Jerry Peet / Lily Orchard / Lily Peet / Valkyrstudios / Bhaalspawn / Tara Callie / "Mod Ebara" - Sociopath writer of pedophile fanfiction and cartoon reviews, faked getting raped to force a divorce, then mobbed and gaslit their ex off Tumblr, satanist neoliberal of the MovieSlob variety, also wants to fuck dogs and/or pokemon

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
102FB2C8-4C02-4D10-8367-AFF97040D3E7.jpeg
more COVID whining.

0441FA44-4F2A-48FC-9B75-7B7CA3DAC9B7.jpeg
Her province is doing well all things considered good on them.
We know Lily wouldn’t take a plane to Rodchester. ( she’d have to fly out of Montreal) She’d go by bus.

0255DBEB-49D1-4595-8E07-245F1F8CEB6A.jpeg

Not to be a Lily and repeat myself but the only reason she can’t travel is bc she’d have to get tested and get a negative result lest she be isolated in a hotel at her own expense.

This is a child’s tantrum personified over not being able to sign some papers.
 
queer is still considered a slur to some lgbt+ people, but the more qidely accepted acronym, lgbtq+ literally has the letter for queer in it. this acronym is just as popular as lgbt/lgbt+.

if she personally doesnt like the word queer, good on her but there are plenty who identify with it, it's literally a gender also, queergender, and some people use it because their identity is something they quite dont have a full grasp of yet or the lables that suit them are either not well known or they have yet to find a lable that suits them, so queer is a good catch all term for any gender, sexuality or romantic identities. Anybody can use the queer tag, from a person who may simply be just Gay+cisgender to someone who might have like 5+ timblr identities, so what, it's an all inclusive word according to the lgbtq+ community.

The general sense is use it as a self identifyer and dont call people who dont like the word queer. all you need is a monkey brain to grasp that consept but i'm guessing lily is as stupid as a brick.
and Lily still says that those who use "Queer" as an identity just hate themselves and promote self-hatred as normal because they are depressed people, which is the worst thing you can say to someone trying to discover their sexual identity in a sea of confusion that is Tumbrl
 
View attachment 1924317
https://archive.md/1znm2
View attachment 1924318
I love how she acts like queer isnt a widespread word used by a majority of LGBT people for many different reasons. In fact I never heard of anyone trying to say queer is a slur/at all bad until I started looking into Lily.

Just like with covid Lily lies to herself and makes up her own reality. Then she gets pissed when someone points out that her fabricated reality is wrong.
The person sending these asks doesn’t even identify as queer personally, they said genderqueer. I don’t know enough about that term but I’m pretty sure telling someone “no, don’t use that term to describe your gender” is transphobic by their standards.

And yes, from what I’ve seen the people who tend to use the word for themselves are trans and/or people of color. So it’s probably also transphobic to tell people not to use the word queer.

Yes, queer is also used in academia. Queer theory. Obviously Lily would not know that because she hates school, has probably taken zero classes on writing or media analysis, and fails at any kind of complex thinking.

But I’ve already said it, Lily doesn’t go outside. I don’t think she interacts with any other trans people outside of Mikaila. Her interactions with other queer people is limited to her carefully collected sycophants. She’s attacked other trans youtubers like Contrapoints.

For someone who’s supposedly trans herself, Lily is incredibly hateful and spiteful to trans people. Maybe if she fetishized them more like she does with lesbians...
 
The person sending these asks doesn’t even identify as queer personally, they said genderqueer. I don’t know enough about that term but I’m pretty sure telling someone “no, don’t use that term to describe your gender” is transphobic by their standards.

And yes, from what I’ve seen the people who tend to use the word for themselves are trans and/or people of color. So it’s probably also transphobic to tell people not to use the word queer.

Yes, queer is also used in academia. Queer theory. Obviously Lily would not know that because she hates school, has probably taken zero classes on writing or media analysis, and fails at any kind of complex thinking.

But I’ve already said it, Lily doesn’t go outside. I don’t think she interacts with any other trans people outside of Mikaila. Her interactions with other queer people is limited to her carefully collected sycophants. She’s attacked other trans youtubers like Contrapoints.

For someone who’s supposedly trans herself, Lily is incredibly hateful and spiteful to trans people. Maybe if she fetishized them more like she does with lesbians...
Can't recall if Ryder's transition into Valithria was actually meant to make Valithria a trans character, or if it was just a ret-con on Lily's end. But other than that, yeah, not a single trans character in any of her writing.

