- Joined
- Sep 20, 2019
The sad thing is you don’t have to."TO BE FAIR, YOU HAVE TO HAVE A REALLY HIGH IQ TO UNDERSTAND A SHOW ABOUT A FAT LITTLE BOY AND HIS LESBIAN ROCK MOMS"
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The sad thing is you don’t have to."TO BE FAIR, YOU HAVE TO HAVE A REALLY HIGH IQ TO UNDERSTAND A SHOW ABOUT A FAT LITTLE BOY AND HIS LESBIAN ROCK MOMS"
Every award for this. Keep on rolling, let's compare love interests.Actually, just while I'm on a roll shilling ATLA, the comparisons between protagonists are actually pretty hilarious.
Both Aang and Steven are high-powered pacifists in nature and are shown to be extremely compassionate and not eager to fight. Except Aang realizes that sometimes you can't deal with evil people by making a bunch of pretty speeches and there will come a time when you need to fight. You don't have to kill or maim someone but you need to match physical strength with physical strength. It's not done out of love for fighting or bullshit toxic masculinity or whatever the fuck tumblr says to keep men from acting like men. It's done out of a sense of protecting loved ones and taking on destructive forces that refuse to listen to reason.
Compare this to Steven's plight where he barely ever has to get physical, said fighting either being extremely brief or presented as destructive and harmful to himself and others, and he gets away with stopping eons of war by whining about love and throwing out sappy one-liners. And here we are in the very last crop of episodes and Steven is spiraling out of control instead of recognizing his responsibilities, braving through the emotional burden without making it about him, taking charge of the security of the world, or ultimately having the maturity to not collapse under pressure. In Season 3 of ATLA, Aang was nervous af about his ability to beat the Fire Lord and there were even times when he doubted himself. But he didn't outright self-destruct under the stress like Steven currently is. And he recognized that he could still be compassionate while still physically fighting for what's right.
And I get that SU is a different kind of show with a different kind of message but sometimes, fighting and mercy go hand in hand in order to protect what you love. Sometimes, it's okay to fight, especially when you know that you don't have to be brutal or malicious about it. It's about being an adult and standing up for others and what you believe in. It's okay to show mercy as well--as long as you know that sometimes there will come times when you can't talk your way out of a major threat. Aang demonstrated that far better than Steven ever will and that's ultimately why this show is a complete shitshow in terms of its themes and character development.
The sad thing is you don’t have to.
lol steven was never and never will be screwed because doing that with a girl is rape to the nth degree that's why she was written outNo wonder Steven is losing his shit right now, Katara cooled Aang down when he went Avatar Mode but Steven may just be SCREWED.
Awesome, someone recognized it!How does someone who has Randy Feltface
Every award for this. Keep on rolling, let's compare love interests.
Katara and Connie are both girls who had no friends and got tangled in the destinys of magic boys. Both of them started from the bottom and got to become good fighters through their journeys. The difference? When Katara and Aang had an issue, they talked to each other and moved on. Connie and Steven kept struggling on their own before finally talking to each other. Even THEN they still went back on their bullshit of feeling like they need to fight things without each other only to realize they can't do that and do stuff together. They did this FOUR TIMES! And then Connie just gets written off of SUFuture. No wonder Steven is losing his shit right now, Katara cooled Aang down when he went Avatar Mode but Steven may just be SCREWED. We'll see.
The worst part is that she was written out explicitly to give Steven more angst. If she was there from the start and talked things through with Steven, Future wouldn’t need to exist. How much do you want to bet they’re going to rehash the lesson a fifth time?And then Connie just gets written off of SUFuture.
The funny thing is Future would introduce two villains who wouldn’t be redeemed...with Aquamarine and Eyeball. Two villains who are barely a threat and are treated like a joke for most of the episode. Greg even blatantly says they’re beyond redemption. So the genocidal tyrants are redeemed and are working alongside the hero but the Team Rocket duo are somehow completely irredeemable. I swear, the show sometimes has this weird morality where being mean or a jerk is tantamount to being Satan.I'll expand on what I said with villains.
Fire Lord Ozai might not be the most complex villain out there but he IS a credible threat and remains so throughout the series. Aang realizes that he can't simply talk his way out of dealing with him and will have to physically fight him. But even then, even when Ozai is shown to be an irredeemable bastard, a monster, and an overall terrible father, Aang values the sanctity of life and spares him. Now this could draw comparison to Steven forgiving villains that did horrible genocidal things, but where the line blurs is the fact that Ozai gets his just rewards by being locked the fuck up. He's not given a pat on the back and told that it's FINE as long as he says sowwy. He's a threat, a villain to the core, and ultimately an obstacle for Aang to prove his growth as a character while still retaining his sense of mercy. Him being the Big Bad serves a narrative purpose in regards to how it impacts both Aang and Zuko's development. Compare this to literally every last villain of the week Steven come across, befriends, and immediately lets off the hook.
