RPGnet Forums

Yeah, wmarshal is soon eating that perma. You don't treat your superiors like that! That appeals process is only ever getting you into a worse position than you started with. Even if the infraction is rescinded (it won't be), wmarshal has just earned the enmity of a seething cuck who will make sure to get him scrubbed.

I would almost feel sorry for the guy, but... nah. Anyone who still posts there deserves everything he gets.
 
Again, you didn't get to meet the full both barrels effect when evangelicals get their hands on something they think is demonic. They didn't change names, they confiscated the material and threw it into a fire. Cringe lore changes is still not worse than that.
There is a long list of classic toys I wasn't allowed to play with, even when I visited friends who had them, because Jim Dobson told my mom they were satanic and would corrupt my young mind. I guess the worst thing was having a He-Man toy temporarily confiscated at my birthday (my mom later decided that actually, an alien with bug-out eyes wasn't going to turn me against Christ).

But still, if you look at the actual content generated during that era, it's pretty good. The Playboy drawings are gone from 2e, but you still have some pretty legendary stuff like Planescape and Dark Sun generated during that era.
What is worse than that, is wokescolds seeking to work to start pressuring websites to stop selling previous editions and older games. That's where my opinion is starting to take a sharp turn on which side I consider worse. I can live with retarded lore changes, they can be ignored and my table will play the game we want to play. I will not abide erasing options, however.
Agree, and the content censorship is coming from inside the house now. The Satanic Panic was a freakout about fantasy; wokery is a freakout about reality, which makes it 1000x worse, because it means there are all these touchstones with reality that are being policed right out of D&D. The less contact with reality you're allowed to have for purely ideological reasons, the more your fiction is being driven by ideology rather than what actually makes compelling fiction, the shittier your fiction gets.

Just as a thought exercise, imagine writing a game called The Thirteenth Century. You get to represent pretty much everyone we know much about--Mongolians, Russians, Mayans, Franks, Anglo-Saxons, Shang China, and so on. Your task is to represent things reasonably accurately, not leaving out major features of religion, warfare, political organization, economic structures (including slavery) foreign relations, and so on.

This RPG would get you banned almost everywhere because everything would be problematic. Every depiction of every culture would be deemed racist, sexist, and worse. You'd be labeled a Nazi--the 21st century version of "Satanist"--and driven out of the scene, probably banned from every convention.
 
Just as a thought exercise, imagine writing a game called The Thirteenth Century. You get to represent pretty much everyone we know much about--Mongolians, Russians, Mayans, Franks, Anglo-Saxons, Shang China, and so on. Your task is to represent things reasonably accurately, not leaving out major features of religion, warfare, political organization, economic structures (including slavery) foreign relations, and so on.

This RPG would get you banned almost everywhere because everything would be problematic. Every depiction of every culture would be deemed racist, sexist, and worse. You'd be labeled a Nazi--the 21st century version of "Satanist"--and driven out of the scene, probably banned from every convention.
7215_thonk.png

 
Sokal and Bricmont's book about the Affair was great, but there's an even better one. Check out Peter Boghossian and his team getting a large portion of Mein Kampf republished in a feminist journal by making it about men instead of Jews.
In any conflict between groups, there will be some members of each group that absolutely match the stereotypes that the other groups have for them.

These are never, ever the ones who get punished for their behavior. They mostly see the rest of their own group as ablative armor for whatever shit theyre pulling (which, depressingly, is almost always the same shit regardless of the group)
 
This is on the level of stupidity as "Is chess racist because White goes first?"
It's named after an play that Shakespeare wrote about how unnatural interracial marriage is; of course it's racist, you bigot!

I should know, because we can all trust their mods' infinite sources of wisdom. (Although, in this case, he's halfway right; but he keeps bringing up shit that happened over an century ago.)
 
Last edited:
This RPG would get you banned almost everywhere because everything would be problematic. Every depiction of every culture would be deemed racist, sexist, and worse. You'd be labeled a Nazi--the 21st century version of "Satanist"--and driven out of the scene, probably banned from every convention.
A straight up plain 13th century RPG wouldn't really be my thang unless you added in some twist; like, an alien invasion or zombie outbreak. Still I'd respect anyone who dared to go down that road as long as it wasn't a cringe fest like FATAL.