For someone so pro LGBT, the only part she seems to consistently represent is the 'L.' Sure, she did FinnPoe in The Sith Resurgence but it was in a very off-handed, detached kinda way. Like they don't get a 'moment' or anything, it's no better than the lesbians kissing in the background of TRoS.

"We're dating, by the way!" said Finn as he wrapped his arm around Poe's shoulder. "Cool," Aliana said without breaking eye-contact with her beloved Rey "Anyways..."
 
Can't recall if Ryder's transition into Valithria was actually meant to make Valithria a trans character, or if it was just a ret-con on Lily's end. But other than that, yeah, not a single trans
For someone so pro LGBT, the only part she seems to consistently represent is the 'L.' Sure, she did FinnPoe in The Sith Resurgence but it was in a very off-handed, detached kinda way. Like they don't get a 'moment' or anything, it's no better than the lesbians kissing in the background of TRoS.

"We're dating, by the way!" said Finn as he wrapped his arm around Poe's shoulder. "Cool," Aliana said without breaking eye-contact with her beloved Rey "Anyways..."
Yeah wasn’t part of the intent on Sith Resurgence to rewrite so it focused less on the white characters like she says the trilogy did with Kylo Ren? Something better diversity something.

If so, congrats Lily, you sidelined Finn and Poe just as much if not more so than the trilogy. Sidelined two characters who aren’t white and who you wrote to be queer.

Focusing on Rey instead of Kylo Ren isn’t better if the intent is better diversity. Yes, Aliana was put in and is focused on, but she’s quite poorly written. Lily’s admitted to not knowing about stereotypes of black characters in writing and it shows.

It’s a rewrite just to add the lesbians that she loves so much and if she admitted that it’d be fine. But if she’s trying to tote it as better than canon better diversity it’s... not.

I wish I were joking about the better than canon bit too, I found the shill page and wow.
TV Tropes is a mistake.

66972E63-E504-40B3-A299-55ACC0EBA353.jpeg
ACC8432F-994B-4D7A-9BFD-8B3054398FCB.jpeg
 
Yeah wasn’t part of the intent on Sith Resurgence to rewrite so it focused less on the white characters like she says the trilogy did with Kylo Ren? Something better diversity something.

If so, congrats Lily, you sidelined Finn and Poe just as much if not more so than the trilogy. Sidelined two characters who aren’t white and who you wrote to be queer.

Focusing on Rey instead of Kylo Ren isn’t better if the intent is better diversity. Yes, Aliana was put in and is focused on, but she’s quite poorly written. Lily’s admitted to not knowing about stereotypes of black characters in writing and it shows.

It’s a rewrite just to add the lesbians that she loves so much and if she admitted that it’d be fine. But if she’s trying to tote it as better than canon better diversity it’s... not.

I wish I were joking about the better than canon bit too, I found the shill page and wow.
TV Tropes is a mistake.


There's almost no chance that the TvTropes page isn't written by Jerry himself, this language is almost note for note how he wrote his wikis and TvTropes entries.
 
There's almost no chance that the TvTropes page isn't written by Jerry himself, this language is almost note for note how he wrote his wikis and TvTropes entries.

Up to and including using 'derisive' instead of 'divisive'.

EDIT: Also, yes, the entire tenor and word choice is definitely Lily (and she's the only person who refers to herself as 'Orchard' so there's that, too). The YMMV page does include an entry calling out Aliana for having a traumatic backstory yet not actually exhibiting trauma, which then has a counterpoint beneath it-- which is actually contrary to TVTropes formatting (if a trope is applicable, it's applicable, you don't argue and counterpoint tropes on the entry page). Looks like somebody dared to actually contribute to the page and Lily couldn't let it lie.

I'm actually editing specifically for this singular entry on the Trivia page:

  • What Could Have Been: After Rey discovers in Chapter 25 that Aliana previously worked for Niima the Hutt who enslaved her and that Darth Mayrik ran his slaves, possibly including Rey, out to different planets, she was originally going to have a big argument with Aliana after she awoke from her coma, due to her never telling Rey despite promising not to keep any more secrets from her. This would have resulted in Rey almost getting consumed by her anger and very nearly destroying her relationship with Aliana before they make up◊. Lily and Mikaila scrapped the argument idea, however, and it's revealed later in a holorecording that Mayrik despised the idea of trafficking a child and reluctantly delivered Rey to Jakku for the money. In said recording, Mayrik claimed that she would've gladly adopted Rey if she didn't know Niima the Hutt would hunt her and Aliana, coupled with the revelation that Aliana refused to do any slave-running jobs for him when she grew up.

