SJW Art and Extremes

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.

Why does Tumblr have an obsession with vitiligo?

  • Suicide Girl model and America's Next Top Model contestant have it, spread on Tumblr, that's why.

    Votes: 667 16.2%
  • Stop fucking asking this this question.

    Votes: 479 11.6%
  • I swear to God I will start deleting these posts.

    Votes: 146 3.5%
  • Goddammit.

    Votes: 391 9.5%
  • ACTUALLY IT'S PART OF A DEEP FALSE-FLAG OPERATION TO TURN ALL BLACK PEOPLE WHITE.

    Votes: 2,437 59.2%

  • Total voters
    4,119
I always wonder why people think the kids could be anything other than white. Jade lives on a island, so she would be tanned, but Jade would still be white.
Rose, though...it's obvious. She's described and implied to be a shut-in poetic pale emo. Also, she has blonde hair.
I've never been that into HS, or fully read it, but its clear that the kids are mostly stereotypes of white teens. Even some of the trolls, like Latula or Eridan, have quirks that are obviously hinting that, if they were human, they'd be white.

According to Hussie, he sees the kids as aracial. Which is how Homestuck headcanons got the way they are (and spilled over into other fandoms), tbh. Except that there are a lot of lines in Homestuck that heavily imply/outright state the kids are not dark skinned (trolls referring to them as "pink" and such). Beacuse, you know, when a white dude writes characters without considering their race, what he ends up writing are generally going to be white people whether he did so consciously or not.

I don't get the contradictory tumblr ID politics stance that a member of the predominant racial group in his culture, with the viewpoints and assumptions of a member predominant racial group can write a "POC" character without meaning to. I thought that race was supposed to be a big part of who a person is and white people were meant to not understand what its like to be non-white. But canon and authorial intent are seen more as obstacles in modern fandom spaces these days, so I guess none of this matters.
 
How come tumblr is so revolted by any remotely suggestive art of underage characters... unless they're boys? I've seen people call out drawings of girls in non-suggestive circumstances, just 'cause they were drawn looking younger than in canon (for real) ... but somehow it's okay to draw outright porn of, like, every teenage anime boy ever-- e.g. the entire sports anime fandom, the cat boy from miraculous ladybug, morty from rick and morty, marco from svtfoe (although it's mostly just suggestive pics of him in girl's clothing and it gets a pass for being "trans representation" or whatever)
 
tumblr_o66venfw4q1qe8we7o4_1280.png

Um....
I don't think this is bad but that's probably because I'm biased. I love Jupiter, the art is really good and chicks with muscles are great. I'll take this slightly brown she-hulk Jupiter over pastel goth landwhale any day.
 
According to Hussie, he sees the kids as aracial. Which is how Homestuck headcanons got the way they are (and spilled over into other fandoms), tbh. Except that there are a lot of lines in Homestuck that heavily imply/outright state the kids are not dark skinned (trolls referring to them as "pink" and such). Beacuse, you know, when a white dude writes characters without considering their race, what he ends up writing are generally going to be white people whether he did so consciously or not.
I thought it was the other way around: fanart became increasingly diverse so Hussie, with much input from his very sjw girlfriend at the time, published an official statement that the kids' races are open to interpretation. It read like a calculated PR move, and it worked.

But you can't convince me the man behind Team Special Olympics didn't give a second thought to these cartoon kids' ethnic background beyond "this one's a white rapper, it's funny."
 
I thought it was the other way around: fanart became increasingly diverse so Hussie, with much input from his very sjw girlfriend at the time, published an official statement that the kids' races are open to interpretation. It read like a calculated PR move, and it worked.

But you can't convince me the man behind Team Special Olympics didn't give a second thought to these cartoon kids' ethnic background beyond "this one's a white rapper, it's funny."

Fairly certain if was pre SJ Hussie. Someone asked if Jade was meant to be Asian (on his formspring iirc) and he responded: "i consider the kids a-racial. The only race they obviously definitely arent is black. which is very racist of me.” Too lazy to find the screen cap again, you can find it quoted on multiple call out type tumblr blog posts. I imagine he just hadn't really considered it much and didn't actually care. It believe it was only after the Trickster Mode/Feeling Caucasian shitstorm that it became policy for the kids to remain raceless at all times and it was spun as some sort of socjus thing that it hadn't been initially. Idk, I wasn't in the fandom at the time. Interestingly, the reference to Bro being white was removed at some point, but I believe is back in again.
 
I don't watch okko but i think the artstyle is thrash but why is tumblr complaining only about the FEMALE designs being sexualized?

ok-ko-lets-be-heroes-ss2.jpg
(HOW DO I DRAW FINGERS???)

