MacGuffin of seeking the Vault.

The dialogue is cluttered with migraine-triggering video game jargon, and the movie makes no effort to stand on its own, like “Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves” so ably did last year.

There’s hardly any character development or dramatic peaks and valleys in “Borderlands” to hold the viewer’s interest, even for such a brief runtime. And the action is subpar. All we get is Oscar winners debasing themselves.
image-released-lionsgate-shows-left-87132222.jpg
For instance, when the group discovers the actual, physical key to the Vault, Curtis slowly turns her head, eyes wide, mouth agape, in a recognizably Spielbergian manner. But the scene is shot so poorly — without any style — that the actress looks ridiculous.

Some comic relief is provided, though.

When a person was vaporized during the climactic battle, I laughed.
 
Mortal Kombat Annihilation still reigns supreme as the best video game movie.
Is it that recent one and not the one from the 90s? Because I remember hearing it's kinda boring starring some guy instead of Liu Kang or Johnny Cash or Sonya Blade.
 
BL3 is the first game that introduced proper buildcrafting mechanics, each hero has multiple ultimates, overrides and augments now that are meaningfuly unique compared to the barebones from bl2 and TPS that were already outdated by the time they came out and slide also makes movement a lot better and smoother.
Respectfully agree to disagree.

The slide was clunky, awkward, and not very well implemented. The game was correct that it should have better movement than BL2 but for some reason didn't take any lessons from any other shooters that came out in the 7 or so years between games. I thought the augments were neat but not groundbreaking and felt mostly like "pick a passive from a huge list of passives" so your minigun just became Fire minigun (because you have +fire damage somewhere) - which didn't feel very elevated from BL2's same exact thing - there were just more places to do it.

Movement was still mediocre, combat was still not great, the story/RPG parts slowed the game down, they still clung onto the comically unfun drop rate, and basically just have a slightly mangled version of BL2 to show for it.

More than anything else - the thing they should have stolen was Diablo 3's adventure mode instead of Diablo 3's Inferno mode.

Nah it was just shitty writing. Take out "Talk to Lilith " segments in BL3 replace them with random action sequences and add to the interesting curve balls that were just wasted opportunities and the game would have been far greater than it released as. Same thing with the humor BL1 the humor wasn't so forced, 2 upped that but still didn't force out soygoy humor, BL3 they wanted to be funny so bad and force it all the time which made the humor annoying and awful,. The lore was basically non existent, and they added characters to replace older characters which nobody liked.
Remove "Talk to Lilith"? But she's so obviously the main character - why would you want to do anything but hang out with Lillith? Whenever Lilith isn't on screen - the characters should be going "Where's Lilith?"

I was specific in saying it was mean writing. Handsome Jack is a cliche but it came across as a lot of fun. The tapes you find, the calls, the plans and traps - he's an actual fun villain. But the Calypso twins? The joke is just "hey aren't Youtubers and people that watch them stupid" and while yes - it isn't a comedy well you can draw from for 30+ hours. There isn't really even a joke there - just a mean spirited observation.

The Borderlands 2 cast may as well not exist (and for the most part, they don't) which is a shame if you liked any of them and thought that Borderlands 3 would be their time to shine (because the BL1 cast were the main characters in Borderlands 2, also).
 
I want to know whose idea it was to give Eli Roth a career. The dude's made 95% shit. He and Kevin Smith are absolute 1-hit wonders that somehow keep going.

ETA and I still can't believe the Minecraft movie with Black is still coming, I'm sure that'll do well about 6 years after everyone forgot it too.

And yes, there really has been a problem with post Gen-X acting. Keanu and Leo are about the youngest I can think of with enough star power to carry a movie on their own, and they are sure getting up there. Tom Cruise lasted forever but he's finally starting to look his age and is really one of the last superstars.

About the best young actors in anything lately has been the freaking Star Wars sequels, just think about that. And out of them Oscar Isaac is the only one that really went on to anything else.
As Critical Drinker says, all the young Disney roles are filled with 'planks of wood'. Millie Bobbie Brown has potential still, I guess. But once she turned from kid actor into almost uncanny superbabe, she hasn't done a whole lot.
 
Last edited:
I still don't understand why they casted so many literal grandparents as the protags in this film based on a game franchise that's most popular with people between the ages of 13-30.

Borderlands as a franchise is cut from the same quirky post-millennial wink-at-camera fourth-wall breaking self-aware redditor cloth as Deadpool, but Deadpool & Wolverine didn't recast everyone as a grey-haired septuagenarian, the cast's median age is roughly the same age as their audience's. The same cannot be said for this film.
I think the film makers legit forgot how old these people are. But to be fair the younger generation of actors aren't particularly enduring either.
 
Honestly some of the shit that has come out of the franchise as of late makes Paul W. S Anderson seem like a genius by comparison. Like yeah he didn't stick to the games wholeheartedly, fucked up a lot of things but at least you can kinda tell he tried to understand the characters and just wanted to make a fun movie for people who like the franchise. I can even forgive him for shoehorning his wife into every movie at this point as a character who did not appear in the games. That movie, the Borderlands movie and the Netflix series with Black Wesker seem like they are an example of weaponizing an IP against the people who liked it [cough cough Saints Row reboot] or getting saddled with an IP that you don't care about at all but it's the only way they'll cut a check so you just make your own movie with the same character names and hope nobody notices that it has dick to do with the game.
And the Anderson RE movies had some good casting for the characters, Sienna Guillory as Jill and Kevin Durand as Barry being prime examples. Kelly Hu could have been a excellent pick for Ada even if the time she appeared in the movie series (2012), Kelly would be a bit older than the character she would portray.
 