I know this is kind of a personal fixation of mine regarding the story decisions in this stupid fanfic but I am absolutely baffled that Lily can't comprehend that 'trafficked a child slave' is something that you can't just shrug off because 'well she felt bad about it and she only did it because she was getting paid'. Even adding the 'Niima would have hunted her down' part is a farce given (1) how powerful Mayrik is supposed to be and (2) SHE TOOK THE JOB.

Lily, you made a shitty decision that makes your self-insert's mother look like a self-centered shithead. And she should, because having a character who is unrepentant about bad things isn't a problem in an of itself: the issue is when you try and set them up to be perfect and pure and above all wrongdoing and yeah okay so she's a slaver trafficker but it's okay because she had a child to support she's just a single mom doing the best she can!

(Also hilarious that apparently Aliana refusing all slave-running jobs is somehow repentance. Which also implies that Aliana was still running jobs for a slave trader, she just didn't run those particular jobs. Yeah, wow. Moral fucking paragon there.)

Edit the Second: Also just want to emphasize that according to this trivia, the argument wasn't about the fact that Mayrik was a slave runner, it's that Aliana was hiding something from Rey. How self-centered are these characters?

This bit of Terrible Writing Advice is weirdly pertinent.
 
Last edited:
There's almost no chance that the TvTropes page isn't written by Jerry himself, this language is almost note for note how he wrote his wikis and TvTropes entries.
That page was written primarily by a user named "morpmorp" and looking at their edit history morpmorp is 99% likely to be Lily
Edits almost exclusively pages related to Lily, or Lily's interests. And the edits all seem to be Lily's opinions too.
I would've copypasted the list with the links and all, but that apparently went over the character limited for posts.

1613519488210.png

Edit:

Up to and including using 'derisive' instead of 'divisive'.

EDIT: Also, yes, the entire tenor and word choice is definitely Lily (and she's the only person who refers to herself as 'Orchard' so there's that, too). The YMMV page does include an entry calling out Aliana for having a traumatic backstory yet not actually exhibiting trauma, which then has a counterpoint beneath it-- which is actually contrary to TVTropes formatting (if a trope is applicable, it's applicable, you don't argue and counterpoint tropes on the entry page). Looks like somebody dared to actually contribute to the page and Lily couldn't let it lie.

I'm actually editing specifically for this singular entry on the Trivia page:



I know this is kind of a personal fixation of mine regarding the story decisions in this stupid fanfic but I am absolutely baffled that Lily can't comprehend that 'trafficked a child slave' is something that you can't just shrug off because 'well she felt bad about it and she only did it because she was getting paid'. Even adding the 'Niima would have hunted her down' part is a farce given (1) how powerful Mayrik is supposed to be and (2) SHE TOOK THE JOB.

Lily, you made a shitty decision that makes your self-insert's mother look like a self-centered shithead. And she should, because having a character who is unrepentant about bad things isn't a problem in an of itself: the issue is when you try and set them up to be perfect and pure and above all wrongdoing and yeah okay so she's a slaver trafficker but it's okay because she had a child to support she's just a single mom doing the best she can!

(Also hilarious that apparently Aliana refusing all slave-running jobs is somehow repentance. Which also implies that Aliana was still running jobs for a slave trader, she just didn't run those particular jobs. Yeah, wow. Moral fucking paragon there.)

Edit the Second: Also just want to emphasize that according to this trivia, the argument wasn't about the fact that Mayrik was a slave runner, it's that Aliana was hiding something from Rey. How self-centered are these characters?

This bit of Terrible Writing Advice is weirdly pertinent.
Funny how feeling bad about it afterwards, is somehow enough to absolve Mayrik of all responsibility for being a slave trader in Lily's book. I don't remember her giving Starlight Glimmer that same benefit when she felt bad about her villainous actions.

That being said, Rey being a slave is such a massively Informed Attribute, that I'm pretty sure it wasn't even the original intention for her character.
Anakin was acknowledged as being a slave, he had an explosive charge implanted in his body to kill him if tried to run away, and it was overall just a big chunk of what made him fall to the Dark Side.
I don't remember Rey ever being called a slave, she doesn't have a tracker, or an explosive, or anything else preventing her from leaving Jakku, and overall the fact that her parents abandoned her is the only significant thing about her growing up on Jakku for her character, not that grew up as a slave as a result.
 