Every male character in the show has large shoulders/arms and stick legs while the women have wide hips/legs and slim arms, that's it's "thing". You can't say "Oh enid's shirt is showing too much skin" when the guy is also wearing the same thing.
tumblr_inline_oxhzkxT3al1r81v31_540.png


Double standards much?
 
Why tumblr always goes nuts over the ugliest looking cartoons? I'll give Voltron the benefit of the doubt since at least that one has a pretty style.

Maybe most artists are thrash and ripping off SU/OKKO artstyle is easy? I really have no honest idea how can Tumblr defend this shit. I also think Enid complains are fair, she looks awful and could be better, but Tumblr idea of "redesign" is either to make her fat AF or a completely different person.

Awful Enid sjw "redesign" i found on tubmlr (Yes, it's trans)
tumblr_oxp4rvgmQi1vlrpcao2_400.jpg


broken feet :(
 
Do you really need to ask? No one is allowed to look attractive ever because it's somehow unrealistic or something something patriarchy or whatever.
Yeah, it's because of "patriarchal beauty standards". It's all well and good to not make everyone you draw look like a supermodel, but Tumblr artists seem to think you're either that or grossly deformed, there is no in-between.
 
Maybe most artists are thrash and ripping off SU/OKKO artstyle is easy? I really have no honest idea how can Tumblr defend this shit. I also think Enid complains are fair, she looks awful and could be better, but Tumblr idea of "redesign" is either to make her fat AF or a completely different person.

Awful Enid sjw "redesign" i found on tubmlr (Yes, it's trans)
tumblr_oxp4rvgmQi1vlrpcao2_400.jpg


broken feet :(
Did they try to turn her into a Naruto character??
 
Fairly certain if was pre SJ Hussie. Someone asked if Jade was meant to be Asian (on his formspring iirc) and he responded: "i consider the kids a-racial. The only race they obviously definitely arent is black. which is very racist of me.” Too lazy to find the screen cap again, you can find it quoted on multiple call out type tumblr blog posts. I imagine he just hadn't really considered it much and didn't actually care. It believe it was only after the Trickster Mode/Feeling Caucasian shitstorm that it became policy for the kids to remain raceless at all times and it was spun as some sort of socjus thing that it hadn't been initially. Idk, I wasn't in the fandom at the time. Interestingly, the reference to Bro being white was removed at some point, but I believe is back in again.

You're both technically right. Before the fandom became really social-justice-y (during the first updates of Act 6), Hussie coded the kids as white and made jokes that amounted to "it's pretty obvious what they're supposed to be, but think what you want". I recall him joking that Dave isn't a ginger, but that was, y'know, a joke. As for instances in the comic itself, Bro was at one point called a "white rapper", Rose was described as having "skin white like a ghost", and the aliens called human babies "pink" on multiple occasions.

He waffled a lot during Act 6. At one point, he actually went back and bleeped out all of the references to race. Jesus Christ, why was it so controversial to call a blonde, straight-haired Texan white? Anyway, he doubled down on the whole "aracial" thing for a while, be it to pacify the fandom or apparently his girlfriend(?). I know basically zero about his girlfriend/her meddling with the comic, beyond that she made the regrettable decision of getting a SBAHJ tattoo. :lol:

However, about halfway through Act 6 he got fed up with social justice influencing his comic (and or broke up with this SJW lady?) and basically threw up a big middle finger to the SJWs by making a caricature of them and making the tricksters "CAUCASIAN!" Right after that, though, he pussied out and changed it to "PEACHY" because people were calling him a racist.

After that, he slowly started to detach himself from social media. He pretty much never interacts with fans anymore, which is understandable given how autistic they are, but sad given that the comic literally began as a collaboration with fans. Imagine if you wrote a comic as sprawling, bizarre, and existential as that and people focused not on the shit you actually wrote about, but on the one thing you expressly chose not to write about. It's roughly equivalent to people bitching about racial diversity in the Lord of the Rings in terms of pettiness and missing the point.

Guess that's what cognitive dissonance does to you. Like I said before, the only thing that matters to these people is diversity. If Sonichu was more diverse, these speds would probably defend it.
 
If you think about it, all of this redesigning is just fetish and shipping for the yaoitards on tumblr with a progressive front. In yaoi there tends to be a lot of feminine projection onto the males. The boys are feminine and "UwU cute" and never straight, always doing something cute, girly, sexuality/gender or ship related. Yaoi fans tend to hate female characters due to them getting in the way of their ship. I figure that's why the females are made ugly/less intimidating and lesbians. That way neither they (the fan) nor a cute girl (because she is now an ugly lesbian) can stop their ship, and if you complain about it they can deflect criticism and validate it's existence by saying its progressive and that those who don't like their ships and headcanons are sexist and homophobic.