Let's talk about Azula because GOD do I love Azula. A villain and a threat just like Ozai but unlike him, she has some solid complexity and psychology behind her ruthless behavior--that of a girl molded into a weapon by her father and longing for the attention she never received from her mother. You could write solid research papers about why Azula is the way she is and how it correlates to real life unstable behaviors caused by broken, abusive families. The show doesn't let Azula off the hook for the horrible things she's done but it also leaves room for a great amount of sympathy towards her--her defeat at the hands of Zuko and Katara is not framed as a triumphant moment but that of a tragic one, watching her unravel for the first time and show herself for what she truly is, a 14 year old girl driven insane by ambition, solitude, and shitty parenting. It's fascinating.
Out of all of SU's villains, Spinel comes the closest to being the most layered. That said, she's still redeemed at the end of the film with a simple pep-talk. Granted, she acknowledges that she still will have to work on her bad behavior and Steven had to be a bit more firm with her but she still is essentially redeemed without going through the weighty motions to make it feasible. I really like Spinel, but she's still rushed. She hurts a bunch of people and is then rewarded with a loving family at the end. It was a sweet moment but it's still pretty unearned.
The Diamonds are even worse. Decades of war and genocide and it's all good because UWU THEY LOST PINK THEY WERE GRIEVING UWU. Or because White Diamond got flustered and it immediately ruins her creepy threatening vibes. Now here they are playing Steven's hapless estranged aunts and everything in Gem world is A-OK. All because Steven made a speech about warm fuzzies and hugged himself or some nonsense.
I'm not saying villains need to ALWAYS stay threatening or irredeemable. I would LOVE to watch a character like Azula go through a redemption arc just to see how they could take something so pitifully broken and turn it towards the light. But there has to be a journey and it has to feel EARNED. There has to be an atonement of sins. The Diamonds or Jasper, or whoever the fuck is never goes through any of that. They're given a lecture and then put out into the world as if none of the bloodshed meant anything.
The funny thing is Future would introduce two villains who wouldn’t be redeemed...with Aquamarine and Eyeball. Two villains who are barely a threat and are treated like a joke for most of the episode. Greg even blatantly says they’re beyond redemption. So the genocidal tyrants are redeemed and are working alongside the hero but the Team Rocket duo are somehow completely irredeemable. I swear, the show sometimes has this weird morality where being mean or a jerk is tantamount to being Satan.
I'm not saying villains need to ALWAYS stay threatening or irredeemable. I would LOVE to watch a character like Azula go through a redemption arc just to see how they could take something so pitifully broken and turn it towards the light. But there has to be a journey and it has to feel EARNED. There has to be an atonement of sins. The Diamonds or Jasper, or whoever the fuck is never goes through any of that. They're given a lecture and then put out into the world as if none of the bloodshed meant anything.
The funny thing is Future would introduce two villains who wouldn’t be redeemed...with Aquamarine and Eyeball. Two villains who are barely a threat and are treated like a joke for most of the episode. Greg even blatantly says they’re beyond redemption. So the genocidal tyrants are redeemed and are working alongside the hero but the Team Rocket duo are somehow completely irredeemable. I swear, the show sometimes has this weird morality where being mean or a jerk is tantamount to being Satan.
Great posts!
I just would like to add something. It's not just that SU forgives it's villains easily, but who is deserving of that easy forgiveness.
There are actually two characters that Steven Universe does treat like irredeemable jerks that receive nothing but contempt from Steven and even the lovable Greg. And I'm not talking about Aquamarine and Ruby as they are treated as a joke, more like silly and stubborn children, instead of the millennia-old gems they actually are (funny you mentoned them in the middle of me writting this).
I am talking about Marty and Kevin.
Martin is a character that Steven doesn't ever try to redeem, and who Greg even says was so bad he is dead to him. Kevin was someone both Connie and Steven outright said they hated. Were they jerks? Sure. But they never went as far as the diamonds did or any gem villain for that matter. Heck, even the lovable Peridot tried to outright murder Steven the first time she saw him.
Marty is just a greedy asshole, and Kevin was a clingy asshole that one time and he is actually pretty tame compared to many teenagers his age all things considered.
To be fair, Kevin was at his mos sympathetic his last appearance, but still, the point stands. Why are these 2 considered irredeemable jerks, while literal murderers, and genocidal dictators, get a free pass? Easy they aren't cool gems with magical powers.
Sugar and crew were obviously doing the shonen thing like Dragon Ball that all the villains eventually become regular characters that befriend the hero. Dragon Ball is famous for this, pretty much most of the main characters were villains at some point.
Except Steven Universe doesn't make it believable.
Zuko became a hero, but there was a journey and even a betrayal, and a change of heart for it to happen. Steven Universe just redeems it's villains easily because it loves the cool factor of having villains turn allies, without doing any of the leg work for it to happen.
And if you aren't a gem? ...well just ask Marty and Kevin. You might as well be Hitler, because nobody is going to care about your feelings or something.
Hell, Lapis straight up tried to kill both Steven and Connie but Steven never held a grudge. Kevin made them uncomfortable and Steven hates the fuck out of him. Everything said here is 10x worse with the fanbase.Great posts!
I just would like to add something. It's not just that SU forgives it's villains easily, but who is deserving of that easy forgiveness.