Last edited:
That page was written primarily by a user named "morpmorp" and looking at their edit history morpmorp is 99% likely to be Lily
Edits almost exclusively pages related to Lily, or Lily's interests. And the edits all seem to be Lily's opinions too.
I would've copypasted the list with the links and all, but that apparently went over the character limited for posts.


Edit:


Funny how feeling bad about it afterwards, is somehow enough to absolve Mayrik of all responsibility for being a slave trader in Lily's book. I don't remember her giving Starlight Glimmer that same benefit when she felt bad about her villainous actions.

That being said, Rey being a slave is such a massively Informed Attribute, that I'm pretty sure it wasn't even the original intention for her character.
Anakin was acknowledged as being a slave, he had an explosive charge implanted in his body to kill him if tried to run away, and it was overall just a big chunk of what made him fall to the Dark Side.
I don't remember Rey ever being called a slave, she doesn't have a tracker, or an explosive, or anything else preventing her from leaving Jakku, and overall the fact that her parents abandoned her is the only significant thing about her growing up on Jakku for her character, not that grew up as a slave as a result.
The username reminds me of a term for art in SU called MeepMorp, so that probably is Lily or someone pretty devoted to her shit opinions.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Haffhart
There's almost no chance that the TvTropes page isn't written by Jerry himself, this language is almost note for note how he wrote his wikis and TvTropes entries.
Bro everything that account has ever edited is either by Jerry or related to something Jerry regularly talks about lmfao

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/el.php?findfor=morpmorp
(You need an account to see this page)

Lily's Pokemadhouse, Sith Resurgence (morpmorp created the pages for both of those) Bob Chipman, Jerry's own page, WoW

Check out some of their edits, they're quite a trip.

Here's a highlight:
1613523074694.png

Bottom to top; totally-not-Jerry removing some unflattering things about Moviebob (the former of which seems to apply to him as well lmfao) and someone putting it back up, unsure why the edit was made in the first place.

Opinion Myopia would be a pretty funny thing to add to Jerry's YMMV page as well. If only it wasn't locked lol

This morpmorp person has done so much editing for Jerry's fanfictions, Jerry's interests, and Jerry himself on TVT that we're left to assume it's either a really, really obsessed fan, or it's Jerry himself.

I close with a really interesting comment in the discussion area of the still-locked YMMV (Your Mileage May Vary, basically a place for people to discuss differences of opinion on certain things or people) section of Jerry's TVT page, incidentally made just today.
1613524274967.png
 
Bro everything that account has ever edited is either by Jerry or related to something Jerry regularly talks about lmfao

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/el.php?findfor=morpmorp
(You need an account to see this page)

Lily's Pokemadhouse, Sith Resurgence (morpmorp created the pages for both of those) Bob Chipman, Jerry's own page, WoW

Check out some of their edits, they're quite a trip.

Here's a highlight:
View attachment 1926125
Bottom to top; totally-not-Jerry removing some unflattering things about Moviebob (the former of which seems to apply to him as well lmfao) and someone putting it back up, unsure why the edit was made in the first place.

Opinion Myopia would be a pretty funny thing to add to Jerry's YMMV page as well. If only it wasn't locked lol

This morpmorp person has done so much editing for Jerry's fanfictions, Jerry's interests, and Jerry himself on TVT that we're left to assume it's either a really, really obsessed fan, or it's Jerry himself.

I close with a really interesting comment in the discussion area of the still-locked YMMV (Your Mileage May Vary, basically a place for people to discuss differences of opinion on certain things or people) section of Jerry's TVT page, incidentally made just today.
View attachment 1926218
Wow, poor Mikail probably has to wait till 3am before they can have Discord sex.
Gotta make sure no one's bad mouthing MovieBob.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SubarashiiRage
Bro everything that account has ever edited is either by Jerry or related to something Jerry regularly talks about lmfao

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/el.php?findfor=morpmorp
(You need an account to see this page)

Lily's Pokemadhouse, Sith Resurgence (morpmorp created the pages for both of those) Bob Chipman, Jerry's own page, WoW

Check out some of their edits, they're quite a trip.

