- Joined
- Jun 21, 2025
Peaked in terms of popularity for the era. RE4 was a 6 year gap between mainline titles and it was appearing on a generation or 2 more advance hardware. That is a big gap and a huge step up from the PS1.I was joking about the journo thing, but survival peaked at RE2? ...Are you sure about that?
If you ask my favorite survival horror game? That's one thing. Probably Demento/Haunting Ground. But if you asked me what is peak Survival Horror? That's going to change my answers entirely.
Take Resident Evil or Silent Hill as examples. Both games saw their 4th installments be huge leaps in combat quality and mechanical competency over their previous games. And while RE4 might be my favorite RE, SH4 is certainly not my favorite Silent Hill. SH1 is my favorite, but just by most measures, Silent Hill 4 is the most realized.
As iconic as the Police Station in RE2 is, I would struggle to sell it as the peak of the genre to myself. It's the start of the genre being coherent. Before RE2 you had what? An RE1 that probably would've been forgotten on it's own? Alone in the Dark and Clocktower? Sweet Home? The genre barely had gotten started.
You don't like Fatal Frame 2, or Siren? Signalis? (Honestly a fuckin incredibly game, one of the best Survival Horrors just on gameplay alone. In fact if someone wanted to argue that it's technically superior to a lot of these older games, that's not an unreasonable argument.)
Lumping all of it into survival horror makes it a mess to discuss. When I say survival horror in this context I mean the pre rendered, 3d character models. Stretching to Silent Hill and Code V. Not the action games we saw on later machines. RE4 is not the same genre as RE3. Like RE7 isn't the same either. One of the complaints I'm seeing about 9 is it can't pick a genre.
Many of the survivel horror classics you list weren't on people's radars. Clocktower, sweet home and Siren were barely paid attention to. They're retcons brought on by more exposure through youtubers.