How can you drive someone out of "the scene" when "the scene" is so insular and cell based by nature? Also, how would they even ban you from a convention? Are they doing table checks to make sure people are playing pick up games from only the approved lists? Room checks? I've done many a pick up game in someone's hotel room, it's amazing what a few TV trays can do for you. True, can't do big scale mini's games, but that's about it.

Meanwhile, on RPGnet: "Is this board game racist, solely because it was named after an Shakespearean play?"
I should know, because we can all trust their mods' infinite sources of wisdom. (Although, in this case, he's halfway right; but he keeps bringing up shit that happened over an century ago.)
I noticed him bitching about HP Lovecraft and cults consisting of nothing but brown people (even though that's patently false in it'self if you bothered to read The Thing on the Doorstep or The Dunwich Horror). I'm surprised that the Tcho-Tcho's got a pass since they're still in the newest CoC and are still Mythos worshippers to a man.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, on RPGnet: "Is this board game racist, solely because it was named after an Shakespearean play?"
Even the fucking replies are more stupidity.
(wikipedia link) According to this, it's a reference to the play, not a coincidence, and probably does specifically reference race with the white and black color scheme. Othello is specifically a variant of Reversi.
And not much of a variant, at that, literally the only difference is the initial setup position and the ability to pass.

Huh. According to Wikipedia, it was invented by a Japanese man, too. I didn't know that.
Not what the Wikipedia link says, the Japanese man who came up with it close to a hundred years after it was definitely confirmed Reversi already existed came up with a variant called Othello then later started claiming he invented it independently.

Othello the play is where the lead is betrayed by second in command and friend. The form of this betrayal is a series of manipulations that cause Othello to betray his love himself.

Othello the board game is about making the pieces betray their original side and become yours.

I wonder what possible connection there could be other racism?
Racism is so pervasive in our society as to be endemic, which makes it worth questioning who benefits from the impulse to deny or dismiss it.
"It must be racism, what other answer could there be?"
 
A straight up plain 13th century RPG wouldn't really be my thang unless you added in some twist; like, an alien invasion or zombie outbreak. Still I'd respect anyone who dared to go down that road as long as it wasn't a cringe fest like FATAL.
Missing the point. Imagine writing an RPG where North American and Sub-Saharan tribes are stuck in the paleolithic, Mongolians are an existential threat to everyone around them, and no, nobody in China has "rights," and no, a woman can't be a Teutonic Knight, and yes, Muslims do go on slave raids, and yes, Meso-American civilization's religion centers on human sacrifice and ritual cannibalism. Add an alien invasion or zombie outbreak, and you will still be vilified as a Nazi.

How can you drive someone out of "the scene" when "the scene" is so insular and cell based by nature? Also, how would they even ban you from a convention?

Plenty of people get banned from GenCon. Jeff Bergen caught a personal, lifetime ban for putting a frog making the OK symbol on a product. And yes, he tried to go anyway and was physically escorted out. If you aren't allowed to show your game at conventions, good luck drumming up any sales. Worst case scenario is you get banned from DTRPG, at which point you might as well not exist.
 
Missing the point. Imagine writing an RPG where North American and Sub-Saharan tribes are stuck in the paleolithic, Mongolians are an existential threat to everyone around them, no, women can't be knights, and no, nobody in China has "rights," and no, a woman can't be a Teutonic Knight, and yes, Muslims and Vikings do go on slave raids, and yes, Meso-American civilization's religion centers on human sacrifice and ritual cannibalism. Add an alien invasion or zombie outbreak, and you will still be vilified as a Nazi.
Yea, and my answer remains the same. I personally would respect someone who tried that and didn't make it a complete bed shitter or poorly disguised coom fest like Venger Satanis. Anyone calling me a Nazi can go piss up a rope.

Plenty of people get banned from GenCon.
So what happens if I sell and/or run my "problematic" game from my hotel room?
If you aren't allowed to show your game at conventions, good luck drumming up any sales.
No big loss. All I gotta do is advertise it here, or on the Chans, or on conservative web spaces and I'll rake in the right wing sympathy bucks.

Hell, if I get Sean Hannity, Metatron, John Doyle, The Quartering, Sargon, Geeks n Gamers, or Archwarhammer to plug my game, I'm set. People will buy my game just to pwn teh libz.
 
😂 We need to question the questioners. RPGNET and Twitter are full of these awful people that usually have the church mouse demeanor of a Heinrich Himmler, and most of his ideas, too.
Imagine being literally angry about a game nobody has played in like 50 years.
 
Back