Here's a highlight:
View attachment 1926125
Bottom to top; totally-not-Jerry removing some unflattering things about Moviebob (the former of which seems to apply to him as well lmfao) and someone putting it back up, unsure why the edit was made in the first place.

Opinion Myopia would be a pretty funny thing to add to Jerry's YMMV page as well. If only it wasn't locked lol

This morpmorp person has done so much editing for Jerry's fanfictions, Jerry's interests, and Jerry himself on TVT that we're left to assume it's either a really, really obsessed fan, or it's Jerry himself.

I close with a really interesting comment in the discussion area of the still-locked YMMV (Your Mileage May Vary, basically a place for people to discuss differences of opinion on certain things or people) section of Jerry's TVT page, incidentally made just today.
View attachment 1926218
Yeesh. Sometimes it really hits you, learning how insanely obsessed a lolcow is with their target hobby. Jerry really does not have anything in his life other than whining about children's media. Wake up on the morning, snarkily respond to Tumblr asks. Eat breakfast, delete Discord messages. Go to the bathroom, beg the fucktoy for more fanart. Eat lunch, edit a video. Go to the bathroom again, edit TVtropes. Eat dinner, write a fanfic chapter. Eat dessert, argue on twitter. Then, if there's nothing better to do before bed, read Kiwifarms so you can angrily vaguepost about how wrong they are. Repeat ad nauseum, until you die.
 
Bro everything that account has ever edited is either by Jerry or related to something Jerry regularly talks about lmfao

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/el.php?findfor=morpmorp
(You need an account to see this page)

Lily's Pokemadhouse, Sith Resurgence (morpmorp created the pages for both of those) Bob Chipman, Jerry's own page, WoW

Check out some of their edits, they're quite a trip.

Here's a highlight:
View attachment 1926125
Bottom to top; totally-not-Jerry removing some unflattering things about Moviebob (the former of which seems to apply to him as well lmfao) and someone putting it back up, unsure why the edit was made in the first place.

Opinion Myopia would be a pretty funny thing to add to Jerry's YMMV page as well. If only it wasn't locked lol

This morpmorp person has done so much editing for Jerry's fanfictions, Jerry's interests, and Jerry himself on TVT that we're left to assume it's either a really, really obsessed fan, or it's Jerry himself.

I close with a really interesting comment in the discussion area of the still-locked YMMV (Your Mileage May Vary, basically a place for people to discuss differences of opinion on certain things or people) section of Jerry's TVT page, incidentally made just today.
View attachment 1926218
I like this comment that implies that Lily only changed her political side not because of a change in attitude or ideals but because the other side offers a defense based on victim points that she can exploit more easily than "free-speech"

Lily still hates and vilifies the majority of the Left with the same entitled attitude, only the excuses have changed
then you realize that Lily never cared for either side she just wants to feel superior while calling people names
 
ok i was doing random research into the word queer and if you want pretty solid proof that lgbt+ folk has been using the word for ages as a self identifier in a non slef loathing way.

There was (kinda still is) a genre of music called Queercore. Basically, its an alternative kind of collection of genres but what unites them is that the lyrics talk about alot of gay issues. things like trans people not feeling comfortable in their own bodies, some songs about gay men and aids and so on and so forth. this genre began and was coined in the mid-1980s. you know, the decade that was the most important for lgbt liberation and a road for equal rights for lbgt+ people?

You cant sit here and tell me this group of people were self-deprecative when calling a genre queercore when the whole point of the genre was for artists who happen to be lgbt+ had a creative outlet to release their frustrations, fears and so ons publicly. Alot of artists become really vulnerable when they write lyrics about their personal life experiences, you think they'd deliberately give ammo to hateful people during their most vulnerable time in their life, especially during a decade where lgbt people were at their most vocal from any point in history before? No, i dont fucking think so.