And yes, there really has been a problem with post Gen-X acting. Keanu and Leo are about the youngest I can think of with enough star power to carry a movie on their own, and they are sure getting up there. Tom Cruise lasted forever but he's finally starting to look his age and is really one of the last superstars.
The youngest that came to mind was actually Chris Helmsworth to me. And even he is 40 years old now.
 
The youngest that came to mind was actually Chris Helmsworth to me. And even he is 40 years old now.
Yeah, I had to look it up even and found:

https://www.yardbarker.com/entertai...rs_working_in_hollywood/s1__38828724#slide_20 and https://www.complex.com/pop-culture/a/jessica-ervin-eickhoff/the-best-actors-in-their-20s

Frankly the only one that I think out of that sad group with much promise is Chalamet.

I don't even think Tom Holland can carry anything cause Uncharted sure didn't go anywhere and I doubt he has many more Spider-Mans left in him. Sydney Sweeny may be good too, but I personally think she's overrated. Ana-Taylor Joy can be good, but with Furiosa completely tanking that's not going to do her any favors either.
 
And yes, there really has been a problem with post Gen-X acting. Keanu and Leo are about the youngest I can think of with enough star power to carry a movie on their own, and they are sure getting up there. Tom Cruise lasted forever but he's finally starting to look his age and is really one of the last superstars.
I was going to say Jon Bernthal but he's 47, balls.
I don't even think Tom Holland can carry anything cause Uncharted sure didn't go anywhere and I doubt he has many more Spider-Mans left in him.
Him and Eddie Redmayne have disgusting faces, I can't stand looking at those two pricks.
 
And the Anderson RE movies had some good casting for the characters, Sienna Guillory as Jill and Kevin Durand as Barry being prime examples. Kelly Hu could have been a excellent pick for Ada even if the time she appeared in the movie series (2012), Kelly would be a bit older than the character she would portray.
Anderson's video game stuff gets way more shit than it deserves.
his MKs were the dumb kung fu Mortal Kombat deserved and it did plenty of HE DID THE THING
his first RE was a pretty solid zombie movie that turned great with the last minute swerve of it was actually happening concurrent with the games and she walks out into the middle of Racoon City straight out of RE2 the game
 
Anderson's video game stuff gets way more shit than it deserves.
his MKs were the dumb kung fu Mortal Kombat deserved and it did plenty of HE DID THE THING
his first RE was a pretty solid zombie movie that turned great with the last minute swerve of it was actually happening concurrent with the games and she walks out into the middle of Racoon City straight out of RE2 the game
He will always get a pass from me for Event Horizon and as you said those other films were dumb fun. The laser scene in RE1 was great and MK had that banger theme.
 
Nah. Marvel's success was 100% some very good casting choices. If Ironman, CA, Thor where cast differently you would have never seen an Avengers movie get made.
Ironman was well cast, CA and Thor could've used a number of actors. Guys like Armie Hammer could've done either role (or maybe gotten Jason Momoa for Thor) since the actors barely had to do anything with it.

Chris Evans practically received a gift from god getting that role as it secured him having a career due to his Marvel fame in spite of being a so-so actor.

If in CA or Thor, Chris Evans or Chris Hemsworth had been as in shape as Hugh Jackman was for X-Men then they would not have had career s today. You cannot say the same about RDJ. Their careers are built upon steroids and CGI, not acting ability or charisma.

Hugh jackman.jpg
 
A bastardization of something that was already painfully unfunny and horribly dated, full of menopausal women playing 20 year olds, did poorly? What a massive shock,

Borderlands 2 is one of the worst written games I've played, and it's really only been recently that people are finally opening up to that. It's mostly full of unfunny jokes, then tries to have deep emotional moments that are entirely undeserved. Let it rot.
 
But who would Civvie 11 roast then?

I'd like to see that too... but nothing seems to get to that greaseball, ever.
He's the DSP of studio owners. A lazy, incompetent slob who somehow survives everything.
No amount of money would convince me this isn't a child molester.
He's had possession of some extremely dubious photos of underage women.
 
Borderlands 2 is one of the worst written games I've played, and it's really only been recently that people are finally opening up to that. It's mostly full of unfunny jokes, then tries to have deep emotional moments that are entirely undeserved. Let it rot.
The only "writing" people liked in BL2 was Handsome Jack. I put writing in quotes because the majority of his lines were ad-libbed by his VA, which chaffed Burch's ass something fierce.
 
Then there was the reboot film that squeezed in the plots from the first two games, race-swapped Jill and Leon (along with destroying their characters), and made the Jill Sandwich line more cringey than it was in the original game.

The biggest head scratcher for me, is that the director is a huge fan of RE.
Something must have gone really wrong in the making of it.
 
Back