There are actually two characters that Steven Universe does treat like irredeemable jerks that receive nothing but contempt from Steven and even the lovable Greg. And I'm not talking about Aquamarine and Ruby as they are treated as a joke, more like silly and stubborn children, instead of the millennia-old gems they actually are (funny you mentoned them in the middle of me writting this).
I am talking about Marty and Kevin.
Martin is a character that Steven doesn't ever try to redeem, and who Greg even says was so bad he is dead to him. Kevin was someone both Connie and Steven outright said they hated. Were they jerks? Sure. But they never went as far as the diamonds did or any gem villain for that matter. Heck, even the lovable Peridot tried to outright murder Steven the first time she saw him.
Marty is just a greedy asshole, and Kevin was a clingy asshole that one time and he is actually pretty tame compared to many teenagers his age all things considered.
To be fair, Kevin was at his mos sympathetic his last appearance, but still, the point stands. Why are these 2 considered irredeemable jerks, while literal murderers, and genocidal dictators, get a free pass? Easy they aren't cool gems with magical powers.
Sugar and crew were obviously doing the shonen thing like Dragon Ball, that is, all the villains eventually become regular characters that befriend the hero. Dragon Ball is famous for this, pretty much most of the main characters were villains at some point.
Except Steven Universe doesn't make it believable.
Zuko became a hero, but there was a journey and even a betrayal, and a change of heart for it to happen. Steven Universe just redeems it's villains easily because it loves the cool factor of having villains turn allies, without doing any of the leg work for it to happen.
And if you aren't a gem? ...well just ask Marty and Kevin. You might as well be Hitler, because nobody is going to care about your feelings or something.
No, not really. The show is simple the core premise is that understanding and friendship are more powerful than straight up strength.I fond there are two kinds of people, the ones who love Steven Universe and the ones that don’t get it.
Like I said.No, not really. The show is simple the core premise is that understanding and friendship are more powerful than straight up strength.
However Sugar is a complete fuck up and manages to mangle that message completely through awful writing and one of the worst plot twists in western animation. Stephen Universe was a passable show, and generally okay up until the Pink Diamond = Rose reveal. Anyone who tries to defend it as "Good" after that horseshit has no taste.
Not really. You were just praising the show and getting all autistic over other people not praising it with you.Like I said.
The worst part is that she was written out explicitly to give Steven more angst. If she was there from the start and talked things through with Steven, Future wouldn’t need to exist. How much do you want to bet they’re going to rehash the lesson a fifth time?
Not to mention her continual inability to not fuck around with what her writers have done. When Yellow Diamond and Blue Diamond first appeared they were absolutely ruthless. Blue Diamond sentenced Garnet to death for being a fusion. Yellow Diamond ordered the complete destruction of Earth. But Rebecca couldn't stand that, she wanted sympathetic villains despite the fact that she doesn't know how to write them for fucking shit. I mean, if these Diamonds WEREN'T already evil pieces of shit, why the fuck would they be colonizing planets that already had sapient species living on them? Humans have been around on this planet for a long time, civilization has existed for 50,000 years. And the gems just show up and decide "Fuck these people, we're taking their planet!" Exactly how is that excusable or forgivable at all?
The Pink Diamond arc was the worst thing ever, largely because even literal window licking tards could see it coming from halfway across the fucking galaxy. It was the most utterly predictable shit ever. And it just made Pink Diamond into one of the worst characters.
I'm not even going to get into some of the character bullshit, like Steven never seeming to actually learn anything. Oh, he learns things, but then tards the fuck out and seems to forget everything he learned by the next episode. Or the way characters don't seem to actually need to learn lessons outside of Steven being a preachy little faggot at them.
That one in particular gets to me. They wanted her to be this morally grey character who had to make hard decisions but was still sympathetic. By the end of the show, she turned out to have abandoned her friend and physically abused her Pearl, with Steven having nothing but disdain for his mother. It actually got to the point that people labelled her “Villain of the Year” and “The True Villain of SU”. How do you fuck up a morally grey character that bad?And it just made Pink Diamond into one of the worst characters.
This goes back to what I was saying about the townies. They claim to be protecting humans but never interact with them that much, again outside of one wedding. What makes this even more bizarre is the whole point of the show is to show “the magic of the mundane” and how humanity is great. Sugar kind of missed the mark on that...For all the crystal gems' boistering about "Earth is precious and worth protecting", they never mention the humans. Just the rock. Figures.
If I was autistic over this show, I wouldn’t need a response notification to remind me the thread exists lolNot really. You were just praising the show and getting all autistic over other people not praising it with you.
It's cuz he's a Straight! White! Male! REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
But in all seriousness, Greg is the only consistently good thing about the show, and the only character other than Spinel with any kind of charm or appeal. The fact that the gems act like assholes to Greg and take him for granted only makes him more appealing.
I fond there are two kinds of people, the ones who love Steven Universe and the ones that don’t get it.
The Pink Diamond arc was the worst thing ever, largely because even literal window licking tards could see it coming from halfway across the fucking galaxy. It was the most utterly predictable shit ever. And it just made Pink Diamond into one of the worst characters.
If I was autistic over this show, I wouldn’t need a response notification to remind me the thread exists lol