This is just an example of how lily cares not for the history of lgbtq+ people. I know just because you are something doesn't mean you have to know all of its history, but especially with lgbt+ people, they find its really nice to at least have an interest in it, considering how much book burning of queer literature and informative books have been destroyed, or historians deliberately misinterpreting clearly queer relationships and people as 'just good friends' or 'it was a different time period', and actively trying to erase gays out of history, Think Sappho that one poet as the most prevalent example.


sorry if this doesn't fit this thread quite as much as other posts here, but it's an interesting slice of the history behind the word queer and how the lgbt+ community has used it for decades as just another lable like gay, or lesbian or trans... come to think of it gay was used as a slur before same sex attraction men used it so... wouldn't gay teeechnically be a slur in lily's case? nahh its not relevent enough to her contrarian lifestyle
 
then you realize that Lily never cared for either side she just wants to feel superior while calling people names
Yup. You hit the nail directly on the head. I remember back when I would watch his stuff (circa 2015) he did the same sort of things with electronic music (The Living Tombstone was a frequent target of his), this one commentator named Tommy Oliver, even at Black Lives Matter at one point. His general attitude hasn't changed, just to whom he directs it at. He hasn't "grown" or "matured", because he still has that massive victim complex and continues to want to feel superior to people. I guess it's just what justifications work and how he can get the easiest outs of criticism

Anyway here's something mildly interesting I found while browsing morpmorp's TVT edits. I had something I was thinking of saying but I completely forgot about it, so here's this instead. Lol

So in the YMMV section of pokemadhouse, morpmorp previously added and then supplemented this trope named "Designated Hero".
1613536003066.png

1613535919302.png


And a different user comes along and edits that edit-
1613536242931.png

-because they felt it was more "flame bait" than actual critique. Supposing Jerry actually is morpmorp, why am I unsurprised at the possibility that Jerry used an alt account to paint himself in a very unflattering light? lmao

I mean. Obviously it can be used as cover for the very accusation that he edits his own pages, in fact he's outright done this before -
1613536833634.png

(Yes, Jerry is Alchorative, and just like morpmorp, Alchorative created detailed pages related to Jerry, including his main page, the Stockholm page, and failed attempts to give RVI and Valkyr Studios their own pages.)

One final note, the person who made the "flame bait" edit is named rivermint, and they've done quite a bit of editing on Jerry's pages as well. I'll admit it's kind of suspect, but I haven't gone through all their edits, and besides, I wouldn't really say it's a good look for us to continuously and consistently accuse people posting positively about Jerry of being Jerry himself. At the same time though, I haven't seen them edit anything that would directly suggest that it isn't him, like I haven't seen them make edits on things he hates or use opinions he wouldn't normally use, and Jerry's no stranger to using multiple alt accounts at one time or for one purpose.

Rivermint, like Alchorative and morpmorp, also seems to have the habit of doing multiple separate edits to a page within minutes or even seconds of each other instead of one single mass-edit of everything on that page they may find objectionable;
Take note of how consistently close in time each different edit on the same pages are

1613537960994.png

1613538033185.png

1613538254034.png


Rivermint does it at a lower extent though. If they are an alt, then I suppose you can only do it so often. Lol

...but in fairness... I do that with my posts here too lmfao (in fact I'm doing it right now). So don't use that as definitive proof but do keep it in mind, I suppose. Maybe tomorrow I'll remember what I was gonna say originally
 
Last edited:
There was a whole bunch of Aliana asks that got answered and apparently the only reason you can dislike her is because she's a black woman and not because she's a horribly written character
 
  • Informative
Reactions: SubarashiiRage
some cartoon-loving, lily hating sped from Mexico by the look of it.
He claims to be a professional writer.

EF255BBB-22CD-4453-8EC3-6B7B102D3FA7.jpeg
Found this. Might be late or old news but I thought it was interesting that they just have a PDF.
😂
Girl’s from Newfoundland.
 
Last edited:

Aliana gets more backlash because she's a character in a Star Wars fanfic being posted on a well-trafficked fanfiction site. This is hugely different from Madhouse, which is just a Tumblr blog where only the dedicated are really following it, or the Val'kyr, where even people who are fans of Lily don't seem to read her excerpts or wiki about them. And Anevay's stories are posted episodically instead of being continuous, which attracts much less attention (to the point that Lily threatened to stop writing them if she didn't get more attention).

(Also somebody asked if Ryder was supposed to be trans earlier-- just to let you know, originally no, he seemed to be posing as a woman just because all the other Val'kyr were women and he was afraid of how they would treat him if they learned he was man. Then Lily retconned this into explaining that all of Ryder's flashbacks were written with female pronouns to justify that actually she'd always been hinting Ryder was a transwoman. Then she just made him a woman because, according to herself, writing trans-people is hard.)

Regarding the main body of these Asks-- this is something I suspected from her writing tips, but this really verifies it to me that she doesn't understand how writing these different races work. Sure, some people probably use them as 'allegory', but the conception is really backwards here. She seems to be implying that fantasy writers start with a real-world culture and then turn them into something alien or fantastical when in reality most fantasy writers start with the fantastical and then look to the real world (or subconsciously call to mind the real world) for inspiration on how their culture would work.