They're just thirsty for gay porn of their favourite characters and feel guilty about it because they don't want to be seen as gross and don't want to be compared to some basement dwelling male who feeds on fandom porn. Because its totally not creepy when they do it.
 
If you think about it, all of this redesigning is just fetish and shipping for the yaoitards on tumblr with a progressive front. In yaoi there tends to be a lot of feminine projection onto the males. The boys are feminine and "UwU cute" and never straight, always doing something cute, girly, sexuality/gender or ship related. Yaoi fans tend to hate female characters due to them getting in the way of their ship. I figure that's why the females are made ugly/less intimidating and lesbians. That way neither they (the fan) nor a cute girl (because she is now an ugly lesbian) can stop their ship, and if you complain about it they can deflect criticism and validate it's existence by saying its progressive and that those who don't like their ships and headcanons are sexist and homophobic.

They're just thirsty for gay porn of their favourite characters and feel guilty about it because they don't want to be seen as gross and don't want to be compared to some basement dwelling male who feeds on fandom porn. Because its totally not creepy when they do it.
Good point, but what about the modern fans desire to make the guys ugly as well?
 
If you think about it, all of this redesigning is just fetish and shipping for the yaoitards on tumblr with a progressive front. In yaoi there tends to be a lot of feminine projection onto the males. The boys are feminine and "UwU cute" and never straight, always doing something cute, girly, sexuality/gender or ship related. Yaoi fans tend to hate female characters due to them getting in the way of their ship. I figure that's why the females are made ugly/less intimidating and lesbians. That way neither they (the fan) nor a cute girl (because she is now an ugly lesbian) can stop their ship, and if you complain about it they can deflect criticism and validate it's existence by saying its progressive and that those who don't like their ships and headcanons are sexist and homophobic.

They're just thirsty for gay porn of their favourite characters and feel guilty about it because they don't want to be seen as gross and don't want to be compared to some basement dwelling male who feeds on fandom porn. Because its totally not creepy when they do it.
Pretty much this, on top of a lot of SJW-isms were really easy to sell to younger fans because of how easy it was to spin into self-validation.

Feel insecure when comparing yourself to the hyper-stylized women in comics/manga/anime? It's not a personal issue that you should seek help with, it's those damn shitlord men who like attractive women who should stop drawing/enjoying such sexy women! You think your favorite yaoi/yuri OTP should be canon? Make long-ass post talking about how your fap material is super ultra important Representation for all those poor gays that should be grateful to you for fighting the good fight for them! Don't like someone else's OTP because it clashes with yours? Clearly that person's a shitlord for shipping something so problematic! Someone makes fun of your Donut Steel self-insert fanfics as being cringey mental masturbation? They just hate the idea of all these STRONK WOMYN expressing their own personal power fantasies!

It's so easy to project SJW rhetoric onto common teen insecurities frequently found in fan bases that it's no wonder that fandoms were the first internet communities that SJWs got their claws into.
 
Last edited:
I don't mind this at all due the fact how good the anatomy is. As well, at all the sailor scouts, I could see Makoto with this body type. Like imagine Usagi with this body type, not good at all.

This drawing reminds small pet peeves of mine when artists draw muscular women, they usually looks actual guys with vagina. Like there is no such thing having muscular body yet maintain feminine look. Dont get me wrong, Not anybody could pull it off. It doesn't help when they are lesbian ones. It basically straight in disguise.

If you think about it, all of this redesigning is just fetish and shipping for the yaoitards on tumblr with a progressive front. In yaoi there tends to be a lot of feminine projection onto the males. The boys are feminine and "UwU cute" and never straight, always doing something cute, girly, sexuality/gender or ship related. Yaoi fans tend to hate female characters due to them getting in the way of their ship. I figure that's why the females are made ugly/less intimidating and lesbians. That way neither they (the fan) nor a cute girl (because she is now an ugly lesbian) can stop their ship, and if you complain about it they can deflect criticism and validate it's existence by saying its progressive and that those who don't like their ships and headcanons are sexist and homophobic.

They're just thirsty for gay porn of their favourite characters and feel guilty about it because they don't want to be seen as gross and don't want to be compared to some basement dwelling male who feeds on fandom porn. Because its totally not creepy when they do it.

Funny yet the most hypocrisy of progressive yaoi fangirl, they called people homophobic and sexist when one, majority women in yaoi are evil bitches(sexist) and two, every chapter of stereotyical yaoi manga features the gay couple to have sex like horny bunny. Bonus it involves rape and Stockholm syndrome involving main couple and make it looks romantic (homophobic). This is why I'm super picky on yaoi manga .

:offtopic: I wondering what is sjw artists' opinion about albinos. They are like whitest of white.
 
Last edited:
Back