"Im alone now, in our 'special place', no cap"
Zoomer Hill
The place where the bad ending is the best ending
Silent Hill 4 has always been my favorite to actually play. It doesn't hold up anywhere near as much as the first 3 but I was the perfect age to play through it when it was pretty new and so that game has a special place in my heart. when I went through them all again as an older teenager and then once more as an adult I could see the actual flaws with the game clearly after hearing about them forever, and it made me retroactively more disappointed in what followed it than I had been.
There is nothing worse than returning to a game you really liked as a kid and see its actually kind of mid or even bad.
Not that this is the case for SH4, simply that even fans that grew up with it like us need to adknowledge that it was a step backwards (but still far far better than anything that came afterwards).
I do have a soft spot for Origins, even if I do know it wasnt that great too (but again, still better than modern SH)
The one thing I can gurantee you that they will fuck up is the puzzles. Remember, it's made for "modern audiences" so some fat western tranny dev at bloober will look at something like the clock puzzle and think that it's too hard because TikTok zoomers can't read clocks that aren't digital.
Now imagine if they tried to remake the first game. Said "modern audience" would shit bricks trying to figure out shit like this because you know they would ruin that one too:
View attachment 6110248
Most puzzles in horror games nowadays suck. Either they are too obvious or so absurdly hard that the only way to know was looking into the minds of the devs.
A good puzzle feels rewarding when you figure them out, which are most of classic SH's puzzles.
But then again, we live in the age of "oh a puzzle? Looking up the answer immediately" so fuck you if you think modern gamers want to use their noggings (despite the fact they are playing a horror game with puzzles).
Truly a sad day when the original Silent Hill movie stayed more true to the source material/music than so called remakes.
The older I get, the more I appreciate it for what it is. I hold it along wit the original Mortal Kombat movie where they are at least trying to stick with the source material, which is more than can be said for most.