Because culture isn't related to race, it's related to environment. Almost every decision about how a culture works can be traced back to factors of their environment, even if modern-day cultural tradition is divorced from that necessity. So you look at a race that would work as being really close to nature and you start looking into cultures that practice animism, or you have a race that lives in the desert, so you look into cultures that survive in the desert.

We're humans, so by and large we only have human perspective to work off of. It's just natural to think 'this is what I want this fantasy race to do, let me look at the real world for inspiration'. It can be creatively hobbling, especially when these different types of races have saturated culture so instead of thinking 'I'd like to create a race that lives in and with the trees of this dark forest' people just say FOREST ELVES and start pulling from everything that came before. On the other hand, people that really try to be creative with their races and start working backwards from things like animal adaptation or even abstract theories can wind up making things that are too alien for other people to appreciate.

For instance, there's a VERY bad book called Dragons: Lexicon Triumvirate. It's very bad. But the guy who wrote it really did go all in making it a fantastical world revolving around a lot of theoretical physics (misunderstood, but still) and concepts that would be impossible in reality and it's actually a deeply creative work (but, I must emphasize, extremely bad). But even if the author weren't terrible it would be a hard sell because so much of its fantasy is divorced from reality as we understand it.

There's also a factor that using fantastical forces to communicate mundane ideas helps people actually understand them better. I've had a weird number of people NOT understand what being asexual is like (spoilers: it's like being a normal person but you don't think about sex), but when it's presented through a lens of a different creature it makes the idea abstract enough that somebody can divorce themselves from real-world presumption and understand it better. Because you aren't working with preconceived notions you can empathize different, and even if you still don't Get It in a real-world context it (ironically) no longer seems as alien. This is the point of metaphor on the whole-- taking one concept that might noto be understood and describing it in a way that more people can.

Going a bit all over the place but eh, so was Lily.
 
So I have a bit of a weird question. Does anyone know if Jerry likes or has talked in any capacity about the show Prison Break?

The reason I'm asking is, I was thinking of the name Alchorative and where on earth he could've came up with it. I got the sudden idea that maybe it's an anagram for something? So I did a bit of searching and-
1613541609991.png


It matches perfectly. Hector Avila is a minor character in Prison Break who appears in four episodes across the first two seasons. This could just be a massive coincidence, but Alchorative doesn't really mean anything otherwise, so this was rather interesting.

Well. Anyway. The matter of the origin of "Alchorative" (or any possible other uses anywhere else on the internet) still piqued my curiosity, so I was looking on google for occurrences of the name Alchorative (and the results beyond the first page were like, 90% junk) and stumbled upon this tumblr post, made by one of the Derpibooru mods who was present when Jerry was exposed for sockpuppeting;

And... it is very, very interesting, with information even I wasn't aware of.

So, apparently Jerry had another account on Derpibooru named "rithirak". This was found through his account activity and it had a similar registration address as "TaraCallie" (which I take to mean he used the same browser instance, IP, etc to make the account) and the uploads from that account are, well...
1613542845513.png
So, using that account, Jerry uploaded an image of Celestia (or "Molestia" I guess) bloodily raping Pinkiepony's OC, and then uploaded a pic that was basically saying "April Davis vs Jerry Peet, make it happen!" using that same cartoonish MLP font Jerry always uses.
1613579120063.png

(Most notably look at the H, the A, and the N)

The other thing this page shows is this;
1613543158313.png


Which basically shows that Derpibooru staff can see when a certain account is using an anonymous ("Background Pony") feature, because the name of the account doing it is displayed directly to them.

So, I guess when this happened;
1613543245028.png


The Frowning Pony was able to see something similar to what was in the image The Smiling Pony shared next to all the Background Pony post agreeing with Jerry.

Now... aside from "rithirak", this doesn't really prove anything that we don't already know. We're all already aware that Jerry has used alt accounts to supplement his own arguments, but it's nice to get further proof that he's done it.

I tried to search up rithirak like I did Alchorative but nothing really came up, so it's either some really obscure reference or it's something that he made up. It's not an anagram of anything meaningful, either, like Alchorative might be, so there goes that.
1613543520358.png


Well. I guess sometimes it's fun to dig a bit. Lol
 
Back